Habs Playoffs player evaluations

[HabsRealist]

How about this :

Impressed ( exceeded expectations ) :



Neutral ( met expectations ) :



Unimpressed ( didnt meet ) :

 

[Aznrx8]

Impressed ( exceeded expectations ) :

Bourque
Galchenyuk
Gallagher
Halpern
Subban

Neutral ( met expectations ) :

Plekanec
Price
Prust
Markov (Hard one here didn't expect him to be the go to guy anymore for a while)

Unimpressed ( didnt meet ) :

Ryder
Desharnais
Pacioretty
Gorges
Bouillon
Diaz
Moen

 

[Habsfan18]

Outside of Bourque, Galchenyuk, Subban and Gallagher, I haven't been impressed with anyone.

Desharnais, Markov, Pacioretty, Bouillon and Ryder have been especially terrible.

And Moen. I'm sorry, but that guy doesn't deserve to wear the CH.

 

[MikeHabs76]

Impressed:
Bourque
Gally
Chucky
Tinordi

Subban also has been great, but I expect that from him.

Neutral:
Gorges
Halpern
Armstrong
Blunden
Dumont
Prust
White
Diaz

Not good:
Bouillon
Ryder
Moen
Price

Very disappointed:
Markov

Utterly disgraceful:
Pacioretty
Desharnais


Should've just stuck Moen or Blunden with the last two for 5 minutes TOI, and put Gally with some people who want to play.

 

[HabsRealist]

Impressed with Tinordi ? He is just lost out there and plays like he is a foot shorter than Bouillon. This guy wont stick in the league, agree with McKeens scouting who has his upside as &th d-man, if he improves. Bergevin got a bit caught with lack of depth but overall he has been a great GM so far.

 

[Natey]

How about we don't talk about this until the playoffs are over? k thanks.

 

[Hannibal]

How about we don't talk about this until the playoffs are over? k thanks.

See you in 20 minutes.

 

[Et le But]

Impressed (exceeded expectations):
Bourque
Galchenyuk
Gallagher
Halpern
Subban
White
Armstrong

Neutral (met expectations) :
Plekanec
Price
Prust
Markov (I knew he wouldn't be very useful in this series)
Boullion (He's very bad but that's just him)
Tinordi (Not ready)
Moen

Unimpressed (didn't meet) :
Ryder
Desharnais
Pacioretty
Gorges
Diaz

Gionta has been bad but he was playing with a torn biceps. Ryder and Pacioretty better be injured too to justify their disgraceful play.

 

[HabsRealist]

Its over, especially if our top players keep pushing guys into our goalie.

 

[Natey]

See you in 20 minutes.

Nothing will be over in 20 minutes.

 

[onemorecup*]

Impressed ( exceeded expectations ) :

Bourque
Galchenyuk
Gallagher
Halpern
Subban

Neutral ( met expectations ) :

Plekanec
Price
Prust
Markov (Hard one here didn't expect him to be the go to guy anymore for a while)

Unimpressed ( didnt meet ) :

Ryder
Desharnais
Pacioretty
Gorges
Bouillon
Diaz
Moen

my opinions below

Bourque solid a keeper
Galchenyuk future superstar
Gallagher fluery version 2
Halpern see ya
Subban horse , our best player righ now

Neutral ( met expectations ) :

Plekanec as expected , so so payoffs vut good player
Price needs top step it up next year but top 5 in league
Prust just as advertised , grit , soild
Markov (Hard one here didn't expect him to be the go to guy anymore for a while)
time to tade him , cant play 5/5 , simply a pp dude now

Unimpressed ( didnt meet ) :

Ryder see ya
Desharnais GONZO OUR WORST PLAYER BAR NONE
Pacioretty stunk it up but a keeper , no one else to replace him with
Gorges one of the most overated D in the league , played like crap
Bouillon trash 7th d
Diaz SEE YA GET LOST
Moen[/QUOTE] SEE YA GET LOST

 

[Habs456]

Good:
Bourque
Subban
Armstrong
Halpern
Galchenyuk
Gallagher
White

Average
Price
Markov
Bouillon
Plekanec
Dumont

Bad
Budaj
Ryder
Tinordi
Gorges
Desharnais
Pac
Moen
Diaz

 

[Ezpz]

Impressed ( exceeded expectations ) :
Halpern
Bourque
Subban
Gallagher
Galchenyuk
White
Armstrong

Neutral ( met expectations ) :
Price
Plekanec
Pacioretty(would have put him below but he was injured)
Gionta(same as patches)
Moen
Dumont
Blunden
Eller(who knows what might have been)
Tinordi(would rather give him top pairing minutes in AHL than #6-7 minutes at NHL next year)
Markov

Unimpressed ( didnt meet ) :
Ryder
Desharnais
Prust(As good as he was regular season he took a TON of boneheaded penalties)
Gorges
Diaz
Bouillon
Budaj

 

[Analyzer*]

Outside of Bourque, Galchenyuk, Subban and Gallagher, I haven't been impressed with anyone.

Desharnais, Markov, Pacioretty, Bouillon and Ryder have been especially terrible.

And Moen. I'm sorry, but that guy doesn't deserve to wear the CH.

Why not ? Guy was physical when needed to be. Battled hard. He wasn't great, but I'd say Ryder (even with a goal), Diaz and Desharnais have been far more useless.

 

[llamateizer]

Impressed:
Bourque
Gally
Chucky
Tinordi
Subban
White


Neutral:
Halpern
Armstrong
Blunden
Dumont
Prust
Diaz

Not good:
Gorges
Bouillon
Ryder
Price
Markov
Plekanek

Wush wush wush
Desharnais

 

[Lionel Mandrake]

Impressed (exceeded expectations):
Bourque (Didn't know what to expect. Was pleasantly surprised. Let's hope that was just a sign of what's to come next year in his case)
Armstrong (expectations were very low, but played solid minutes)
Galchenyuk (I thought he might be overwhelmed. He wasn't. Shame on MT for not trusting him more over some struggling vets.
Subban (This guy is a gamer. Walks the MFing walk. Love the guts and the leadership)

Neutral (met expectations) :
Gallagher (Not a knock on him. I've just become so accustomed to his in your face blue colar play that I expect nothing less than greatness from this little turbocharged motor. Simply delivered)
Plekanec (I no longer expect Plekanec to be a scoring dynamo in the playoffs. Just solid all around with the occasional head scratching blunder)
Markov (Even in his prime, Markov never had a playoff gear)
Diaz (Got back from a long term injury just before the playoffs, what did people expect?)
Moen (was expecting what we got. Raised his level by about 4% and was generally a non factor)
Halpern (Still had gas left, not enough to think about a re-sign though)
White (His crazy side is much more helpful in a playoff environment)
Prust (Warrior. Would have loved to see what he could do without the bum shoulder)
Boullion (Boo's what he is. A mediocre #6. Not his fault when his importance and role are artificially increased by a lack of alternatives)

Unimpressed (didn't meet) :
Ryder (Even if I wasn't expecting a lot of hustle, I didn't think he would actually let the team down once the new contract boosting regular season stats were in the bank. This guy's a mercenary)
Price (underwhelmed by his demeanor in this series. Was playing and reacting like a goalie with an inferiority complex, always looking behind. The talent is there, but the questions about his mental game are starting to take the forefront, I don't like it - and I'm no hater)
Desharnais (Did one long term contract signature completely kill his game? Where's the urgency?)
Gionta (Thought the playoffs were where he'd make us forget a very lukewarm season. Just the end of his rope I fear)
Pacioretty (Needs to stop with the more complete player BS to explain his new artsy farty approach to the game. Crash the net for *******' sake!)
Gorges (This guy has to be playing hurt. Not the shadow of his former self)
Tinordi (I knew he needed to add some weight. Just didn't realize how much. Hit the gym Jarred! Now!)

 

[domdo345]

You guys really impressed with Tinordi? I know he's young and it's alright and no worries but he sucked lol...BADDD gap control, terrible first pass, lost his guys many times (like the Zibanejad soccer goal) and not that physical. This guy really needs some AHL playoffs next year. Of course, paired with Bouillon only agravated the whole thing.

 

[MyNameIsNobody*]

Impressed with Tinordi ? He is just lost out there and plays like he is a foot shorter than Bouillon. This guy wont stick in the league, agree with McKeens scouting who has his upside as &th d-man, if he improves. Bergevin got a bit caught with lack of depth but overall he has been a great GM so far.

I agree with you 1000%. People on this board lambasted me for thinking the same. If I were montreal I would try to package him in a trade for a strong big nasty defence man

Tinordi is slower than Hal gill

If this guy is depended on in the future we are in trouble. And for you people who think he's the second coming of chelios all I have to say is , did you watch him play today??? He was awful.

 

[Ezpz]

I agree with you 1000%. People on this board lambasted me for thinking the same. If I were montreal I would try to package him in a trade for a strong big nasty defence man

Tinordi is slower than Hal gill

If this guy is depended on in the future we are in trouble. And for you people who think he's the second coming of chelios all I have to say is , did you watch him play today??? He was awful.

wat. lol

 

[HabsSlappy]

Impressed:
Gallagher
Galchenyuk
Prust
Subban
White
Bourque
Eller (I'm sure he would be there had he played more)

Neutral:
Tinordi
Markov
Halpern
Plekanec
Armstrong
Moen

Not Impressed:
Desharnais
Pacioretty
Gionta
Ryder
Gorges
Diaz
Bouillon
Price
Budaj

 

[MyNameIsNobody*]

You guys really impressed with Tinordi? I know he's young and it's alright and no worries but he sucked lol...BADDD gap control, terrible first pass, lost his guys many times (like the Zibanejad soccer goal) and not that physical. This guy really needs some AHL playoffs next year. Of course, paired with Bouillon only agravated the whole thing.

People on this board put tinordi in the impressed catagory, they are blinded by his 6.7 inche skinny ass frame. Guy is SLOW SLOW SLOW got beat badly tonight.

Lolllll

 

[Guilliam]

I agree with you 1000%. People on this board lambasted me for thinking the same. If I were montreal I would try to package him in a trade for a strong big nasty defence man

Tinordi is slower than Hal gill

If this guy is depended on in the future we are in trouble. And for you people who think he's the second coming of chelios all I have to say is , did you watch him play today??? He was awful.

Lost all credibility there dude.

Even his detractors agree that Tinordi skates well.

 

[domdo345]

Lost all credibility there dude.

Even his detractors agree that Tinordi skates well.

he skates well for a big guy but his gap control was awwwwful. So either he lacks confidence, or his skating is just not NHL playoffs ready yet. Either way, he backed off way too much and gave the blue line easily.

 

[Habskrieg]

Impressed ( exceeded expectations ) :
Bourque
Gallagher
Galchenyuk
Tinordi
Subban
Prust

Neutral ( met expectations ) :
Plekanec
Markov
Moen
Armstrong
White
Price

Unimpressed ( didnt meet ) :
Pacioretty
Desharnais
Gorges
Diaz
Bouillon
Ryder

 

[MyNameIsNobody*]

Lost all credibility there dude.

Even his detractors agree that Tinordi skates well.

You will see. He will not stick around next year. No matter how much you want to believe


So long suckers.