Value of: Martin Necas to the Habs

[Pierre Lebrun]

I assume this is not going to be cheap. But the premise behind it is that with the Habs A) selecting Zadina, and B) needing a young center so badly, this could be a great move for them longterm. Multiple Canes fans have suggested selecting Zadina for the purposes of uniting him with Necas - this is the converse of that with the Habs attempting to do it instead.

Thoughts?

Click to read more...

 

[MinJaBen]

Canes need young, fast, dynamic centers, too. I don’t see anything you have short of the 3OA that would move me to get rid of Necas....which, of course, ruins the premise of your proposal.

Easy no.

 

[Pierre Lebrun]

Canes need young, fast, dynamic centers, too. I don’t see anything you have short of the 3OA that would move me to get rid of Necas....which, of course, ruins the premise of your proposal.

Easy no.

Considering the chemistry of that combo, would anyone be interested in 3OA for Lindholm? Assuming Necas steps in very soon. Canes essentially get Svechnikov, Zadina, and Necas together for Lindholm. Not sure I like this anymore lol..

 

[Hulkacaniac]

Considering the chemistry of that combo, would anyone be interested in 3OA for Lindholm? Assuming Necas steps in very soon. Canes essentially get Svechnikov, Zadina, and Necas together for Lindholm. Not sure I like this anymore lol..

Carolina would like that, but Montreal would certainly not

 

[jfhabs]

Drouin/Galchenyuk for Necas? Not sure I would do it, just would like to know how Canes fan would feel about this deal.

 

[Pierre Lebrun]

Drouin/Galchenyuk for Necas? Not sure I would do it, just would like to know how Canes fan would feel about this deal.

from Habs perspective I'd move Galchenyuk for Necas 1 for 1.

 

[Cardiac Jerks]

I assume this is not going to be cheap. But the premise behind it is that with the Habs A) selecting Zadina, and B) needing a young center so badly, this could be a great move for them longterm. Multiple Canes fans have suggested selecting Zadina for the purposes of uniting him with Necas - this is the converse of that with the Habs attempting to do it instead.

Thoughts?

Canes fans want Svechnikov. Check the poll on our board. All the talk of reuniting Zadina and Necas has been from random sources and it’s just pure speculation based on their history.

We will happily keep Necas and we will happily draft Svechnikov. Their is no moving Necas for anything short of a huge overpayment. Their is no need to. We especially aren’t going to move him for an older winger. We need a 1C just as bad as you do and he’s the only thing we have in the system that looks like he has that potential.

 

[MinJaBen]

Considering the chemistry of that combo, would anyone be interested in 3OA for Lindholm? Assuming Necas steps in very soon. Canes essentially get Svechnikov, Zadina, and Necas together for Lindholm. Not sure I like this anymore lol..

I’d do this with little reservation. I’d add one of our D prospects (Fluery, Bean, McKeown, Martin) as well.

 

[Cardiac Jerks]

I’d do this with little reservation. I’d add one of our D prospects (Fluery, Bean, McKeown, Martin) as well.

It’s odd to see a trade proposal completely slanted in our favour. Generally teams fans just want to rob us of the few good players/prospects/picks we have and send us their garbage in return. It’s a strange feeling being on the other end.

 

[Hostile Offer]

Considering the chemistry of that combo, would anyone be interested in 3OA for Lindholm? Assuming Necas steps in very soon. Canes essentially get Svechnikov, Zadina, and Necas together for Lindholm. Not sure I like this anymore lol..

Yeah this is thankfully not going to happen. Lindholm is nowhere near worth that.

 

[RodTheBawd]

I assume this is not going to be cheap. But the premise behind it is that with the Habs A) selecting Zadina, and B) needing a young center so badly, this could be a great move for them longterm. Multiple Canes fans have suggested selecting Zadina for the purposes of uniting him with Necas - this is the converse of that with the Habs attempting to do it instead.

Thoughts?

I call bullshit on that. And no, Necas is damn near untouchable.

 

[jonlin]

Canes fans want Svechnikov. Check the poll on our board. All the talk of reuniting Zadina and Necas has been from random sources and it’s just pure speculation based on their history.

We will happily keep Necas and we will happily draft Svechnikov. Their is no moving Necas for anything short of a huge overpayment. Their is no need to. We especially aren’t going to move him for an older winger. We need a 1C just as bad as you do and he’s the only thing we have in the system that looks like he has that potential.

I`d point out that in Aho I see a lot of potential for 1C. He isnt a sure bet, but the potential is there. He plays C for Finland in WC too

 

[Svechhammer]

Considering the chemistry of that combo, would anyone be interested in 3OA for Lindholm? Assuming Necas steps in very soon. Canes essentially get Svechnikov, Zadina, and Necas together for Lindholm. Not sure I like this anymore lol..

Done, where do I sign?

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

I assume this is not going to be cheap. But the premise behind it is that with the Habs A) selecting Zadina, and B) needing a young center so badly, this could be a great move for them longterm. Multiple Canes fans have suggested selecting Zadina for the purposes of uniting him with Necas - this is the converse of that with the Habs attempting to do it instead.

Thoughts?

Absolutely not true. I don't think even 1 Canes fan have suggested, that, just other fan bases hoping that the Canes pass on Svechnikov. In fact, here is our poll and 93% chose Svechnicov, and the 3 posters that picked Zadina aren't even Canes fans (1 is a Wings fan, 1 is an Oilers fan, and 1 appears to be a MTL fan).

Secondly, Necas potentially fills a need with Carolina being a high potentials center and they are very high on him. I'd be shocked if they moved him.

Third, you couldn't reunite Zadina and Necas in MTL, because if you happened to acquire Necas, it would cost you the 3rd OA pick.

 

[Starat327]

When do we create the "Your prospect C to Montreal" Mega thread?

 

[member 157595]

Team that needs high-end forwards trades away a high-end forward prospect?

 

[Svechhammer]

Absolutely not true. I don't think even 1 Canes fan have suggested, that, just other fan bases hoping that the Canes pass on Svechnikov. In fact, here is our poll and 93% chose Svechnicov, and the 3 posters that picked Zadina aren't even Canes fans (1 is a Wings fan, 1 is an Oilers fan, and 1 appears to be a MTL fan).

Secondly, Necas potentially fills a need with Carolina being a high potentials center and they are very high on him. I'd be shocked if they moved him.

Third, you couldn't reunite Zadina and Necas in MTL, because if you happened to acquire Necas, it would cost you the 3rd OA pick.

Shhhh they already offered 3OA for Lindy. Take it and run, man

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

Zadina for Lindholm. Done. Sounds great. Close thread.

 

[BleedBlue14]

When do we create the "Your prospect C to Montreal" Mega thread?

Missed the opportunity at the TDL.

 

[Unsustainable]

Considering the chemistry of that combo, would anyone be interested in 3OA for Lindholm? Assuming Necas steps in very soon. Canes essentially get Svechnikov, Zadina, and Necas together for Lindholm. Not sure I like this anymore lol..

As a Canes fan, I would take that and run. But value wise, Canes add to Lindholm for the 3rd.

But Lindholm + Bean maybe for 3rd?

 

[Unsustainable]

Drouin/Galchenyuk for Necas? Not sure I would do it, just would like to know how Canes fan would feel about this deal.

Drouin Yes, Galch No

 

[LakeLivin]

Drouin/Galchenyuk for Necas? Not sure I would do it, just would like to know how Canes fan would feel about this deal.

Firm no and no from this Canes fan.

 

[Voodoo Glow Skulls]

Firm no and no from this Canes fan.

Firm no from a Detroit fan.

 

[SpeakingOfTheDevils]

Carolina would want much more than Montreal would want to surrender.

Why can’t you guys just draft your own players? Sheesh.

 

[ole ole]

Carolina would want much more than Montreal would want to surrender.

Why can’t you guys just draft your own players? Sheesh.

Why can't you stay out of Hab threads?