I don't understand why Cincy is even in contention to be honest. Is it because Fickel is their coach? They beat a perennially overrated ND, but I just don't see them being that much different than someone like Fresno St, another mid major, but whom beat UCLA and hung in there with Oregon in Eugene.
But I don't get the rankings this year, lots of voters really trying to make some teams a thing...'member UNC being like #10 at the start? The Big Ten if they do squeak into the CFP is going to exposed so hard, voters really trying to make Iowa, PSU, tOSU, MSU, UM a thing, and I just struggle to see any of them as great teams now that conference play is trashing records.
But on one of the CFB threads on the football board, I said that I'm on Team Chaos...maybe I'll root for Ferris St in DII action, GLIAC football represent.
They're 8-0 and have a win over #10 ND. They've been repeatedly pretty damn good in the last few years. They're not Ball State pulling out a miracle undefeated run to the MAC championship to lose it there and never approach that again. Also... You not seeing a difference between Cincinnati who hasn't lost yet and Fresno State who's lost twice is you being blind.
Cincinnati has had one game within one score. 27-20 over Navy. They beat Notre Dame AT Notre Dame by 11.
Fresno State has had 5 one score games. To their credit, their two losses are part of those five. Fresno is playing the Mountain West teams like Wyoming, Nevada, and others and it's dogfights all the way down.
Cincinnati is playing an AAC schedule and is jack-hammering most teams.
Also... there is quite literally only one ultra impressive team in college football this year. That's Georgia. Pretty much every single other team you can point to an Achilles heel or has put up a stinker.
My only issue is that Alabama and Oregon have no claim to be in the top 4 over Cincinnati... and I probably would have kept Oklahoma there too, even though they've had some real stinkers that they pulled out. 8-0 in the Big 12 is 8-0 in the Big 12.
Georgia
Michigan State
Cincinnati
Oklahoma
I could definitely live with this.
Want Oregon or Ohio State or Alabama in that fourth spot over Oklahoma because of awful games vs. Texas, Tulane, and Kansas? Can't fight you on that, I suppose. I'd go Oregon because they do have H2H over Ohio State. Alabama can go rot for all I care. They're gonna play in the SEC title game. And if they beat Georgia, they're in. If they lose to Georgia, they're probably out. Give someone else a chance in the sun and to bask in being ranked up there. The rankings are all bullshit anyway.