SingnBluesOnBroadway
Retired
That's not fair. Malhotra was a long time ago, under different management and is a much different situation that an Andersson.
Prospect Info: Lias Andersson - Part IV
- Thread starter Krams
- Start date
-
Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
- Status
yea Malhotra actually had a lot more talent. Andersson reminds me of Derek Armstrong vibe. great 1st round selection for an AHL player/ Euro Tweener, not an NHL player.. Andersson will have an Immonen type of career
What are you talking about?
How come I know? Lol I have the benefit of hindsight. I am back seat driving, it’s a lot easier now to call that it was wrong to rush Lias over right away. I would bet my right arm that everyone in the organization willingly would admit that too, it’s not really debatable. And you say the same thing, I don’t follow at all. We are saying the same thing lol.
You make it sound like I am claiming to know better than these guys how to develop Lafreniere. I am not. I am looking at a de facto disaster and putting it in a context.
You don’t have to be a super scout that knows things better than our scouting office to claim that Hugh Jessiman was a bad pick. We made some really dumb calls on Lias. Really few kids have been ready at 18 lately. Really really few. Lias was a bit of a reach at 18. He would undoubtedly been much better of to grow a few years and building up his physics before being rushed to the NHL.
How could our brass make a mistake of this magnitude? A more experienced coach would without any single doubt in no unclear terms have explained to his GM that the league was just too tough for an 18 y/o like Lias. A GM that — unlike Gorton — had more experience of handling high prospects wouldn’t have rushed him over. Just like Gorton never would do it again. These are facts.
JCProdigy
Registered User
Hey Ola, I might of been a lil tipsy during my last post to yaWhat are you talking about?
How come I know? Lol I have the benefit of hindsight. I am back seat driving, it’s a lot easier now to call that it was wrong to rush Lias over right away. I would bet my right arm that everyone in the organization willingly would admit that too, it’s not really debatable. And you say the same thing, I don’t follow at all. We are saying the same thing lol.
You make it sound like I am claiming to know better than these guys how to develop Lafreniere. I am not. I am looking at a de facto disaster and putting it in a context.
You don’t have to be a super scout that knows things better than our scouting office to claim that Hugh Jessiman was a bad pick. We made some really dumb calls on Lias. Really few kids have been ready at 18 lately. Really really few. Lias was a bit of a reach at 18. He would undoubtedly been much better of to grow a few years and building up his physics before being rushed to the NHL.
How could our brass make a mistake of this magnitude? A more experienced coach would without any single doubt in no unclear terms have explained to his GM that the league was just too tough for an 18 y/o like Lias. A GM that — unlike Gorton — had more experience of handling high prospects wouldn’t have rushed him over. Just like Gorton never would do it again. These are facts.
I think we're talking past each other a lil bit. It's all good. I normally don't disagree with your takes and if I do, I respect that you can at least back 'em up with some logic.On this subject, we agree on a bunch, I just had two points of contention: That Quinn "hates" Lias. That Quinn is totally incapable of empathizing with a high draft pick.
It doesn't matter though because Andersson is over in the SHL for now and there is no road map for his future in the NHL, if there even is one.
As for Quinn/Gorton/Rangers, ya hope they learn from Andersson (and all the rest of the personnel moves they have made) and are better, smarter, stronger, going forward.
.....oh and maybe if Quinn wraps Lias up in a hospital receiving blanket you'll feel more confident in Lias coming back
Hey Ola, I might of been a lil tipsy during my last post to ya
On this subject, we agree on a bunch, I just had two points of contention: That Quinn "hates" Lias. That Quinn is totally incapable of empathizing with a high draft pick.
It doesn't matter though because Andersson is over in the SHL for now and there is no road map for his future in the NHL, if there even is one.
As for Quinn/Gorton/Rangers, ya hope they learn from Andersson (and all the rest of the personnel moves they have made) and are better, smarter, stronger, going forward.
.....oh and maybe if Quinn wraps Lias up in a hospital receiving blanket you'll feel more confident in Lias coming back
Thanks and same here!
This is a bloody subject to start with. For me it is also a little touchy subject because I've been half-annoyed at how our front-office is anything but a meritocracy and the writing has been on the wall that we would see some blunders. Individually I don't mind anyone from Davidsson to Gorton to Drury to Ortmayer to DQ, and I do think that it has been apparent that the day only has 24 hours for Gorton.
But these guys will learn as they go. Something has finally been done about HFD. I think we will think twice about rushing kids in the future.
Brooklyn Rangers Fan
Change is good.
I'm calling BS on this one, @Ola. You've had it in for JD from the moment his hiring was announced.Thanks and same here!
This is a bloody subject to start with. For me it is also a little touchy subject because I've been half-annoyed at how our front-office is anything but a meritocracy and the writing has been on the wall that we would see some blunders. Individually I don't mind anyone from Davidsson to Gorton to Drury to Ortmayer to DQ, and I do think that it has been apparent that the day only has 24 hours for Gorton.
But these guys will learn as they go. Something has finally been done about HFD. I think we will think twice about rushing kids in the future.
Yeah, but I loved him before that, its in the context of the front office already in place that I rather would have seen some experienced GM.
I truly believe that Jeff Gorton could be the best guy for the job in NY. But that is because (a) he is not in any way risk adverse like so many other GM's out there, (b) he is great at working the phones and making things happen. So many GMs out there never accomplish this. But I don't think he is the visonary as some of his peers. Think we will hit a few mines if he doesn't surround himself with guys more in tune with the progress in the NHL. What worked 10 years ago will far from always work today so to speak.
GeorgeKaplan
Registered User
Powerplay tip in goal? All day Andersson says
I bash the kid but the one thing he’s always been good at is scoring down low around the net. Couldn’t beat a high school goalie Clean from the hash marks out but hands around the net always top notch.
I bash the kid but the one thing he’s always been good at is scoring down low around the net. Couldn’t beat a high school goalie Clean from the hash marks out but hands around the net always top notch.
Harbour Dog
Registered User
My hope for him was to develop into that type of net front guy that people hate to play against. He always had his size against him a bit for that role, but he was feisty enough, and has very quick hands to loose pucks.
Edit - just noticed that I'm talking about him in past tense lol. I'm resigned to him not being a Ranger.
If he can only produce on the pp he’s not even going to an nhler at all Let alone a Ranger.
GeorgeKaplan
Registered User
Even strength, there’s 5 skaters in red
I think he is playing this way because Andersson really wants out of NYR. Rangers should keep him and not trade him. why do him any favors. still a AHL player at best. we have seen AHL players do the same thing as Andersson in europe.
GeorgeKaplan
Registered User
It's not about doing him favors, if he's an AHL player at best like you say, why not trade him to get something else?
UnSandvich
Registered User
- Sep 7, 2017
- 5,892
- 9,027
Because some people are more concerned with spite than they are with making intelligent organizational decisions
Andersson value is a 7th round pick at this time. he ruined his value with his immaturity issues
Amazing Kreiderman
Registered User
- Apr 11, 2011
- 45,070
- 40,920
Probably closer to a third, but a trade isn't happening before the expansion draft. And I wouldn't be surprised if Seattle picks him
NYSPORTS
back afta dis. . .
- Jun 17, 2019
- 7,993
- 4,459
he’s not even worth moving at this point. Sit and wait. His value is at a low
Brooklyn Rangers Fan
Change is good.
Or maybe our fan base is full of a bunch of hypocrites who hate on Lias when Lias asked for a trade but have no problem with Fox, Hayes and Vesey refusing to play for their teams and wanting to sign here.
Big difference they had a choice and took the UFA loophole. And In Fox Rangers traded for him to secure him being a Rangers. Did any of them quit on their team like Andersson when things don’t work well??
It's not a loophole. It's intentional.
Amazing Kreiderman
Registered User
- Apr 11, 2011
- 45,070
- 40,920
Yes, Hayes and Vesey literally quit on their team. They literally walked away from the team that had their rights. Vesey even did it twice. All within their rights of course, using the possibility to opt for UFA status, but they did quit on the team that drafted them
SA16
Sixstring
How do you quit on a team that you never had a contract with or agreed to play for in the first place?
- Status
