Kucherov 6 point night

[AvroArrow]

We're all in agreement that he's a generational winger right ?

 

[Luigi Lemieux]

Peak Malkin was every bit as good as peak Crosby, based on the half season he was capable of immediately following 2010-11; 33-32-65 in 41 vs. 32-34-66 in 41. Playoffs are more or less the same story both had 28 points in 17 games after 3 rounds, then Crosby had Lidstrom and Zetterberg stapled to him in the finals allowing Malkin to run wild and dominate. I think if anything Crosby would’ve strung together a few more of these super dominant seasons in his age 23-25 frame than Malkin would’ve, and possibly didn’t even get to reach his true potential even on a per game basis, we’ll never really know for sure.

To Kucherov’s credit he seems primed to have two of these seasons in a row right now which actually not even McDavid has done. One last thing though, none of these players have reached the playoff peak of McDavid in 2022 or 2024, that’s firmly the best player I’ve seen since Lemieux.

I don't think Malkin 09 was very far off Mcdavid 24. 36 points in 24 games vs 42 points in 25 games in a lower scoring year.

You literally just said to enjoy Kucherov. The unique issue is to him, not TB. Tell me this without entire Crosby, MacKinnon and McDavid stat lines dominating full pages here

Kucherov is incredible and has the best vision/iq in the league. Think he ages better than any of the guys mentioned in this thread due simply to that. At his performance level it's inevitable he gets compared to other greats.

 

[Golden_Jet]

I mean you're the one that said he was peak Crosby over a full season. Peak Crosby lapped the field, no one was even close. A 99 game sample size is pretty telling that no one was in his league. If you want to go to prime instead, 07-14, it's Crosby again.

 Crosby 1.42
Malkin 1.22
Ovechkin 1.18
St Louis 1.07
Thornton 1.05

And adjusted stats are only adjusted based on league averages. They are absolutely not a good way to compare the two eras for scorers. The increase in scoring disproportionately helps scorers, not your average 3rd liner. Smaller goalie pads, more empty net points, high pp efficiencies, no more headshots or cheapshots, no more net front battles, etc. 144 points when there's 9 100+ scorers is not more impressive than 109 (Malkin) or 104 (Crosby) when they are the only ones to hit 100 points in the league.

Crosby missed a lot of games, not the same.
Save that for the Crosby thread, I don’t even see Kuch mentioned.

 

[Luigi Lemieux]

Interesting analysis: If you look at their 82 gp paces for the years that they both played since 2017 (ie. not including McDavids 2021 - which isn't fair to him, since one of his best seasons, but Kuch also just didn't play so hard to compare).

Overall points and goals on 82gp paces are actually pretty close.

Take from that what you will.

	McDavid p/gp	Kuch p/gp	McDavid g/gp	Kuch g/gp
2017​	1.22	1.15	0.37	0.54
2018​	1.32	1.25	0.50	0.49
2019​	1.49	1.56	0.53	0.50
2020​	1.52	1.25	0.53	0.49
2021​	1.88	-	0.59	-
2022​	1.54	1.47	0.55	0.53
2023​	1.87	1.38	0.78	0.37
2024​	1.74	1.78	0.42	0.54
2025​	1.54	1.76	0.54	0.56

	McDavid Points	Kucherov Points	McDavid goals	Kucherov goals
2017​	100	94	30	44
2018​	108	103	41	40
2019​	122	128	43	41
2020​	124	103	44	40
2021​
2022​	126	120	45	44
2023​	153	113	64	30
2024​	142	146	35	45
2025​	126	144	44	46
TOTAL	1,002	951	345	329

Kucherov actually seems like he's getting better with age, which is pretty unheard of. He doesn't really rely on physical talents so it'll be interesting to see how long he can dominate. Wouldn't totally surprise me if MacKinnon and McDavid start declining before him despite being years younger. They lean a lot on their skating ability.

Crosby missed a lot of games, not the same.
Save that for the Crosby thread, I don’t even see Kuch mentioned.

I'm not the one that brought up Crosby.

 

[Frank Drebin]

don't think Malkin 09 was very far off Mcdavid 24. 36 points in 24 games vs 42 points in 25 games in a lower scoring year.

Crosbys line faced top lines in 09 though, yes?

 

[Video Nasty]

You talking about the leagues 7th leading scorer as well? I guess you’re right. 7th in scoring is pretty good. At the prime age of 27

I’m talking about the guy who is currently cooking with 30 points in his past 15 games, has gained 8 points apiece on Kucherov and MacKinnon over the past month, despite their recent efforts of 5-6 point games, and has the league’s third highest PPG in history which he is still increasing as he approaches age 28.

Sure, he’s currently 7th in raw scoring in mid-December, yet he’s working on a 9th consecutive season of being no lower than second in PPG, and top three all ten seasons of his career. He’s where he is despite missing three games due to injury—essentially four since he played a mere 37 seconds when he exited—and had just 10 points through 11 games and fell behind by 15 points. It’s going to be pretty damn silly if McDavid is in the midst of another 150 point Art Ross and you’re crowing about one of the most proven athletes ever not leading the scoring race in mid-December.

I know you badly want McDavid to not tie Mario with six Art Rosses, and also not widen the gap further between McDavid and Crosby, but barring more missed time, McDavid is looking primed to scoop it up. Sorry that you can’t see the difference in a Kucherov or MacKinnon with the Jaime Benns of the world confusing Crosby at the same age.

McDavid is currently remolding the Big Four into a Big Five. It’s inevitable. You can’t stop it. Embrace it like @WalterLundy showed you did less than six months ago.

 

[Luigi Lemieux]

Crosbys line faced top lines in 09 though, yes?

Yea true, probably mattered the most against Detroit, where Lidstrom-Rafalski + Zetterberg blanketed Crosby all series letting Malkin take advantage of Stuart-Kronwall + Datsyuk.

 

[authentic]

Yea true, probably mattered the most against Detroit, where Lidstrom-Rafalski + Zetterberg blanketed Crosby all series letting Malkin take advantage of Stuart-Kronwall + Datsyuk.

Datsyuk only played 4 games that series, pretty sure Malkin had 2 points in those games and 6 in his first 3.

 

[blundluntman]

Kucherov, Mackinnon, & McDavid's Year-and-a-half-long scoring race must be what it felt like watching guys like Lafleur, Dionne & Trottier back in the day. You had the 09 season with Crosby, Malkin & Ovi but it was pretty short lived and Crosby wasn't at his best (plus, they didn't all represent different franchises).

It's a great time to be a hockey fan, probably the best the game has ever been in my lifetime.