Five members from Canada’s 2018 world junior team (Hart, McLeod, Dube, Foote and Formenton) told to surrender to police, facing sexual assault charges

Status
Not open for further replies.

Melrose Munch

Registered User
Mar 18, 2007
24,187
2,312
My posts tell a story of due process. That is what is directed by law.

Do we have a bunch of privileged animals raping, or an Amber Heard type girl ?

BTW - I'm kinda leaning towards animals, BUT we should keep an open mind and respect due process.
This is not a courtroom lol. I learn towards the first. Remember she didn't bring this up, the press did.
 

Gregor Samsa

Registered User
Sep 5, 2020
4,488
5,101
Anyone think the NHL forced the players to take an indefinite leave that way they don’t have to make a ruling on a suspension right now? Everyone’s contract is up soon but any chance the NHL does something with that or do they just not get resigned?
 

Melrose Munch

Registered User
Mar 18, 2007
24,187
2,312
Also the costs of the defendents, because that would be a very stupid lawsuit with zero perspective of success from what we know and no way they don't end up alao footing the bill.
It's exactly what some famous guy did recently and it didn't work out for him!

Anyone think the NHL forced the players to take an indefinite leave that way they don’t have to make a ruling on a suspension right now? Everyone’s contract is up soon but any chance the NHL does something with that or do they just not get resigned?
I think the players just left and the NHL found out the same time we did, which is even worse.
 

TopC0rner

Registered User
Feb 21, 2018
722
682
Do we have a bunch of privileged animals raping, or an Amber Heard type girl ?
Amber Heard is a very specific case. She used her public platform to make public claims and that in itself puts her in a special spot regarding slander. Also, the slander case isn't in Canada for multiple reasons (slander cases in Canada are tough to win and the payouts are slim compared to the USA).

You can't just sue someone in Canada because they gave a testimony that paints you badly in a criminal case. Well you could, but it will get dismissed easily. In Canada, in rare cases, the Crown will press charges against a witness who they deem has made a false testimony in criminal court.
 

oilexport

Registered User
Aug 29, 2010
2,082
692
This is not a courtroom lol. I learn towards the first. Remember she didn't bring this up, the press did.
We don't really know why the case was reopened. Was it the press and public outrage, or the alleged victim who found the strength to go through a potentially difficult process to get justice.

The case was dropped initially....

We need to have due process.

If in fact these guys did half of what is alleged, I'm all for a revamp of HC.

Abuse has no place in my world.
 

Melrose Munch

Registered User
Mar 18, 2007
24,187
2,312
We don't really know why the case was reopened. Was it the press and public outrage, or the alleged victim who found the strength to go through a potentially difficult process to get justice.

The case was dropped initially....

We need to have due process.

If in fact these guys did half of what is alleged, I'm all for a revamp of HC.

Abuse has no place in my world.
HC probably has to go. Given that this isn't the only case, it will happen again.

Junior hockey should be on its last warning. Not allowing 18-year-olds in the AHL is a big part of why it still exists.
 

93LEAFS

Registered User
Nov 7, 2009
34,228
21,426
Toronto
HC probably has to go. Given that this isn't the only case, it will happen again.

Junior hockey should be on its last warning. Not allowing 18-year-olds in the AHL is a big part of why it still exists.
Hockey Canada looks terrible, but the NCAA has an even worse track record than them. So, I'm not really sure what works as an alternative development path for North American talent.
 

JoeGarelli

Registered User
Jun 24, 2013
431
210

RegDunlop

Registered User
Nov 5, 2016
3,873
4,180
Edmonton
As someone posted already


Not a single mention. And that is why it must be torn down.

How weak...chickenbleep...I hope the media goes nuclear on the NHL.

I've idolized the NHL through Hockey Night in Canada, going to many games, meeting my heros when I was young, teaching my kids about the history, spending a lot on merch, etc. For over 50 years this game has been poetic for me as a player, father, coach, and fan.

I'm pretty much finished thinking (dreaming?) anything positive about our hockey culture here, the ridiculous non transparency - and outright unlawful - actions from. Hockey Canada, and the blatant cover ups and looking away from the NHL.

I'll always watch, play, and love this sport. But these allegations, check that, maybe not just these allegations but everything else dirty from different organizations that these incidents are unveiling, have disgusted me so much that I wouldn't even be opposed to tearing down not only HC but the whole junior and professional systems if all that is said to be true actually is. A reset is needed.
 

RegDunlop

Registered User
Nov 5, 2016
3,873
4,180
Edmonton
Doubt they knew beforehand charges were being laid. Guessing they took Dube at his word, he left before anyone else did.

Flames organization is between a rock and a hard place. They cant be happy at all. They wouldnt of released a statement about Dube going on mental health leave unless thats what they were told. Now they cant say anything because charges have been laid and the NHL will also have told them not to. I dont blame the team, I blame Dube.

"They wouldn't of released a statement about Dube going on mental health leave unless thats what they were told"

Told by whom? Dube's camp? And they just take the only player on there team that they know to be caught up in this scandal at his word? No questions? No inquiry? Bullshit

McLeod had a so so reputation.

Michael McLeod? How so?
 
Last edited:

Melrose Munch

Registered User
Mar 18, 2007
24,187
2,312
"They wouldnt of released a statement about Dube going on mental health leave unless thats what they were told"

Told by whom? Dube's camp? And they just take the other player on there team that they know to be caught up in this scandal at his word? No questions? No inquiry? Bullshit



Michael McLeod? How so?
In Mississauga at junior he was kind of one of those guys who was a party animal, always getting in trouble for those things. I heard rumors years ago, but he was always coming up for the wrong reasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RegDunlop

RegDunlop

Registered User
Nov 5, 2016
3,873
4,180
Edmonton
Methinks this is all going to be a lot bigger than if 5 guys are found guilty and get to play more hockey. This is the start of a big change — when this is said and done, “hockey culture” is going to be extinct. I can’t see how society is going to tolerate any more of what we all have heard that has gone on for decades in hockey (I.e disgusting hazing rituals, bullying, alleged sexual assaults like this one). This case broke the camel’s back.

This may be true.
I'm a lifer in this sport and this is finally my ground zero
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tryamw

Melrose Munch

Registered User
Mar 18, 2007
24,187
2,312
I've idolized the NHL through Hockey Night in Canada, going to many games, meeting my heros when I was young, teaching my kids about the history, spending a lot on merch, etc. For over 50 years this game has been poetic for me as a player, father, coach, and fan.

I'm pretty much finished thinking (dreaming?) anything positive about our hockey culture here, the ridiculous non transparency - and outright unlawful - actions from. Hockey Canada, and the blatant cover ups and looking away from the NHL.

I'll always watch, play, and love this sport. But these allegations, check that, maybe not just these allegations but everything else dirty from different organizations that these incidents are unveiling, have disgusted me so much that I wouldn't even be opposed to tearing down not only HC but the whole junior and professional systems if all that is said to be true actually is. A reset is needed.
I 1000 percent agree with you again.

But I think for many, basketball and football are knocking at the door. All it takes is another lockout...

Hockey Canada looks terrible, but the NCAA has an even worse track record than them. So, I'm not really sure what works as an alternative development path for North American talent.
We have to figure out something.

Why is it every other sport's "elite" compeition is within high schools, but not hockey?
 

93LEAFS

Registered User
Nov 7, 2009
34,228
21,426
Toronto
In Mississauga at junior he was kind of one of those guys who was a party animal, always getting in trouble for those things. I heard rumors years ago, but he was always coming up for the wrong reasons.
I've heard mixed things. The staff generally liked him, at least until the end of his tenure there (Sean Day drove them absolutely insane). I have heard multiple times nightmare hockey parents (although, by that standard don't get them started on "assistant coach" Michael Nylander). I don't think anyone would have guessed this is where it would end up.
 

RegDunlop

Registered User
Nov 5, 2016
3,873
4,180
Edmonton
I wish I could say the same about my team.

It's as if the GM said... You know what, I'm going to go all in. Hard to believe they didn't know this about Foote being a possible implicated player.

They did.
Don't feel bad. EVERY team owner and management knew all about the situation and who was involved for years. I'm an avid Oiler fan - currently shitting on the Flames for their ridiculous PR, but I can assure you that Edm, NYR, Colorado, Vegas, etc, etc, etc, would have had these players on their teams as easily as you guys have. This was NOT supposed to come out.
 
Last edited:

93LEAFS

Registered User
Nov 7, 2009
34,228
21,426
Toronto
I 1000 percent agree with you again.

But I think for many, basketball and football are knocking at the door. All it takes is another lockout...


We have to figure out something.

Why is it every other sport's "elite" compeition is within high schools, but not hockey?
I would think that's more a Canada compared to the USA thing. High-school sports aren't supported or cared about to the same level in Canada as the States. Most Canadian kids really good at Basketball go to those joke prep-schools in the States to get scouted and play high-level AAU. I believe both travel baseball and travel soccer are the ways to get scouted for those sports here too.
 

Melrose Munch

Registered User
Mar 18, 2007
24,187
2,312
I've heard mixed things. The staff generally liked him, at least until the end of his tenure there (Sean Day drove them absolutely insane). I have heard multiple times nightmare hockey parents (although, by that standard don't get them started on "assistant coach" Michael Nylander). I don't think anyone would have guessed this is where it would end up.
Me neither, but I got a bad feeling when I first heard about this and his name was there on the roster. Kind of a shock for me too, but you never really know eh?

I would think that's more a Canada compared to the USA thing. High-school sports aren't supported or cared about to the same level in Canada as the States. Most Canadian kids really good at Basketball go to those joke prep-schools in the States to get scouted and play high-level AAU. I believe both travel baseball and travel soccer are the ways to get scouted for those sports here too.
Fair enough. Not a fan of AAU either to be honest. Something has to change. We don't need Hockey Canada if this is the way they do things.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tryamw

VivaLasVegas

Registered User
Sponsor
Jun 21, 2021
8,394
9,012
Lost Wages, Nevada
We don't really know why the case was reopened.
Seems like the criminal investigation got a boost in November right after HC completed its (unreleased) final report, which could possibly suggest that certain incriminating evidence such as witness statements not previously available to law enforcement were referenced in the report, or other facts in the report lead to law enforcement obtaining new incriminating evidence. At least, such has been my impression of what happened. But as you say, we really don't know and quite possibly will not know until the trial begins.

 

93LEAFS

Registered User
Nov 7, 2009
34,228
21,426
Toronto
Me neither, but I got a bad feeling when I first heard about this and his name was there on the roster. Kind of a shock for me too, but you never really know eh?


Fair enough. Not a fan of AAU either to be honest. Something has to change. We don't need Hockey Canada if this is the way they do things.
I would say in general we just have a problem with how sports organizations/high level youth athletes get covered for. I'm not sure high-schools or the NCAA would do a better job, especially if there is a profit incentive. I'm sure if people just looked at what has been covered up in power 5 conferences, people would collectively lose their minds. Hell, just look at Baylor which was supposed to be a prestigous religious private school, and look what they did to keep their football team on the field. I'm sure someone digging deep into powerhouse High-school football or basketball teams have horror stories.
 

Panthers Propaganda

We're a team
Oct 28, 2015
4,859
4,686
Canada
Within this case there is a discussion to be had about the repugnant hockey culture that Canada has bred in a lot of our youth.

A significant portion of the kids coming up now act like they are God’s gift to this earth more concerned about racking up their snap score than anything. Hell, it was well known that most of my hometowns WHL roster had another side piece in practically every city they play in. At least once a month someone’s girlfriend caught them on Tinder in the next town over. Most felt they were untouchable in school as well behaved like shit with minimal effort because they were for sure making the show.

Not one Canadian who has had an interaction with a Junior A player should be shocked.

Hard to believe that a sport that refers to female fans as puck-bunnies has a culture issue.

As a guy who grew up playing a lot of different sports, hockey included I can’t really think of one with a worse culture.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad