Speculation: Eastern Conference is a Beast-Should we be sellers

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
I think they should stand pat, nothing they get at the deadline is going to put them over the top. They don’t have the goaltending, defence or ability to get over that first round slump. This team is going to get annihilated.
Not saying they will win in the first round or anything, but why do you think they will get annihilated? Even going back to Matthews and Marner's rookie year, they have never lost a series before game 6. And had many chances to close out series in 6 or 7.

I do agree though, I think they should maybe spend a 2nd on a defenseman if there is one out there, but I don't see the point in spending a 1st or multiple 1sts for what is left out there now.
 
I don't think we should be sellers, but I do believe Dubas is a thick headed idiot if he doesn't utilize Muzzin's LTIR space.

If he doesn't use Muzzin's LTIR space, he's very limited in what he can do -- as if you assume Liljegren to the minors; I believe there's only about $1.2-$1.3m of full-season cap hit that can be acquired with a 21 man roster.

He seems to be adamant about not moving top assets, which I can agree with to an extent, but there has to be a better strategy than "sub Dermott for Schenn"; or more "Change up the mix" type moves. To me, the approach should be to "weaponize" cap space. Max Domi is a $2.6m addition at 50%. There's not a ton of contenders that can still add that type of salary. Mark Giordano a $3.375m addition. Those 2 together can practically fit within Jake Muzzin's LTIR.
Isn't Muzz coming back prior to the playoffs? I thought he was already skating and practicing.
 
D is more than just a stretch, considering we have the 3rd best defensive results in the conference. As for goaltending, while it's been concerning for a couple months, that doesn't really mean much. We have two goalies that are capable of doing well (one was literally a Vezina candidate a few months ago), and not only do we have 20 games left before the playoffs, but we should all be very aware that goaltending can flip on a dime. Especially if Campbell's play was caused by his rib injury. You also attempted to blame Dubas for this, even though he's done more to improve our goaltending and especially defense (which was horrible before he came) in a few years than any Leaf GM in modern history.

We have good defensive results because we have the puck a lot, not because we are good defensively.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Atrusai
If you say so. What are the weaknesses you speak of
Tampa's lost a lot of depth. Florida's defense and goaltending are both question marks. Both of those teams have been pretty average on special teams this year. Etc.

They're both great teams overall, like Toronto, but no team is perfect.
 
We have good defensive results because of both, but the why really doesn't matter much anyway.
The why always matters. If good defensive metrics are solely predicated upon puck possession, that’s an issue. It’s an issue because as we’ve all seen in the past with this team, those possession numbers get compresssed in the post season.
 
The Leafs defensive zone too often resembles and episode of Benny Hill.
What a wild exaggeration. That's not true at all. People just have this ridiculous idea that elite defensive teams never give up any chances, which is completely wrong. Leafs are a very good defensive team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Auston 316
What a wild exaggeration. That's not true at all. People just have this ridiculous idea that elite defensive teams never give up any chances, which is completely wrong.

It’s all about them being soft in battles and slow to read offensive shifts. Yes other teams make mistakes, but not on the scale nor with the frequency as Toronto.
 
The why absolutely matters, and it gets exposed very often. The Leafs defensive zone too often resembles and episode of Benny Hill.

I loved Benny Hill. I hope this comment was at lesst somewhat in endearment of this clsssic show, lol.

More than the sped up running around your.commrnt invokes in my mind, I think of the Leafs being the little bald sidekick who is smacked on the top of his head by Benny, every playoff year it seems. It would be nice for the Leafs to do some smacking of their own.

More Russian Bears and less glitter this playoff please.
 
It’s all about them being soft in battles and slow to read offensive shifts.
You must be confused. We're talking about the Leafs here. Reading and anticipating offensive plays is one of our stronger attributes. Also, just because our defense includes players that can actually play and utilize their sticks like they're supposed to, instead of 6 slow, lumbering, face-punching cross-check machines on skates, it doesn't make us soft in battles. But keep perpetuating that lazy, untrue narrative.
Yes other teams make mistakes, but not on the scale nor with the frequency as Toronto.
Yeah, most of them make more.
 
Isn't Muzz coming back prior to the playoffs? I thought he was already skating and practicing.

I'm advocating that he shouldn't... and the Leafs take a kucherov approach with him (unless somebody else gets hurt)
 
One or two more 5+ GA games and we'll officially be in the bottom half of the GA column league-wide.

Must be driving the Dubites crazy, because either Dubas really doesn't know jack shit about finding good goaltending or this team isn't near as good defensively as they make it out to be. You have to admit to one or the other.
 
You must be confused. We're talking about the Leafs here. Reading and anticipating offensive plays is one of our stronger attributes. Also, just because our defense includes players that can actually play and utilize their sticks like they're supposed to, instead of 6 slow, lumbering, face-punching cross-check machines on skates, it doesn't make us soft in battles. But keep perpetuating that lazy, untrue narrative.

Yeah, most of them make more.

I'm talking about the Leafs on the ice, and you're talking about some bar graph you read online somewhere. That's the confusion.

Cheating for offensive chances isn't good reading and anticipating. That's one of the biggest reason we often struggle in the defensive zone.

Poke-checking is good in certain situations. Our problems occur when we should take the body, but can't.
 
I definitely think we should've made a strong push for Lindholm, he was a better fit than any of the D out there but I don't think in our position you can be a seller. Take a shot at Chychrun and see if Fleury wants to play in TO. I cant imagine selling is a viable option.
 
I definitely think we should've made a strong push for Lindholm, he was a better fit than any of the D out there but I don't think in our position you can be a seller. Take a shot at Chychrun and see if Fleury wants to play in TO. I cant imagine selling is a viable option.

But again, Lindholm is not going to stop the core from choking hard. Spending premium assets only to lose in 1st round again is just digging a deeper hole. IMO, one of the big 4 has to go! Last year was on them, everything else going forward is on Dubas because he refuses to shake up the core. If they don't have that killer instinct, they will never get it. You can not learn it. Lindholm, Chiarot, Fluery, doesn't help with that. It's not like Fleury never had a history of choking in the playoffs either.
 
Can't see Lyubushkin being moved. He was just acquired and they should be looking to re-sign him for a few years.

Holl I doubt is going anywhere although if it was me he would've been left exposed in the expansion draft.

Dermott will most likely be moved but he barely plays so it will have a very minimal impact on the team.

Mikheyev won't be moved and shouldn't because that 3rd line dominates every night. I doubt he will re-sign so they'll have to replace him but it's fine if he walks.

Mrazek should be moved for another backup that's having a similar season in hopes of a change of scenery being a solution to their struggles.

This team is not selling
 
The 5th best team in the league is not selling. Give your head a shake.

We have just as good a chance as any of these teams, even with their additions.
The 5th best team in the league has pretty much the same core that has lost in the first round every year. the only difference is Campbell is injured and not looked good when he was in nets. How can you honestly expect this team to get further this year with same group of guys and an inconsistent goalie? You know they say crazy is doing the same thing over and over again expecting different results.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cbbb25
The 5th best team in the league has pretty much the same core that has lost in the first round every year. the only difference is Campbell is injured and not looked good when he was in nets. How can you honestly expect this team to get further this year with same group of guys and an inconsistent goalie? You know they say crazy is doing the same thing over and over again expecting different results.

Ya, the Leafs should probably stay put or even sell. Im going to assume Leafs loose the series 4-2 in the first round and sports radio and Leaf land has the same discussion like we've had the last half decade.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bretpatrick7

Ad

Ad