Value of: Garnet Hathaway to NYR at 50% Retained

[LaffyTaffy13]

I think for the rangers, a team who by all accounts want to go for it these next 2 years, hes the type of 4th line player they need.

What would philly want for him at 50% retained? And yes I recognize theyd be eating money in 2024-2025 as well.

Would Philly take something along the lines of

A) 2024 1st round pick

B) 2024 2nd and Zac Jones

I get hes only got 2G/1A this year but love his game and Lavi likes him alot.

Click to read more...

 

[jaywills1020]

You don’t trade a 1st for Hathaway even if he was 75% retained.

 

[EK392000]

You don’t trade a 1st for Hathaway even if he was 75% retained.

You don’t trade a first for Hathaway even if he’s 100% retained.

 

[mightyquack]

How many draft picks do you need to throw in so that he comes with a spit hood?

 

[usahockey22flyers]

Yes

Yes

 

[Silky mitts]

He got traded for roughly a 2nd last year at $1.5M and was scoring twice as much

 

[SnS]

Torts is obsessed with the guy. He won’t approve a trade for anything.

 

[LaffyTaffy13]

He got traded for roughly a 2nd last year at $1.5M and was scoring twice as much

At 50% retained youre asking philly to eat about $1.5ish mill. Theres a cost to that

 

[DingDongCharlie]

2nd and a 3rd with the retention should be the ceiling.

 

[Larry Hanson]

Always like Hathaway and wish the Flames would have somehow kept him but these valuations are crazy. At 50% retained his cap hit is what it should be to start with.

 

[litflyersfan]

I think for the rangers, a team who by all accounts want to go for it these next 2 years, hes the type of 4th line player they need.

What would philly want for him at 50% retained? And yes I recognize theyd be eating money in 2024-2025 as well.

Would Philly take something along the lines of

A) 2024 1st round pick

Briere in his office after pulling this one off

 

[Black Tank]

Why would the Rangers consider this right now? They're playing well, guys like Brodz and Jones have stepped in when needed and contributed and they're physically abusing opponents on most nights. Maybe injuries change the analysis but for now they don't need to give up assets for guys like Hathaway.

 

[GAGLine]

At 50% retained youre asking philly to eat about $1.5ish mill. Theres a cost to that

There's no reason to be paying that cost. There are other, cheaper options.

 

[Flyer lurker]

I think for the rangers, a team who by all accounts want to go for it these next 2 years, hes the type of 4th line player they need.

What would philly want for him at 50% retained? And yes I recognize theyd be eating money in 2024-2025 as well.

Would Philly take something along the lines of

A) 2024 1st round pick

B) 2024 2nd and Zac Jones

I get hes only got 2G/1A this year but love his game and Lavi likes him alot.

1) Hayes is all ready retained and between Walker and Hathaway value Walker for sure will get more and save the retainage there. Dream scenario is Cam Atkinson is traded at 50% for 2 years.

Of course flyers would retain for a 1 but that ain't happening.

2) Hathaway won't get a 1. Doubt its a 2. If offer is ranger 2024 2 for GH and a 4 you got him. Maybe a 2026 3 and 6?

 

[pld459666]

Rangers were interested in signing him, but at a cost similar to Wheeler and Gustafsson.

He made the better financial decision and signed with Philly.

Not sure where he would fit and for similar production at less than half the cost, we have sold 4th liners in Pitlick and Bonino. Plus we already have our own overpaid 4th liner in Goodrow. No need in adding another.

The Hathaway ship has sailed.

 

[ponder719]

Yeah, moving Hathaway shouldn’t be a problem from Philly’s perspective, but we have better/more important pieces to use our remaining retention slots on, even if that reduces the return.

 

[Mrfenn92]

Torts ain’t letting it happen. Anytime it’s mentioned torts goes something like this

 

[SingnBluesOnBroadway]

I think for the rangers, a team who by all accounts want to go for it these next 2 years, hes the type of 4th line player they need.

What would philly want for him at 50% retained? And yes I recognize theyd be eating money in 2024-2025 as well.

Would Philly take something along the lines of

A) 2024 1st round pick

B) 2024 2nd and Zac Jones

I get hes only got 2G/1A this year but love his game and Lavi likes him alot.

Dear God no.

 

[BackToTheBrierePatch]

You can have him for a 7th round pick. No take backs either

I think for the rangers, a team who by all accounts want to go for it these next 2 years, hes the type of 4th line player they need.

What would philly want for him at 50% retained? And yes I recognize theyd be eating money in 2024-2025 as well.

Would Philly take something along the lines of

A) 2024 1st round pick

B) 2024 2nd and Zac Jones

I get hes only got 2G/1A this year but love his game and Lavi likes him alot.

As K said in Men in Black, “you really need to lay off the sauce”

 

[bernmeister]

I think for the rangers, a team who by all accounts want to go for it these next 2 years, hes the type of 4th line player they need.

What would philly want for him at 50% retained? And yes I recognize theyd be eating money in 2024-2025 as well.

Would Philly take something along the lines of

A) 2024 1st round pick

B) 2024 2nd and Zac Jones

I get hes only got 2G/1A this year but love his game and Lavi likes him alot.

NO
stop w/win now bs that doesn't work

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

At 50% retained youre asking philly to eat about $1.5ish mill. Theres a cost to that

There is, but It's not a 1st round pick.

NO
stop w/win now bs that doesn't work

Vegas, and TB disagree

 

[Clark Kellogg]

I think for the rangers, a team who by all accounts want to go for it these next 2 years, hes the type of 4th line player they need.

What would philly want for him at 50% retained? And yes I recognize theyd be eating money in 2024-2025 as well.

Would Philly take something along the lines of

A) 2024 1st round pick

B) 2024 2nd and Zac Jones

I get hes only got 2G/1A this year but love his game and Lavi likes him alot.

I wouldn’t care if Laviolette was dating him.
No, that’s a massive overpay.

 

[One Winged Angel]

I suggested Hathaway would be a trade target on my Twitter and podcast a few weeks back. I don’t think the cost should be that high, even with retention.

 

[bernmeister]

....
Vegas, and TB disagree

Isolated exceptions prove the rule
bern is correct

 

[cwede]

I think for the rangers, a team who by all accounts want to go for it these next 2 years, hes the type of 4th line player they need.

What would philly want for him at 50% retained? And yes I recognize theyd be eating money in 2024-2025 as well.

Would Philly take something along the lines of

A) 2024 1st round pick

B) 2024 2nd and Zac Jones

I get hes only got 2G/1A this year but love his game and Lavi likes him alot.

NYR don't have a 4th line need
w Kakko and Chytil injuries, IF they add upfront,
more likely a shoot-first winger or another C