GM/Franchise mode - does anyone else play all the games without simulation? | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

GM/Franchise mode - does anyone else play all the games without simulation?

Maco

Registered User
May 15, 2017
12
0
I haven't posted in any forums for about 8 years, so I felt like sharing my past few years of playing Be A GM.

If you have no interest in my boring GM history, then my main question in a nutshell is: Have you ever played all 82 games + playoffs yourself, and how many seasons?

Anyway, before I purchased PS4 + NHL17, I had only played NHL 11, 12, 13 & 14. I played NHL14 for over 2 years only having one Be a GM save with the Nashville Predators.

I ended up grinding the save for over 14 seasons in which I played every single game myself. What kept me going was checking real life individual + team records and trying to beat them in the game. Playoff games were around 10 min periods with goal scoring sliders low and goalie sliders almost as high as you can get. Reg season games were the usual 5-6 mins. Back in NHL 14 I think you only had 6 different options with the sliders as opposed to the current 100.

After every season I had to adjust the sliders to make the game more difficult. Towards the end it didn't matter what I did with the sliders, or how much I tried to avoid scoring glitch goals, losing just seemed impossible. I suppose one of my mistake was making too many unrealistic trades that made my team "too good".

Among superstar level, I had to make the CPU 30% faster in skating, 100% stronger/more affective in body/stick-checking, take their fatigue effect off and bump my players' fatigue effect and speed to the max etc. I'm probably not that much better than an average player online, but I ended up being pretty good against the CPU's lol.

The first 9 seasons were tight enough to keep the excitement. Made the playoffs every year and won "only" 2-3 Stanley Cups, but through seasons 10-14 I won all 5 Stanley Cups. Perhaps motivated by my 9th season (still remember this one) where I lost 4-0 against the Oilers in the first round after a 130 point regular season.
In my first season I signed Ilya Kovalchuk as a free agent (this was the year he had left the league irl) and he scored around 1100 career goals (Atlanta + New Jersey goals included). He was our captain as a 45-46 year old when I quit the save. My favorite player was Joe Thornton, whom I always sign with any team I play with no matter what. I have this subconscious rule that I can only pass with him and he ended up assisting probably half of Kovalchuk's goals. I also Signed Erik Karlsson when he was 33 years old and I was able to score 135 points with him in his best season. That was 3 points shy of the real life record points in a season by a defenseman. I also had a goalie named Victor Corson who at some point broke the real life consecutive clean sheet record. I think I was able to keep the doors shut for about 250 minutes, but I can't remember the exact amount.

After finally getting bored with PS3 and NHL 14, I started my first Be A GM in NHL 17 (superstar + AI difficulty 6/6 etc) with the Jets and in my first season I missed the playoffs for the first time in my (around) 25 season GM history since NHL 11. A win in my last reg season game would have earned me the last Western conference playoff spot, but ironically, I lost 2-1 against the Predators. As much as I was frustrated, I was also excited that after all these years I would finally have to think about actually improving my team to get to the playoffs, instead of just trading for the sake of it.
I'm in my second season now and I signed Tyler Johnson and Alex Semin as free agents and traded Trouba + a disappointing Hellebuyck for Matt Murray & Mark Streit. Both have been better than their trades were and Johnson + Semin seem to be clutch players for whatever reason.
I just made the Conference finals today. Subconsciously I'm hoping I wont win the cup just yet, so that eventually winning the Cup would feel more rewarding. What's rewarding however, is that Joe Thronton lead the league in assists this season after being a disappointment in his first.

Phew, just had to get all that out there :laugh:

I'm curious if anyone else has gone through a massive save like that and eventually learning the CPU too well to lose regardless of what you do with your sliders?
 
Nah, I feel like it's cheating a bit, I like to see how my trades and signings work out in the sim. I do play the third period of about 10-15 games though just for fun at random points in the season because I do enjoy playing with my team I built. Playoffs are a big no though because that's also kind of unfair, I'm not trying to be cocky but I'd win every game (I play on the highest setting at full sim) I don't find it fun to play every game and playoff games but that's just me
 
Wow. I could never do that. I end up starting and stopping a new franchise about 100+ times over.

What I recently found worked best for me was simulating the first 3/4 of a season. Then I'll make a few trades depending on where I am in the standings and play the rest of the year. It adds a little bit more fun for me because those games might make a difference in the standings. I do the same in the playoffs, only playing games 6 & 7.

The hardest thing for me to figure out is what to do at the end of that season. I need to figure out a spreadsheet or something to track everything

Kudos to you for grinding out that many years!!
 
I suppose it's which way you start playing. For me simming feels like cheating since normally I play every game haha. I just enjoy playing the game and doing all the GM stuff, so it feels like a good mix doing both. Sometimes I feel the simulation just gets too random and your GM work feels less important.
However when playing NHL 17 I feel the EA's coding for late drama makes the game almost decide whether you win or not, or a least increases/decreases your odds by a lot during the end of the game. Also for some reason I seem to score every time with a player that I bring to the roster after being scratched. My last playoff game against Colorado for instance (this has happened almost 50% of the time in other games as well), I scored a breakaway goal with 78 overall stay at home defenseman Mark Stuart after he had sat out half of the season and I had never scored with him before... In the same game Colorado scored two goals in the last minute to force the game into OT.
My favorite one however was against Vancouver, scoring an empty net goal with 18 seconds left in the 3rd and eventually losing the game in OT. Just in my current playoff run I've conceded a goal with 1,0 seconds left, tied the game with 1 minute left and scored the winner with 10 seconds left in the same game and so on. I've conceded 2,4 GA per game and about 25% of the goals I've conceded are scored in the last minute.

Btw, in NHL 14 after around season 2018, all the newly drafted players never grew past 81 overall. Mine or CPU players. Is that a common "glitch" or was there just something wrong with my save? Seasons 2020-2028 ended up being dominated by 30-38 vets, because none of the younger "fake" players grew past 4th line/AHL top line stats. Also, the best forwards would have all have their shooting and passing stats as 99, but every other stat 60-80.
 
These days I'll mostly sim by the period, and if a game goes to overtime/shootout I'll think about jumping in.

I do like to play a few games at the start of a season to get a feel for the team I have, and in playoff elimination games when I feel like it.

I'm not as good as a lot of you seem to be so I can still lose the games I intervene in.

Actually I just finished my preparations for a new GM mode (jersey testing took forever) where in some alternate timeline the Arizona Coyotes and Carolina Hurricanes are replaced by the powerhouses Osaka Dynasty and Kyoto Shockwaves respectively.
 
A big issue with the game for years has been the inability to lower the regular season length. Very few people have the patience or interest to play 82 straight games in order to get through a season. 20something would be perfect because with periods set to a more realistic 8-10 minutes and custom sliders, a normal person could realistically play a game or two a night or a few games on the weekend and have the season mode keep their interest since they'd be progressing through the season at a reasonable pace.
 
I usually get about 5-10 games in then either get bored and SIM the season or I start all over. Franchise mode is just boring now.
 
I use NHL as a supplement to my exercise regime. So I have a recumbent bike set up in front of hte projector and I play every game through multiple seasons. Not so hard if you knock out 4 games a day, 3-4 times a week.
 
I am currently about 30 games into my second season. I play as the Sabres and I have played all games up to this point.

Last season I ended up finishing with about the 8th pick. It was really similar to the actual Sabres. I am ok at the game and play on Superstar.

This season with Eichel (92), Reinhart (90) and Ristolainen (91) with huge increases in OVR, I am killing it and 2nd in the conference. My team looks like this:

Girgensons-Eichel-Nylander
Bailey-O'Reilly-Okposo
Carrier-Reinhart-Baptiste
Foligno-Larsson-Fasching

McCabe-Ristolainen
Jake Larsson-Anthony DeAngelo
Guhle-Justin Schultz

My Centers are insane. I love rocking that Center spine.
 
I usually start one every year where I play every game but rarely make it past the second season. Last time I made it to the third season and beyond was probably back on 06 or 07. Part of the reason for that is that I have never not won the cup in any season I have played no matter how much I jack up the difficulty. That changed this year with NHL 17 as my Blue Jackets got knocked out in the second round by Philly. It got me really excited to improve my team for year two, and I made several significant moves over the offseason to do so inlcuding trading for Duchene and RFA Neiddereiter as I didn't have the picks to make an offer sheet. Just like OP with his new additions these two players have been very clutch for me. I just passed the deadline and I have been competing for the President's all season, however Duchene just went down with a season ending injury with a stat line of 29 goals 29 assists for 58 points in 59 games and leaving me pretty thin on center depth.

I'll edit this post with my lines when I get home later.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad