Tribute Jack Campbell Discussion Part 2

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Before he fell off a cliff, he was likely looking at the Lehner deal (5x5) in the open market

If he doesn't bounce back, 3x3 perhaps or Mrazek's deal (3x3.8) might be the best case scenario
if he doesn't bounce back he'll be looking at 2 x 2 at best unless Edm gets desperate , lol
 
Eh. IMO Jack Campbell has essentially played himself down to a 1 year deal again.

At this point, he’s back to being a question mark, who has shown flashes of being a legitimate starter, flashes of being a tandem goalie and flashes of well…. Being neither.

I love Campbell, I want him to turn it around and come through this a better goalie.

However right now, even 3x3 is risky
 
The Leafs let two points get away against the Canucks. And the goalie question continues to grow | The Star

About Jack Jack Campbell allowed four or more goals for the sixth time in his last eight games. It wasn’t the response he was looking for in his first start since he allowed five on 25 shots last Saturday, before being pulled against Detroit.

Campbell, though, is trying to reverse a natural tendency to be hard on himself.

“I’ve been hard on myself and it’s snowballed lately,” the goalie said. “I’m trying to chill a bit more. I’m never happy giving up goals any time. But I appreciate the fans supporting me and the team, and I promise I’ll get out of it. Sometimes trying too hard isn’t the best thing. I’ll get it back, I promise."


“Obviously there was a bit of nerves tonight. I wanted this game badly, and I wanted it for (Simmonds) too. But I’m trying to critique my game more appropriately, instead of bashing it all the time.”

Campbell and Petr Mrázek have allowed more goals since Jan. 1 than any other current playoff team over that span. Toronto also ranks 28th with a .911 save percentage at five-on-five.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DraftSchmaft
For me the biggest problem is campbells consistency

he doesn’t have a B or even C game.

he has either A+ game or F game

it’s either a vezina game or an echl goalie. That’s what’s been the biggest difference between Campbell and other true starters. Campbell doesn’t have many .905-.920 games. He doesn’t have the average night. He either has 1-2 on 30+ shots or he has 5+ on 30+.

I’d rather have a goalie who plays great 2 games, bad 2 games, and average 6 games vs a goalie who plays great 4 games and bad 6 games. It gives us a chance in 8 games vs 4.

Campbells gotta have a middle ground because he is such a polarizing goalie right now

That's right. It's an A game, or it slowly snowballs into an F game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aashir
The Leafs let two points get away against the Canucks. And the goalie question continues to grow | The Star

About Jack Jack Campbell allowed four or more goals for the sixth time in his last eight games. It wasn’t the response he was looking for in his first start since he allowed five on 25 shots last Saturday, before being pulled against Detroit.

Campbell, though, is trying to reverse a natural tendency to be hard on himself.

“I’ve been hard on myself and it’s snowballed lately,” the goalie said. “I’m trying to chill a bit more. I’m never happy giving up goals any time. But I appreciate the fans supporting me and the team, and I promise I’ll get out of it. Sometimes trying too hard isn’t the best thing. I’ll get it back, I promise."


“Obviously there was a bit of nerves tonight. I wanted this game badly, and I wanted it for (Simmonds) too. But I’m trying to critique my game more appropriately, instead of bashing it all the time.”

Campbell and Petr Mrázek have allowed more goals since Jan. 1 than any other current playoff team over that span. Toronto also ranks 28th with a .911 save percentage at five-on-five.

"There was a bit of nerves tonight" is very worrisome to hear in March. So he's telling us that his game is off, trying to hard etc etc....but on top of that he's also nervous coming into games? The nerves tonight will increase 100x for puck drop game 1.
 
This organization eats goalies alive. At least over the past 20 years or so. Jack is just the latest.

His only salvation is to sign elsewhere this summer and he'll look like Hasek by comparison to what he is now.

As for the team, I don't see Dubas making a move here so the Leafs only hope is that Jack somehow manages to get back into a groove before the playoffs so his head is right going into what will be an enormously important and therefore massively stressful first round for this team.

Different Leaf goalies have failed for different reasons, but the common denominator since the Phil Kessel trade is the Leafs are built primarily on offensive punch which puts more strain on the goaltending position. We ask more out of our goalies, gives them less defensive support. The Frederik Andersen trade was probably the one time we went out and got a fairly blue chip prime age goalie in net.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aashir and ToneDog
"There was a bit of nerves tonight" is very worrisome to hear in March. So he's telling us that his game is off, trying to hard etc etc....but on top of that he's also nervous coming into games? The nerves tonight will increase 100x for puck drop game 1.

He's over the hill now, but a guy like Jonathan Quick would be so refreshing to have in the goal position. The guy expects to win, battles to win and just has that A-type personality. I don't think we have a lot of those edgy competitor personalities and to have one in goal would be huge.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DraftSchmaft
He's over the hill now, but a guy like Jonathan Quick would be so refreshing to have in the goal position. The guy expects to win, battles to win and just has that A-type personality. I don't think we have a lot of those edgy competitor personalities and to have one in goal would be huge.

Quick has horrific stats. So does Peterson

Elvis has been bad. So has varlamov.
Ned has been brutal all year

Since the allstar game. Gibson has been worse than Campbell. Bob has been .882. Helley has been like .903 in a long stretch.

goaltending is nuts.


I really don’t know. Do we try to trade for Gibson/jelly/varlamov?

bank of husso or francouz as ufa?
Try to get a youngster like vanacek/hill?

teams that need goalies next year

1.) Colorado. 2.) Toronto. 3.) Chicago 4.) edmonton

with Pitt maybe trying to get fleury and Washington shopping.

If so that would put us 2-4 on the list

Kuemper. Husso. Francouz. Campbell fleury.
 
Quick has horrific stats. So does Peterson

Elvis has been bad. So has varlamov.
Ned has been brutal all year

Since the allstar game. Gibson has been worse than Campbell. Bob has been .882. Helley has been like .903 in a long stretch.

goaltending is nuts.


I really don’t know. Do we try to trade for Gibson/jelly/varlamov?

bank of husso or francouz as ufa?
Try to get a youngster like vanacek/hill?

teams that need goalies next year

1.) Colorado. 2.) Toronto. 3.) Chicago 4.) edmonton

with Pitt maybe trying to get fleury and Washington shopping.

If so that would put us 2-4 on the list

Kuemper. Husso. Francouz. Campbell fleury.

I'm not saying to get Quick now, but we could use a competitor like him as opposed to a guy who feels nerves during a home game in March...
 
  • Like
Reactions: HolyCrap
He's over the hill now, but a guy like Jonathan Quick would be so refreshing to have in the goal position. The guy expects to win, battles to win and just has that A-type personality. I don't think we have a lot of those edgy competitor personalities and to have one in goal would be huge.

I thought Mrazek was supposed to be one of those edgy competitor types.
 
Quick has horrific stats. So does Peterson

Elvis has been bad. So has varlamov.
Ned has been brutal all year

Since the allstar game. Gibson has been worse than Campbell. Bob has been .882. Helley has been like .903 in a long stretch.

goaltending is nuts.


I really don’t know. Do we try to trade for Gibson/jelly/varlamov?

bank of husso or francouz as ufa?
Try to get a youngster like vanacek/hill?

teams that need goalies next year

1.) Colorado. 2.) Toronto. 3.) Chicago 4.) edmonton

with Pitt maybe trying to get fleury and Washington shopping.

If so that would put us 2-4 on the list

Kuemper. Husso. Francouz. Campbell fleury.

Varlamov hasn't been all that bad, especially given how awful the Islanders have been this year.

I think behind this defense, he gets back to the .920-.925 he has been sporting recently. I don't know how clutch he can be in the playoffs, but he has made the Conference Finals each of the past two years... And we have a much better offense than the Islanders so we have the potential to beat the teams he lost to.

I think Varlamov is probably our best bet. The contract is right (2 years at 5 mill; not a rental) but it also brings down the price because not many teams can or probably will want him (or can afford him) at 5 mill. We can give them Mrazek, who can be a more cost appropriate tandem option with Sorokin, or we can move Mrazek to a team like EDM and give the Islanders an expiring Koskinen.

Generally, however, I think unless the Leafs can get Varlamov or maybe Fleury/Holtby/Gibson, they will run with Campbell/Mrazek.
 
Campbell is going to be another name in the growing list of goalies that have left Toronto only to re-discover their game elsewhere. At the end of the day this organizations failures in net come down to a few key points:
  • This market is extremely high pressure and tough on goalies especially
  • A f***ing moron for a goalie coach
  • A roster of players that refuse to play winning hockey
  • A GM with a flawed vision of how to build a winning team
It's no secret that Campbell lacks confidence. Those that know me know I've watched him for a long time, going back to his junior days. Campbell is one of the most talented goalies on the planet and one of the nicest guys around. The problem is he's extremely mentally fragile, and this team doesn't have the play style or coaching to support him. Quite frankly I'm shocked he played at the Vezina level he did for as long as he did with this team. But he's going to go to a team with competent off ice leadership like the Isles (barf) or Canucks or Wild and turn his career around yet again, while the goalie carousel in Toronto will continue to turn.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheGoldenJet
577320_10151289052771401_1720108445_n.jpg
 
Before he fell off a cliff, he was likely looking at the Lehner deal (5x5) in the open market

If he doesn't bounce back, 3x3 perhaps or Mrazek's deal (3x3.8) might be the best case scenario

Depending on how he finishes, teams may be reluctant to give as much of 3 years of term. May have to settle for an Andersen type "show me deal" at like 3 mil over just 1-2 years in length.
 
It seems like Campbell is losing sight of any action on the puck that forces him to adjust his line of sight from top to bottom and vice versa, ie. if the puck starts high and then goes low, or starts low and then goes high, he seems to lose sight of it.

Early on that didn't seem to make a difference.
I wonder if he has an eye or neck problem.

Agreed. They have to flush him.

No, he'd still make a good back-up goalie. He seems fine with rest and a goalie that can potentially go on a hot streak over a short term is great thing to have in a back-up, but that assumes it's not an injury issue.
 
Not sure if this is even a Campbell problem.
every year.....EVERY year for as long as I can remember. Leafs are great in the first half
then this is what we get in the 2nd half
question is.
Is this a Campbell problem?
or a Leafs problem?
 
Not sure if this is even a Campbell problem.
every year.....EVERY year for as long as I can remember. Leafs are great in the first half
then this is what we get in the 2nd half
question is.
Is this a Campbell problem?
or a Leafs problem?

Have the Leafs' played defense that deserves an .875 save percentage?

Have the Leafs still been putting together a 100 point pace in spite of the worst goaltending in the league since the start of 2022?

Seems like a Campbell problem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheGoldenJet

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad