Rask all day. Even though I know where this is coming from and I agree with OP in the other thread.
I started this thread mostly out of being unable to talk about these expectations of players in their player threads without critics being labeled haters or on the opposite side, fanboys.
We all want these guys to succeed, I'm not sure why there are people that think otherwise, we are just very vocal and passionate about our expectations and disappointments should they not be met.
With salary/impact factored in, here's my order.
My list is:
1. Rask, he is essentially the most important position, and top 3 salary in the league for the position. He had amazing stats in the beginning of the season, but mid-late season had some pretty awful stats. It all averaged out to mediocre stats, and a solid win line, but he's a Vezina quality goalie. That's my expectation of him. He's in the most important position on the ice. And that's heavy.
2. Krejci, close second, but he's top 10 salary in the position, he's the kind of guy that should make guys around him better, not the other way around. I'm likely harder on him due to his salary, but there's a reason he got the contract.
3. Backes, wasn't happy with the length, but I understand that's likely the cost to acquire him. I do expect more offense... and am worried it could become an anchor.
4. Bergeron, offensive stats down this year, but another Selke nomination, he's paid for more than just his offense. I do expect better offense output, but a little is negated with his defensive game.
5. Chara, with his age, and decreasing cap hit next year, my expectations aren't as high for him. Just hoping to give him a solid performance, and he's kind of all alone with rookies on a depleted d-core right now.