Toggle sidebar

Prospect Info: David Reinbacher

  • Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Habs said:
Well not to me lol


You know how many people are saying he's the future on the PP, even though the scouts say he's a 3-4 dman? So why did we burn a pick at 5 for a guy that can't QB the PP ? Shutdown Dmen aren't that hard to find
Click to expand...

That's a hard one...

Because no one is actually saying he is the future on the PP and no serious scouts say he's a 3-4 dman. :dunno:
 
  • Like
Reactions: themilosh, Vachon23, Catanddogguitarrr and 5 others
Habs said:
Well not to me lol


You know how many people are saying he's the future on the PP, even though the scouts say he's a 3-4 dman? So why did we burn a pick at 5 for a guy that can't QB the PP ? Shutdown Dmen aren't that hard to find
Click to expand...
And you know scouts are never wrong.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Catanddogguitarrr
Habs said:
Well not to me lol


You know how many people are saying he's the future on the PP, even though the scouts say he's a 3-4 dman? So why did we burn a pick at 5 for a guy that can't QB the PP ? Shutdown Dmen aren't that hard to find
Click to expand...

There's 0 people saying he's the future on the PP and anyone saying he's a 3-4 D man are just those who are mad that they didn't pick Michkov or simply think that being a 1-2D requires being a dipsy doodle artist who puts up a bunch of points and don't even know they are supposed to defend.

They used a top 5 pick because big, rangy, smooth skating, right shot defenseman, with puck poise, high IQ and plus offensive attributes are a scarcity.

They are trying to build a winning team, not have the highest point producing simulations in EA sports.

Watch someone like Ryan Suter or Jacob Slavin play defense and tell me they aren't/weren't top 2 defenseman.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: JAVO16, Walksss, Catanddogguitarrr and 10 others
OnTheRun said:
That's a hard one...

Because no one is actually saying he is the future on the PP and no serious scouts say he's a 3-4 dman. :dunno:
Click to expand...

Are you kidding? Are we going to pretend the expectation @5th overall isn't going to help the PP?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdk
Guess said:
Not sure if he's been mentioned yet, Francis Booboo said that Reinbacher was just 'ok' at camp, despite Reinbacher saying he was told not to try anything fancy.

He did add that he's not worried and give him time
Click to expand...
He also said last year Maillloux was the most NHL ready prospect
 
Habs said:
Are you kidding? Are we going to pretend the expectation @5th overall isn't going to help the PP?
Click to expand...
I personally don't expect a shutdown RHD to also be a PP point producer. Sure, it would be nice if he could, but I want him focused on stopping the other team's top offensive players at 5on5 and when we're on the PK. If Reinbacher had also been a big time point producer at he RHD position, he would have challenged Bedard for #1 overall.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catanddogguitarrr, Redux91 and WeThreeKings
Habs said:
that just seems like BS. So Hutson has the green light to do spin-o-ramas and risky dekes at the blueline, but they told Reinbacher to settle down and not stand out?
Click to expand...
Yea because Hutson’s game to be effective is completely different than Redenbacher - Hutson is there to generate offense not “play Defense”
 
Habs said:
Are you kidding?
Click to expand...

That's my line.

Habs said:
Are we going to pretend the expectation @5th overall isn't going to help the PP?
Click to expand...
Now that's a completely different take, it went from the claim of many people seeing him as the future of the PP to your expectation of what a 5OA should provide to the team.

The original claim is just blatantly false so we'll skip over that.
The 2nd part is your opinion and everything goes here, If you believe being a PP QB should be an absolute requirement to be drafted top5, then so be it.
That said, not being a PP QB doesn't make one a 3-4 dman.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catanddogguitarrr and salbutera
WeThreeKings said:
There's 0 people saying he's the future on the PP and anyone saying he's a 3-4 D man are just those who are mad that they didn't pick Michkov or simply think that being a 1-2D requires being a dipsy doodle artist who puts up a bunch of points and don't even know they are supposed to defend.

They used a top 5 pick because big, rangy, smooth skating, right shot defenseman, with puck poise, high IQ and plus offensive attributes are a scarcity.

They are trying to build a winning team, not have the highest point producing simulations in EA sports.

Watch someone like Ryan Suter or Jacob Slavin play defense and tell me they aren't/weren't top 2 defenseman.
Click to expand...
What I expect from a top-pairing D drafted 5OA is 24-26 TOI a game. Not that concerned with his point totals. Is that unreasonable?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Redux91, ZUKI and salbutera
OnTheRun said:
That's my line.


Now that's a completely different take, it went from the claim of many people seeing him as the future of the PP to your expectation of what a 5OA should provide to the team.

The original claim is just blatantly false so we'll skip over that.
The 2nd part is your opinion and everything goes here, If you believe being a PP QB should be an absolute requirement to be drafted top5, then so be it.
That said, not being a PP QB doesn't make one a 3-4 dman.
Click to expand...
Some guys get drafted high and don’t end up big point producers but still have incredibly long careers. Sure I’d love him to be the next Larry Robinson but if he contributes in a significant way to the teams success, no one will care.
 
Habs said:
Are you kidding? Are we going to pretend the expectation @5th overall isn't going to help the PP?
Click to expand...

Yes.

He could probably QB a PP but he won't obviously do it above Hutson or Matheson.

And there is a lot of other way he can impact the game like the hardest defensive minutes.

Who had the PP1 in Detroit last season and who was the most impactful defenseman?

Hint : not the same player.
 
I wouldn't be showing him vids of Shea Weber per say, as I would show him vids of Noah Dobson as that's who I think his game resembles more as he does not use that big frame to his advantage at all. Not saying he's soft, as he's clearly not but he's not physical.

I would have been showing Guhle Shea Weber vids as I felt he could model his game after him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ReHabs, Kobe Armstrong and Bobby Holik agent
Habs said:
Are you kidding? Are we going to pretend the expectation @5th overall isn't going to help the PP?
Click to expand...
Go to the Hawks forum and see how many think Korchinski will still have PP1 despite drafting Levshunov, then come back here and apologize. You're making a problem out of your own bizarre assumption.
 
junyab said:
Go to the Hawks forum and see how many think Korchinski will still have PP1 despite drafting Levshunov, then come back here and apologize. You're making a problem out of your own bizarre assumption.
Click to expand...

And if Reinbacher is a flop I want you to come back here and admit it, but I know you won't
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: ReHabs and Bobby Holik agent
Habs said:
And if Reinbacher is a flop I want you to come back here and admit it, but I know you won't
Click to expand...
Huh? I made no statement or claim that he's a guarantee or not. Go back the last 5 drafts and tell me every top echelon defenceman was drafted to be a top PP QB. It's simply not the case. You can most certainly be a top 2 2-way d-man without QBing the PP1.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catanddogguitarrr
pepperMonkey said:
Wait, sorry I haven't read this whole thread but are you saying he's gonna be a flop? Because why else would someone come back to admit that?
Click to expand...

A flop? I don't think he was worth the #5 pick, so in my mind that would be a flop of a selection. Does he suck? No. Did we take the PBA? No. Is that the way to rebuild? No. Would you be happy if he is a #3-4 20pt dman? Maybe you would be? I would not

But we are allowed to disagree here still, right? We are just one big dysfunctional family anyways. I just find it funny you can call out any player in the team's organization except Reinbacher, he's so protected by the fans lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bobby Holik agent
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom