LeafsNation75
Registered User
To read the rest of this list you need a subscription to ESPN+, however here is what they said about Toronto and how their ranking system works.
Watchability rankings for all 31 NHL teams
Toronto Maple Leafs
Star power: 10
Secondary plot lines: 10
Controversy quotient: 9
Fun factor: 10
Aesthetics: 8
Overall watchability rating: 47
There isn't another team in the NHL that elicits the kind of emotions that the Toronto Maple Leafs do from fans, including their own. They have must-see players: Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner, John Tavares. They have the greatest stakes of any team in the league, trying to win a Stanley Cup for the first time since 1967 with a roster bumping up against the salary-cap ceiling, facing the constant pressure of the market in which they play. And every single Canadian team in their division wants the chance to thump them.
Watchability rankings for all 31 NHL teams
- Star power: The number of outright stars or compelling players on the team.
- Secondary plot lines: Outside of "trying to win," what are the other storylines that could make following this team memorable?
- Controversy quotient: From trade requests to trash talkers to possible suspensions, what kind of chaos could this team create?
- Fun factor: The on-ice entertainment value for a team.
- Aesthetics: These teams shouldn't just be fun to watch, they should be pleasing on the eyes, too, including their Reverse Retro jerseys.

Toronto Maple Leafs
Star power: 10
Secondary plot lines: 10
Controversy quotient: 9
Fun factor: 10
Aesthetics: 8
Overall watchability rating: 47
There isn't another team in the NHL that elicits the kind of emotions that the Toronto Maple Leafs do from fans, including their own. They have must-see players: Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner, John Tavares. They have the greatest stakes of any team in the league, trying to win a Stanley Cup for the first time since 1967 with a roster bumping up against the salary-cap ceiling, facing the constant pressure of the market in which they play. And every single Canadian team in their division wants the chance to thump them.