NHL Talk Miscellaneous NHL Discussion CIX: Processing a Tremendous Amount of Insane Information

deadhead

Registered User
Feb 26, 2014
51,288
22,338
Oh my bad, I forget PP points don't count as points.

The worst PP team in the league the last ~4 years doesn't want a PP specialist? How badly do you want this team to tank, be honest.
If Briere traded a 2nd rd pick for a PP specialist, would you applaud that move?
Ghost is ancient history, AV and CF are ancient history.
Who gives a F at this point?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Don Nachbaur 26

freakydallas13

Registered User
Jan 30, 2007
7,608
18,594
Vancouver
If Briere traded a 2nd rd pick for a PP specialist, would you applaud that move?
Ghost is ancient history, AV and CF are ancient history.
Who gives a F at this point?
Yeah man, trading a second for a ppg defenceman sounds awful. Gross. Yucky. Who wants that?

Better to let the team tank! That's what you always say.
 

Beef Invictus

Revolutionary Positivity
Dec 21, 2009
130,747
171,744
Armored Train
Ghost doesn't score that much at ES, he's a PP specialist.
Would I want a top 4 D-man who scores a lot at ES, yeah, we have one in Sanheim.


No we don't. Arizona doesn't count, it's like saying AMac was a first pair D-man b/c he was on the first pair on a terrible Islanders team.

Ghost has been on the third pair on every other team he played for since leaving Philly.
Or do you think Brind'Amour is stupid?

Arizona does count. So does Philly. And Detroit. And anywhere else he has played. You don't get to throw away entire years because they happen to prove you wrong. The correct thing to do is admit you're wrong and adapt.

Rod stupid? Reread my post. The answer to that is already there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kelmitchell2

Curufinwe

Registered User
Feb 28, 2013
57,050
45,533
Yeah man, trading a second for a ppg defenceman sounds awful. Gross. Yucky. Who wants that?

Better to let the team tank! That's what you always say.
111 PPG in 275 games since trading Ghost and Voracek. 13.8 PP%, and only 10.5% Net because they have allowed 27 SHG.

Amusingly, that puts them at 33rd in both percentages, because Utah and Arizona are treated separately.

 

Kelmitchell2

Registered User
Aug 30, 2020
4,318
7,242
Ghost is 6th in 5x5 minutes on Carolina.
But he plays 3:52 minutes a game on PP.
Most of his scoring has come on the PP, ES 2-6 8 PP 4-13 17
Necas, Aho, Svechnikov, Jarvis

That's what AV didn't get, don't make him into what he wasn't, a top 4 D-man.
Carolina shelters him at ES and rides him on the PP.
Pp points matter as well, stop down playing points, points are points and they really matter all the same
 

deadhead

Registered User
Feb 26, 2014
51,288
22,338
Probably a team that paid an enormous price to dump him and has ranked for years on end at or near the bottom of the league in PP%.

Worst "trade" in franchise history.
Nah. Trading Sharp for a 3rd rd pick was much worse.
 

ybnvs

Registered User
Mar 20, 2014
2,267
4,001
Nah. Trading Sharp for a 3rd rd pick was much worse.

Nah. The Ghost dump and moves directly after have caused massive ripple effects for years on end. What did they do after dumping Ghost? Traded an overpayment for Risto, re-upped Risto, scrambled after a Ghost-replica replacement in Gus/Yandle/TDA, and have since been unable to replicate any semblance of production Ghost was and is currently producing.
 

nacc BLOCC

Registered User
Apr 16, 2019
96
152
What we really need is the ability to test before the person dies. I understand it's caused by a buildup of a certain protein in the brain that effects the function of neurons. Hopefully some brilliant scientist develops a test.


cows at upenn have been getting repeatedly rammed in the head by calibrated pistons to develop cte, all while undergoing routine brain scans, so that scientists can figure out what cte would look like on imagining.

these sorts of studies in tandem with the increasing power of brain imaging and data processing will lead to identifying cte without the need to use a tissue sample (be dead) in the fairly near future.

so less a brilliant scientist than the contribution of many researchers and animals across different fields.
 

deadhead

Registered User
Feb 26, 2014
51,288
22,338
Nah. The Ghost dump and moves directly after have caused massive ripple effects for years on end. What did they do after dumping Ghost? Traded an overpayment for Risto, re-upped Risto, scrambled after a Ghost-replica replacement in Gus/Yandle/TDA, and have since been unable to replicate any semblance of production Ghost was and is currently producing.
Risto had nothing to do with Ghost.
Yandle was the short-term replacement, York and Andrae attempts to draft a PP QB.
TDA was a desperation move by a GM on his way out.

Ghost wouldn't be nearly as productive on the Flyer PP the last few seasons without G, Simmonds and Schenn. In Carolina he has much better talent than he had in Philly his last 3 seasons here (15, 8 & 8 PP points).
 
  • Haha
Reactions: SnS

WolfOfBroadStreet14

Registered User
Aug 15, 2020
749
1,067
Risto had nothing to do with Ghost.
Yandle was the short-term replacement, York and Andrae attempts to draft a PP QB.
TDA was a desperation move by a GM on his way out.

Ghost wouldn't be nearly as productive on the Flyer PP the last few seasons without G, Simmonds and Schenn. In Carolina he has much better talent than he had in Philly his last 3 seasons here (15, 8 & 8 PP points).
The literally dumped Ghost by attaching picks to him so they could trade even more picks for Risto…I’m not hating on Risto but to say Risto had nothing to do with Ghost is certainly a stretch.
 

Beef Invictus

Revolutionary Positivity
Dec 21, 2009
130,747
171,744
Armored Train
Nah. The Ghost dump and moves directly after have caused massive ripple effects for years on end. What did they do after dumping Ghost? Traded an overpayment for Risto, re-upped Risto, scrambled after a Ghost-replica replacement in Gus/Yandle/TDA, and have since been unable to replicate any semblance of production Ghost was and is currently producing.

Don't forget losing a Drysdale trade as part of that scramble.
 

Blackhawkswincup

RIP Fugu
Jun 24, 2007
191,143
23,835
Chicagoland
Nah. Trading Sharp for a 3rd rd pick was much worse.
Nah. The Ghost dump and moves directly after have caused massive ripple effects for years on end. What did they do after dumping Ghost? Traded an overpayment for Risto, re-upped Risto, scrambled after a Ghost-replica replacement in Gus/Yandle/TDA, and have since been unable to replicate any semblance of production Ghost was and is currently producing.

Couldn't it be argued Sharp SCF performance against Flyers was more impactful in negative for Flyers?

Sharp in finals vs Flyers

4 goals + 2 assists and a +7

Was one of the Hawks best players in that series

Without Sharp the Hawks are never SC caliber team. Would Flyers have won vs 2010 San Jose Sharks in your opinion?
 

Hollywood Cannon

I'm Away From My Desk
Jul 17, 2007
88,613
161,213
South Jersey
Couldn't it be argued Sharp SCF performance against Flyers was more impactful in negative for Flyers?

Sharp in finals vs Flyers

4 goals + 2 assists and a +7

Was one of the Hawks best players in that series

Without Sharp the Hawks are never SC caliber team. Would Flyers have won vs 2010 San Jose Sharks in your opinion?

d9fe2aee.jpg
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Beef Invictus

deadhead

Registered User
Feb 26, 2014
51,288
22,338
The literally dumped Ghost by attaching picks to him so they could trade even more picks for Risto…I’m not hating on Risto but to say Risto had nothing to do with Ghost is certainly a stretch.
AV wanted to dump Ghost and Voracek in any case.
They attached one pick to Ghost, cost less than it cost Fla to dump Stralman.
 

Beef Invictus

Revolutionary Positivity
Dec 21, 2009
130,747
171,744
Armored Train
Couldn't it be argued Sharp SCF performance against Flyers was more impactful in negative for Flyers?

Sharp in finals vs Flyers

4 goals + 2 assists and a +7

Was one of the Hawks best players in that series

Without Sharp the Hawks are never SC caliber team. Would Flyers have won vs 2010 San Jose Sharks in your opinion?

Alright, someone light the fire in The Forum Banner boilers. Bring it up to steam.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad