Proposal: Make a trade proposal where your team gives up the best asset

[GIN ANTONIC]

Simple as that. Every proposal on this board is about how a fanbase can Ryder, Halak, 2nd their way into getting a premium player.

So, I pose this challenge... come up with a BALANCED trade proposal that benefits your team and your trading partner, but in the deal you are giving up the single most valuable piece. Just try it OK.

Canes have Jackson Blake and Logan Stankoven as young right handed RW that can play in the top 6. Seth Jarvis is a 23 y/o with back 30 + 30 seasons and primed to hit ppg status next year all while playing a tenacious, high motor 200 ft game. One of the best defensive forwards in the league and signed for the next 7 years at $7.4m. Canes could trade him to fill a lot of other holes in the roster.

To CGY: Seth Jarvis, Jesperi Kotkaniemi, Scott Morrow
To CAR: Nazem Kadri, Rasmus Andersson, Huberdeau ($2.5m retained)

Svech - Aho - Blake
Huberdeau - Kadri - Stankoven
Hall - Staal - Martinook

Slavin - Andersson
Nikishin - Chatfield
Gost - Walker

Also, I want to preface this by saying I hate this trade as a Canes fan but maybe Flames fans hate it too... so perhaps it's close? I dunno.

 

[landy]

Rantanen for Necas...

 

[ACC1224]

Leafs don't have any good assets.

 

[Soundgarden]

Forsberg for Pittsburgh's '26 1st.

 

[HugeInTheShire]

Palat + 2nd to Utah for Crouse.

The 2nd is probably the best asset lol

 

[Satanphonehome]

Peterka, Samuelsson and #9 for Cuylle, Schneider and #12

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

Peterka, Samuelsson and #9 for Cuylle, Schneider and #12

This seems bad for Buffalo but maybe I'm missing something? I know Peterka is 'being shopped' apparently but to give up the higher pick as well?

Feels like the difference between Peterka + #9 and Cuylle + #12 is bigger than the difference between Schneider and Samuelsson

 

[MinJaBen]

Canes: Furture considerations
Oilers: Rights to Jeff Skinner before the draft

 

[Mac Attack]

Col: Necas
Van: Wallinder, 1st

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

Peterka, Samuelsson and #9 for Cuylle, Schneider and #12

Don't the Rangers have to give that to Pittsburgh otherwise It's a 2026 1st?

 

[RobertCalifornia]

** The Following trade is under the imaginary premise that Quinn Hughes does not exist **

To St Louis
Jack Hughes
Dougie Hamilton
Seamus Casey

To New Jersey
Robert Thomas
Dylan Holloway
Brayden Schenn
Philip Broberg
Jake Neighbors

 

[Gregor Samsa]

Michkov would get the attention of a lot of teams

 

[StewieP19]

To Colorado : Guentner
TO Utah : Necas extended

 

[n8]

Simple as that. Every proposal on this board is about how a fanbase can Ryder, Halak, 2nd their way into getting a premium player.

So, I pose this challenge... come up with a BALANCED trade proposal that benefits your team and your trading partner, but in the deal you are giving up the single most valuable piece. Just try it OK.

Canes have Jackson Blake and Logan Stankoven as young right handed RW that can play in the top 6. Seth Jarvis is a 23 y/o with back 30 + 30 seasons and primed to hit ppg status next year all while playing a tenacious, high motor 200 ft game. One of the best defensive forwards in the league and signed for the next 7 years at $7.4m. Canes could trade him to fill a lot of other holes in the roster.

To CGY: Seth Jarvis, Jesperi Kotkaniemi, Scott Morrow
To CAR: Nazem Kadri, Rasmus Andersson, Huberdeau ($2.5m retained)

Jarvis > Svechnikov ???
Fun idea!
People have weird ideas of what "best asset" constitutes for their team.

 

[namttebih]

Matthews for Cooley, Hayton and 4OA

 

[n8]

Peterka, Samuelsson and #9 for Cuylle, Schneider and #12

Best asset. Wrong thread.
Your deal should include Tage. Dahlin has a NMC so he would be exempt from best asset status.

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

Jarvis > Svechnikov ???
Fun idea!
People have weird ideas of what "best asset" constitutes for their team.

I’m not saying Jarvis is the best asset on the Canes, although he might be.

The thread is about making a proposal where your team gives up the best asset in the deal

 

[n8]

I’m not saying Jarvis is the best asset on the Canes, although he might be.

The thread is about making a proposal where your team gives up the best asset in the deal

Set the standard! Give us your best Svechnikov trade.

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

Set the standard! Give us your best Svechnikov trade.

No.

 

[Slats432]

To Carolina: Victor Arvidsson
To Edmonton: 3rd round pick 2026

 

[SirPaste]

** The Following trade is under the imaginary premise that Quinn Hughes does not exist **

To St Louis
Jack Hughes
Dougie Hamilton
Seamus Casey

To New Jersey
Robert Thomas
Dylan Holloway
Brayden Schenn
Philip Broberg
Jake Neighbors

What in the world is this

 

[Perratrooper]

To Colorado : Guentner
TO Utah : Necas extended

Are you an Utah or Colorado fan?

As an Avs fan I’d probably do it

 

[n8]

No.

GIN ANTONIC: Starts a "trade your best player thread"
Also GIN ANTONIC: Refuses to propose a trade with the best player on the team

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

GIN ANTONIC: Starts a "trade your best player thread"
Also GIN ANTONIC: Refuses to propose a trade with the best player on the team

You can’t read. Thats not what this thread is.

MAKE A TRADE WHERE YOUR TEAM GIVES UP THE BEST ASSET IN THE DEAL

 

[Baksfamous112]

Lane Hutson
Nick Suzuki
2025 16th overall pick (Calgary)

For

Macklin Celibrini
Sam Dickinson
2025 #2 Overall (San Jose)