Is Thornton the most underrated generational talent?
- Thread starter illpucks
- Start date
-
Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
He wasn't generational. Great player, first ballot HHOF. Unless you are calling guys like Yzerman, Sakic, etc generational and really expanding the term.
jetsforever
Registered User
- Dec 14, 2013
- 28,313
- 25,124
We definitely don't hear Drai as "generational".
Thornton isn't really either, although he's at the very top of the next tier.
Thornton isn't really either, although he's at the very top of the next tier.
JustaFinnishGuy
Joonas Donskoi avi but not a SEA fan ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
How does a player who wasn't generational for any year of his career become generational because he's decent at the end of his career?
Eternal Leaf
Registered User
tilly123123
Registered User
- Nov 7, 2018
- 129
- 154
No it’s becasue he’s a leaf now. You new around here !? Lol
Huokaus
Registered User
- Oct 29, 2010
- 1,163
- 695
8 Leafs threads in the first page 
But yeah, I haven't heard the word "generational" being tossed around for Drai, nor for Thornton for that matter. Players can be really good without being generational.
But yeah, I haven't heard the word "generational" being tossed around for Drai, nor for Thornton for that matter. Players can be really good without being generational.
He is not at the level of Crosby or Ovechkin by any stretch.
He’s just playing well...
And not being funny it’s against Ottawa and Matthews is on a 15 point streak - it’s just a scrimmage for them.
He’s just playing well...
And not being funny it’s against Ottawa and Matthews is on a 15 point streak - it’s just a scrimmage for them.
92 assists is post lockout record. Serious generational playmaking there. Combined with a 56 goal Cheechoo Rocket win over a 123 pt- 54 goal Jagr, and a 52 goal Ovi. Those guys didn't do anything like that. I know they are amazing players Sakic and Yzerman but I mean not like that stat.
92 assists say otherwise. 56 goal Cheechoo says otherwise. It was out of this planet. He's the best playmaker of the generation like Ovi is the best goal scorer of the generation. If Ovi is generational then Jumbo should be too.
What does generational even mean anymore? Seems like it’s thrown around way too often. “Franchise” and “generational” aren’t the same thing IMO.
Generational isn't a level at a certain trait. It's by being the clear best player of your generation. He's not ahead of Ovi or Crosby or Jagr of forwards he played against. Where he ranks next to Sakic and Yzerman is also highly debatable guys he played against for a few years. Great player, first ballot HHOF, will get his number retired in San Jose. But, not generational.
My thing is that I will say out of all the NHL players that have entered the league since 2005, Thornton is the best playmaker. He will beat all the best guys at playmaking in his prime. So to say he's not generational is just silly and overlooking that.
nowhereman
Registered User
He isn't close to generational.
Gretzky, Orr, Howe, Lemieux, Crosby, OV, Beliveau, McDavid and Hull are deserving of the term "generational". After that, you have guys like Sakic, Esposito, Clarke, Yzerman, Lidstrom and Potvin; incredible players but not quite at the very pinnacle of the sport. I'd have Thornton in the group after those guys.
Gretzky, Orr, Howe, Lemieux, Crosby, OV, Beliveau, McDavid and Hull are deserving of the term "generational". After that, you have guys like Sakic, Esposito, Clarke, Yzerman, Lidstrom and Potvin; incredible players but not quite at the very pinnacle of the sport. I'd have Thornton in the group after those guys.
Nona Di Giuseppe
Registered User
"generational playmaking"
get out with that garbage. a player is generational. one aspect of a player is not. it's not how the term is used. and just the fact henrik sedin was in the neighborhood illuminates how non-"generational" this is.
The Crypto Guy
Registered User
- Jun 26, 2017
- 29,010
- 38,389
he's good at goal scoring too but that isnt his role but hes actually quite elite at it
only knock on him is the no cups. if he has 2-3 cups hes probably up there with sid and geno in peoples convos
also if henrik and daniel were 1 player they might be generational the knock is because they are twins
Generational celebration potential if he ever pots 4.
Jesus Take the Wheel
Registered User
I always enjoy the exaggerated comments you combine with clips to try and prove a point
No thats probably not the best pass in nhl history (not that is matters because a 10 seconds clip is not evidence to prove a point about a players 20 years career)
No Thornton is not generational, he was not consistently considered the best player in the league at any time throughout his career
