Thoughts: I will always remember his call on Stepan’s series winning goal against Washington (though it would have meant infinitely more had the Rangers gone on to win that Cup, which they should have).
But, I always found him far inferior to Gary Thorne as the National voice of hockey. I’m sure I have heard many times over that Thorne was technically inferior and prone to mistakes and mispronunciation but that guy simply had the cadence and the tone and his important goal calls were unmatched in excitement. Even if wrong, “1940.... is history!” just had such forceful punctuation and pop to it. And “Do you believe it? Do.... you.... believe it? He said we will win game 6, he has just picked up the hat trick!”
So many other gems too.... “off the floor, on the board,” Steve Yzerman GWG, Raymond Bourque after 22 years, etc. No one could yell “scoooore” like him.
Emrick I always found too high pitched and nasally to rise to the same level, but that being said, I will admit that his peers are far worse than him even. Rosen is excellent but I don’t want him (ever) taken away from full time Rangers calls, and on top of that he’s too old to take the job at this point, they will want someone with some staying power. But Emrick still managed to make that Rangers run of the mid 2010s memorable.
Suffice to say, I’m mixed on his retirement. I’m excited to see if they can find someone more on par with Thorne; but the realist in me looks around and sees options like Kenny Albert (who is ok but not great) or Forslund who I think is just as annoying as Emrick, and I think the hockey broadcaster options are generally terrible. The sport in general needs an overhaul of announcers and to get away from the corny Canadian routine and get more of a Thorne/Joe Buck/Mike Breen type, someone whose voice alone can inspire excitement and enthusiasm. Frankly I think that is one of the most important thing to the next TV deal: finding a compelling play by play voice.
Best of luck, Doc, but I won’t tremendously miss him unless the networks botch his replacement.