Proposal: Montreal/Toronto

[mrinsane]

To Montreal: Leo Komarov, Stephane Robidas and 5th round pick 2017

vs

To Toronto: David Desharnais, Mike Condon and Brian Flynn


MTL POV: Leo can play LW and C plus he bring energy on the 3rd or 4th line. He can put some points and hurt the opponent. Robidas will retire next year or maybe this but If he can play 30 games this year, I'd be happy to have him as teacher for Beaulieu.

TOR POV: Leafs are in need for a backup with some experience with a good contract.. Mike Condon could take the net for 30 games or more and Andersen will make the rest of the job. If Lou want to trade for d-man.. Bozak will be on the market.. and adding DD could make a deal easier.. he got one year left at 3.5. Flynn will play as 13th forward or fourth line guy.

Click to read more...

 

[LeafGrief]

Wait, so we give up Komarov for your cap dump, backup goalie, and a 13th F? Robidas has an island so we aren't worried about getting rid of him either.

No freaking way man.

 

[crowi]

I don't see Toronto giving up Komarov for that. He has dem intangibles. Good all-around player.

 

[The Examiner]

To Montreal: Leo Komarov, Stephane Robidas and 5th round pick 2017

vs

To Toronto: David Desharnais, Mike Condon and Brian Flynn


MTL POV: Leo can play LW and C plus he bring energy on the 3rd or 4th line. He can put some points and hurt the opponent. Robidas will retire next year or maybe this but If he can play 30 games this year, I'd be happy to have him as teacher for Beaulieu.

TOR POV: Leafs are in need for a backup with some experience with a good contract.. Mike Condon could take the net for 30 games or more and Andersen will make the rest of the job. If Lou want to trade for d-man.. Bozak will be on the market.. and adding DD could make a deal easier.. he got one year left at 3.5. Flynn will play as 13th forward or fourth line guy.

I wouldn't trade Komarov for all three of those players. I'd want an over-payment for Leo. You can have Robidas and the 5th, though. Actually you can have Robidas for future considerations.

Also, Leo does not play centre. He may take some draws but he is not a centre.

 

[Albus Dumbledore]

leafs politely decline

 

[Stuzchuk]

that is very bad for TOR, plus as per many trade rumour site, apparently they were looking for a low 1st for Komarov last year at the deadline...

 

[SeaOfBlue]

We give up the two most valuable pieces by the Leafs perspective, so no thanks. No room for Desharnais or Flynn at all, and Komarov is worth a lot more than the entire return on his own. We don't need to drop Robidas since he'll just be on the LTIR all year and doesn't cost us any cap or salary (in fact, we may just trade him to a team needing to reach the floor).

Condon is the only one we'd want, but you aren't getting anything valuable for him. If you want Holland, Corrado and a few prospects, and are willing to throw in a mid round pick on top of Condon, then maybe we can talk.

 

[sansabri]

If the Leafs want Condon, they can have him - but we're not taking their cap dumps.

 

[LeafChief]

No thank you.

Komarov holds more value than that and we don't need to move Robidas. We have a nice safe place for him.

 

[Fogelhund]

If the Leafs want Condon, they can have him - but we're not taking their cap dumps.

Komarov is a cap dump now?

 

[Mark Kandy]

Komarov isn't the type of player you trade to the team you hate & play against often!

Oh, and the offer isn't good.

 

[sansabri]

Komarov is a cap dump now?

I was referring to Robidas. Calm down.

 

[iBELEAF]

not even close

 

[Hally BlackWood]

I was referring to Robidas. Calm down.

that's why you said cap dumps and not cap dump right.

 

[sansabri]

that's why you said cap dumps and not cap dump right.

Right. As if Robidas is the only cap dump the Leafs have

Again, you can have Condon if you want him. No cap dumps, though.

 

[leaflover]

The only name in the trade proposal that should interest Toronto is Komarov.

 

[Babcocks Marner]

No. Leo is one of those players that you don't trade. You would have to over pay, and not many would be willing to do so. He is a rare breed for a 2nd/3rd liner.

 

[SeaOfBlue]

Right. As if Robidas is the only cap dump the Leafs have

Again, you can have Condon if you want him. No cap dumps, though.

None of them are in this deal though?

And Robidas is not a cap dump we'd pay assets to dump. We throw him on LTIR for another year, he doesn't hurt us in any way other than wasting a contract spot, and that's it.

 

[CanadienShark]

That's a damn high price for Toronto to pay to be rid of Robidas.

 

[indigobuffalo]

Given Bergevin's trades lately, I think Komarov for Pacioretty is more likely.

And it's also funny that OP thinks Komarov would be 3rd or 4th line material on the Habs...

 

[dream43]

Komarov is better than Desarnais (who has a worse contract)
Robidas can just go on Ltir and do nothing (We have no incentive of giving up assets to move him)
Flinn is a fwd we have no use for. (We have plenty of 13th fwds/ahl playrs)
Condon is meh. No need to give assets just wait for waivers or sign Enroth.

 

[Mad Brills*]

Leafs might sign enroth, so this might not happen.

 

[Advanced stats]

Komarov is the most valuable piece by far. Not even close to enticing for Toronto.

 

[Halla]

leafs laugh at this offer.
desharnais and condon will both be on waivers. they have little to no value. flynn is a spare part forward we dont need. we will keep our physical guy who will likely be a 20/20 player

 

[Halla]

That's a damn high price for Toronto to pay to be rid of Robidas.

yup. for a guy that has a 3 mil hit with one year left and can be LTIR....
leafs are under the cap with only a couple cheap dmen to sign. no need to move anything of value for a collection of junk