It's honestly pretty simple to see where the dissonance comes from.
Some posters are looking at this season's raw results and are satisfied. That's fair.
Other posters are looking at the 'how' about this year's results and are dissatisfied with any of the following, which I also think is fair:
1. Kid usage and future;
2. repetitive issues not being addressed (special teams);
3. Overreliance on and burnout of vets and how that relates to the near future.
I don't think either one is 'wrong,' but daily either side gets treated as 'bad fans' and such because of it.
I think we can all agree on certain things and that is, context aside, the team this year is better, that special teams SUCK, that we want more from the youth, that we have a pending need for goaltenders, and that player usage as far as minutes at least has some concerns.