WarriorofTime
Registered User
- Jul 3, 2010
- 31,538
- 20,615
No offense but are you aware of the hawks current pool/its relative strengths and relative weaknesses?
LD Anton Silayev - Torpedo Nizhny Novgorod, KHL (2024, 10th, NJ)
- Thread starter Kshahdoo
- Start date
Kevin Musto
Hard for Bedard
- Feb 16, 2018
- 22,574
- 29,253
True.
But at the same time, Silayev has higher upside than any D in the Blackhawks system.
You don't pass on 2 million dollars because you already own a million.
WeThreeKings
Demidov is a HAB
They might be deep on LD but they're weak on the right side, so Silayev doesn't make sense but Levshunov sure does.
Look at the top end of next years draft, a lot of very good forwards, the defense doesn't look great and the ones that do are almost exclusively left shot D.
Wouldn't be surprised at all if Chicago goes Levshunov, not that it helps my Habs any cause then Anaheim or CBJ just pivot to Demidov.
Look at the top end of next years draft, a lot of very good forwards, the defense doesn't look great and the ones that do are almost exclusively left shot D.
Wouldn't be surprised at all if Chicago goes Levshunov, not that it helps my Habs any cause then Anaheim or CBJ just pivot to Demidov.
austin63867
Registered User
- Nov 13, 2018
- 513
- 605
He's 6'7 and has strong skating. Beyond that, I don't see much that's developed. His defensive game is prone to decision making lapses, his puck control has been questionable at times, and the production that made him a top prospect quickly dried up. I've watched aboit a dozen games so far and haven't been super impressed on a consistent level. Even when he went back to the MHL I didn't see much of the top prospect I was promised. Had he not been in Torpedo, I doubt he'd be getting as many KHL looks as he did, and if his MHL play was all to go on, he wouldn't be talked about as a top-five pick in my view.
Last edited:
Fantomas
Registered User
- Aug 7, 2012
- 13,662
- 7,304
In other words, he's a complete project. A lot of things have to go right for Silayev to realize his potential and even then, who can really imagine this guy becoming a future #1 dman with a polished all-around game? He'd have to develop one very soon, because his repertoire is currently a mess. What even are his comparables?
Silayev had a strong (I woud argue fluky) start to the season and some edgy "scouts" put him high on their lists and he's been sitting on these lists ever since, even though he's done almost nothing special.
In my view, some scouts are too obsessed with these "unicorn"-type players. You still need a prospect to demonstrate a real translatable set of skills to convince me of his elite status.
WarriorofTime
Registered User
- Jul 3, 2010
- 31,538
- 20,615
A player doesn't get ranked #1 by CSB if they only have size going for them and are a complete project. They see something special in him and they aren't alone based on McKenzie's recent rankings.
I honestly liked Simashev more as a prospect. Like others have said, I think a lot of his hype is riding from that first month of production. Hasn’t done anything much in the MHL either
Half Clapper
Registered User
- Dec 1, 2017
- 1,352
- 1,499
Are the people criticizing this player watching him play, or just going off stats?
CBJWerenski8
Rest in Peace Johnny
- Jun 13, 2009
- 43,751
- 26,821
It’s HFBoards on a European player. Absolutely just going off stats and other peoples write ups.
Kevin Musto
Hard for Bedard
- Feb 16, 2018
- 22,574
- 29,253
Sounds like it. They only ever talk about the production.
Which is the most points a KHLer has ever put up at the age of 17.
And he's a defense-first shutdown defender.
This is kind of backwards to me.
If I was just looking at clips and seeing him skate, and then seeing 6'7, and the KHL points at his age (a lot), I would be blown away.
It's watching full games that makes me more reserved about his offensive upside. You rarely see Silayev trying anything.
If people are offended that some like Simashev more, well that's a great prospect. Simashev is also huge and also has amazing skating. And very unlike Silayev, he has a great ability to deceive with his movements, which gives Simashev more upside in transition than Silayev.
Guadana
Registered User
Simashev was much better player in his pre draft year - much better in transition, in escaping, with the puck.
samsagat
Registered User
- Jun 20, 2013
- 1,183
- 902
He was a 17 yo playing in the KHL, not the CHL. You have to consider it when you evaluate his offensive shyness.
The kid was trying to play a mistake free game and focussed primarily on his defensive assignments.
On a general basis, the KHL is harsher on their youngsters than the NHL. The Novgorod Torpedo, under Igor "the professor" Larionov, being a little different in that matter, Silayev got a lot of playing time.
Silayev have a Chara like defensive game, with Hedman skating. He's a defensive annihilator.
The kind you win championships with. He's in his element in 2-1 tight games.
Because of his combination of massive size and fluid skating, he's at his best when funneling attacking opponents to the boards to crush them.
And offensively wise, he could easily end up having a Chara/Weber type of offensive contribution. Centered around his wicked shot, that needs a little refinement in terms of precision.
Silayev have a very high floor, he could probably make the NHL right away.
But his roof potential is over the top...
Could end up being a franchise defenseman, in his own fashion.
austin63867
Registered User
- Nov 13, 2018
- 513
- 605
So you just ignore the part where I said I watched 12 games of his but sure it's the stats
Caser
Moderator
I'd add to the bolded part that, while definitely not being perfect, in that component he looked better than other more experienced Torpedo Ds.
I watched him in the MHL playoffs too, and he did not start to make a play there.
Perhaps he'll just need more time to develop confidence after a long season playing cautiously in the KHL.
I think "easily" overstates it. I'm not ruling anything out but I don't think his shot is that close or that easily developed into an elite weapon.
Not making excuses but I wonder if he was physically/mentally worn down or his heart really just wasn't into playing in the MHL after spending the year in the K.
This I'm sympathetic to. Perhaps Silayev looks much better after a good off season of training and positive energy balance.
People said the same thing after Michkov's disappointing MHL playoffs a year ago, I didn't like it then, I don't like it now.
I understand that but these are 17/18 year olds that we are talking about. I remember when I was in high school many many years ago and bouncing back and forth between varsity and JV. I would try in the JV games but my heart wasn't in it and I felt I was "above" it. Teen stuff but it's real.
Yeah I don't get it.
Anyways it's not relevant for Silayev either. He's a competitor and certainly showed that defensively.
