It’s the annual overrated/underrated thread!

[TheDawnOfANewTage]

We usually have these every month or so, but we’ve had like 2 site crashes since the last one I can recall. And I’m actually curious- who do you consider overrated these days? What about underrated? Barkov (secretly low-key) had that crown for so long, but now everyone acknowledges him as great. So who it is this season?

For me:

Overrated: Rantanen, just a bit.
Underrated: Guentzel. Werenski. Anyone in CBJ doing thangs.

Also: whose stock has risen? Whose has fallen? It’s kinda tangentially related, curious about young players who are improving. Like Protas, but that’s an easy one.

 

[Bombshell11]

Overrated: Bedard
Underrated: +/-

 

[Kevinsane]

Underrated: Joey Daccord
Overrated: Auston Matthews

 

[nbwingsfan]

Overrated: Byfield, J.Hughes, Edvinsson (by our own fanbase)

Underrated: Bedard, Bratt, Marchenko

 

[Mr Nogatco]

Underrated: Nies
Overrated: Swayman

 

[Star Platinum]

We usually have these every month or so, but we’ve had like 2 site crashes since the last one I can recall. And I’m actually curious- who do you consider overrated these days?

Overrated: Xenforo Tech Support

 

[Dirty Dan]

Keller is 11th in scoring and no one cares cause his team has no name

 

[Kegs]

Keller is 11th in scoring and no one cares cause his team has no name

Keller is grossly under rated.

 

[BigDaddyLurch]

UNDERRATED: Angry Olli

OVERRATED: Post Counts/Likes

 

[Coffee]

Overrated: Honestly can’t really think of any good ones at the moment

Underrated: Canucks boards

 

[banks]

I'll try not to repeat names that were already mentioned.

Underrated: Nick Suzuki, Matt Duchene, Sebastian Aho, John Tavares, Jordan Kyrou, Nick Schmaltz, Teuvo Teravainen, Thomas Harley, Brock Faber.

Overrated: Roope Hintz, Zach Hyman, Jake DeBrusk, Steven Stamkos, Sam Bennett, Elias Lindholm.