Trying to look at it objectively. He's played 14 seasons and has:
- Without going year by year and comparing him to the rest of the league, I'd say he has what are probably...
- 4 really good years
- 5 average to above average years
- 2 below average years
- 3 bad years
- He has 2 Vezina's.
- He is 14th all-time in regular season wins, just 4 shy of 400
- He's been a 1st team all-star just once
- Has not yet won a Cup
Yeah, I think he should be in the HHoF. I think it's close, but his career has been very good, he ranks highly all-time in wins, and has hardware. There have been worse goalies, never mind players, entered into the HHoF.