Value of: Evans deadline or sooner?
- Thread starter Goal Caufield50
- Start date
Dr Quincy
Registered User
- Jun 19, 2005
- 29,389
- 11,751
Best case scenario a 3rd. But only because teams overpay at the deadline.
I would retain him unless a second or equivalent was available. Give a Laval pivot like beck a chance
really? with Dvorak also 100% gone, who plays Cs?
suzuki, Dach (who's still not in game shape) and ....Rookies?
They'll try to resign Evans and they certainly aren't trading him for a 3rd.
guaranteed.
They have 7 picks in the 1st 3 rounds
Last edited:
General Fanager
Registered User
Id resign Evans. Trade Dvo or let him walk.
NinjaTurtle
Registered User
I’d offer Jakob Pelletier and a 4th round pick for Evans. Would love to upgrade the 4th line centre position on the Flames and think he could contribute over the next few seasons in the bottom 6 (assuming we’d resign him before offseason).
He's one of the best 4th line centers in the league which has value but its still 4th line.
Early 3rd/ very late 2nd round pick value I think.
Early 3rd/ very late 2nd round pick value I think.
Slightly less than Lars Eller fetches
Slightly more than Nico Sturm fetches
Jakob Pelletier is small and has not shown he can be effective as an NHL player- but he's French!!! Sorry, but Jakob Pelletier and a 4th-round pick isn't going to get it done. The Habs will re-sign Evans if they can come to a mutually agreeable deal, or they will wait for a better offer.
NinjaTurtle
Registered User
Yeah, I knew this would be the reaction. Worth a try, and it could be the starting point in a trade negotiation. Flames really aren’t in a position to overpay for a rental, but if they thought he was a part of the future and would resign reasonably I could see a better offer to the Habs.
A pick and or a prospect I suppose , but at some point we have to stop rebuilding and start building . A player like Evans in the bottom six can be just as important as players like Suzuki , Caufield or Dach in the top six . IMO the Habs should try to resign him .
He's starting to play like he was before the Scheifele hit. He could still become a good 3rd line C.
CanadienShark
Registered User
- Dec 18, 2012
- 40,075
- 14,771
That's a shit offer. Better to keep him.
HuGort
Registered User
I would hold out for a first. If I couldn't get it - sign him. He's good 4th line center
Dr Quincy
Registered User
- Jun 19, 2005
- 29,389
- 11,751
Bouboumaster
Registered User
- Jul 4, 2014
- 10,826
- 9,319
pth2
Registered User
- Jan 7, 2018
- 3,495
- 2,772
I'd rather re-sign him than get some picks.
If moved, I expect a 2nd and a 4th or similar value.
If moved, I expect a 2nd and a 4th or similar value.
HabsWhiteKnightLOL
Registered User
Habs should keep Evans. seems like a no brainer , all those teams need a 4th line center than can play PK and do faceoffs
I was looking at the advanced analytics for the Habs today and it's a nightmare of bad performances by the vast majority of that roster.
But Evans and Dvoark are actually two of the rare exceptions to the analytics fiasco that is the 2024-25 Habs.
If Evans can play relatively well on this ish-show of a team... Is this the type guy that probably plays even better on a team that doesn't stink?
Dvorak may also fit into that bucket.
I'd be interested in either of these guys if the Habs put them on the market.
The Habs may want to think about resigning one or both of them.
But Evans and Dvoark are actually two of the rare exceptions to the analytics fiasco that is the 2024-25 Habs.
If Evans can play relatively well on this ish-show of a team... Is this the type guy that probably plays even better on a team that doesn't stink?
Dvorak may also fit into that bucket.
I'd be interested in either of these guys if the Habs put them on the market.
The Habs may want to think about resigning one or both of them.
Dvorak is available for cheap.
For Evans, you need an offer the Habs can't refuse unless Evans prices himself out on an extension.
HugeInTheShire
You may not like me but, I'm Huge in the Shire
If he becomes available, the Devils should be all over it. No idea what his value is but, if it's a pick or 2 they should do it.
Djp
Registered User
He is one of those players that is more worth to keep than to trade. Habs should try to re sign him to an extension.
He kills penalties, hustles, pretty good at face offs, plays physical. You need to keep those fourth line centers on any hockey team. They are very difficult to replace.
Keep in mind that his max value would be a 2nd from a playoff team. That puts the pick in the #45-64 range. If someone told you that you would draft a player who will play 400+ career games (he is at 280 now), kill penalties, good at face offs and pace for 30 points a season I’m sure everyone would take that.
He kills penalties, hustles, pretty good at face offs, plays physical. You need to keep those fourth line centers on any hockey team. They are very difficult to replace.
Keep in mind that his max value would be a 2nd from a playoff team. That puts the pick in the #45-64 range. If someone told you that you would draft a player who will play 400+ career games (he is at 280 now), kill penalties, good at face offs and pace for 30 points a season I’m sure everyone would take that.
