Value of: LEAFS and STARS / LEAFS and KRAKEN

[Stuart Little]

Stars send:
John Klingberg (50% retained)

Leafs send:
Justin Holl
Nick Robertson


OR

Kraken send:
Mark Giordano (50% retained)

Leafs Send:
Justin Holl
Ilya Mikheyev

Click to read more...

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

Kraken trade is a joke, Andy Greene got a better return than that with zero retention

Maybe your offer for Klingberg is fair for Gio

 

[Stuart Little]

rationale:

Stars and Kraken likely not going to be in playoff picture (or unlikely)
- either team can then get a Dman under contract for next year at a reasonable rate PLUS additional an additional asset.

For the leafs - they would get the BETTER player in each deal (with the potential possibility of an extension - provided getting rid of a Kerfoot,etc in the off-season)

 

[Stuart Little]

yes I do understand that each of those teams could trade Gio or Klingberg at deadline and get picks/prospects

I was merely pointing out (do they view Robertson) as a first round pick/ready player and the value of Holl - yes I know Holl has been "bad" this year - but, he has proven to be way better and has a great contract,

 

[Golden_Jet]

No chance on either deal, especially Dallas, why would they retain salary for those players.

 

[FerrisRox]

Stars send:
John Klingberg (50% retained)

Leafs send:
Justin Holl
Nick Robertson


OR

Kraken send:
Mark Giordano (50% retained)

Leafs Send:
Justin Holl
Ilya Mikheyev

In each of these trades, the team retaining money is trading, by far, the best player in the deal.

This is insane.

 

[93Crazed101]

As much as I like uniting siblings onto teams, I can't justify that horrendous value.

 

[Kaen]

Brutal for the Kraken and Stars. Plus wasn't there a rumor that the Stars were resigning Kling?

 

[Cogburn]

Would the Leafs accept that package for, say, Muzzin or Brodie in the last year of their contracts? Or in the Stars case, Rielly, prior to him resigning?

 

[Stuart Little]

Yes - please

id be all for

Muzzin

for
Prospect and lesser dman

 

[Aashir Mallik]

Those are terrible for stars and kraken.

 

[Dr Pepper]

What's the point of retaining 50% on the last year of an expiring contract? Is that supposed to sweeten the deal, or what?

Brutal value for Dallas, they can get so much more for Klingberg at the deadline - provided they're out of the race by then and haven't signed him already.

 

[blankall]

Other teams can get more at the deadline. These two will must certainly create bidding wars. Are the leafs really in a position to be bidding away their first on a high end dman ufa? Is this the year for them to go all in?

 

[Unspecified]

You want Dallas to retain 50% on an expiring contract and ship a top pairing D to Toronto for that?

 

[ThankGord]

Toronto has to add picks on both trades, add even more if you're set on asking for 50% retained.

 

[kihei]

Kraken say no. If we are going to trade our captain, we are going to want someone coming back with a modicum of offensive upside. The current incarnation of Holl isn't an improvement on our D and Mikheyev is just another decent forward without a scoring touch.

 

[The Devilish Buffoon]

I'm not sure Dallas would accept that at 200%.

 

[McSuper]

You want Dallas to retain 50% on an expiring contract and ship a top pairing D to Toronto for that?

Same old same old . Don't you know only TML players have value . I had a few of their fans tell me they wouldn't trade Matthews for McDavid .

 

[innitfam]

That Dallas deal is putrid. Seriously awful.

 

[coopooter]

Where’s the first round pick ?

 

[McJedi]

Stars send:
John Klingberg (50% retained)

Leafs send:
Justin Holl
Nick Robertson


OR

Kraken send:
Mark Giordano (50% retained)

Leafs Send:
Justin Holl
Ilya Mikheyev

Wonder if a TML fan came up with this garbage? We’re all a littler dumber having read these two proposals.

lock this up for its terribleness.

 

[brokenwolf88]

Hard no on the Dallas trade.

I dont care how good Klingberg is im not trading away Robertson just so Klingberg can walk at the end of the year. If he came signed then maybe.

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

I fully expect the Leafs to be buyers come March, and to be in on both these players, but this doesn't do it

 

[Unspecified]

Hard no on the Dallas trade.

I dont care how good Klingberg is im not trading away Robertson just so Klingberg can walk at the end of the year. If he came signed then maybe.

If he were to come signed it would be for 5 Nick Robertson's

 

[CupcakeSprinkles]

Mods need to delete this thread. Bad.