Value of: Carson Soucy + Mason Appleton

[Cor]

This is a package I think a lot of contending teams should be looking at from Seattle.

What do we think the rough value of this would be?

Click to read more...

 

[Hockey 4 Life]

1st youngish roster player and b prospect.
So for the leafs 2022 1st dermott, Abramov or Sda.

 

[No Name The Nameless]

1st youngish roster player and b prospect.
So for the leafs 2022 1st dermott, Abramov or Sda.

Copy, paste in every trade thread.

 

[Hockey 4 Life]

Copy, paste in every trade thread.

Your entitled to your opinion but I've said somthing similar in two threads. You call it copy and paste, I call it consistency.

 

[Mersss]

Your entitled to your opinion but I've said somthing similar in two threads. You call it copy and paste, I call it consistency.

So let me get this straight...
CHiarot, who's a much better dman than Soucy, wouldn't fetch a 2nd rd pick...

BUT, somehow, Soucy and Appleton (4th lienr) fetches a 1st, roster player and a B prospect...
Yeah... right...

 

[Buresflyingelbow]

I’d like both in Vancouver

 

[D00bis]

neither of these guys have the stats that scream "they can be elite any day now" probably why the kraken fans are testing the water but dont be surprised at the underwhelming offers. mediocre attracks mediocre

 

[Irie]

So let me get this straight...
CHiarot, who's a much better dman than Soucy, wouldn't fetch a 2nd rd pick...

BUT, somehow, Soucy and Appleton (4th lienr) fetches a 1st, roster player and a B prospect...
Yeah... right...

Apples to Oranges.

Soucy is signed though next season and is 27 years old.

Chiarot is going to be 31 this season and is a pure rental.

Soucy is +7 on a bad Seattle team.

Chiarot is -20 on a bad Montreal team.

People push the narrative here that Soucy is a 6th defenseman, but that doesn't really tell the story.

Soucy has played mostly with Dunn, Giordano, and Oleksiak at even strength, and none of those pairings have been deployed like traditional bottom pairings.

You believe Chiarot is a much better player, but given age, contract status and current play, I'd take Soucy.

 

[57special]

Soucy is a #5, possibly a #4. If he's a #6 you have a really strong D. Appleton adds little.

 

[Tbaybruin]

Soucy is a #5, possibly a #4. If he's a #6 you have a really strong D.

Sorry I want soucy way more.

 

[NjdevilfanJim]

Yeah Soucy plays a steady heavy game and two shots with him makes offer go up

 

[KillerMillerTime]

Apples to Oranges.

Soucy is signed though next season and is 27 years old.

Chiarot is going to be 31 this season and is a pure rental.

Soucy is +7 on a bad Seattle team.

Chiarot is -20 on a bad Montreal team.

People push the narrative here that Soucy is a 6th defenseman, but that doesn't really tell the story.

Soucy has played mostly with Dunn, Giordano, and Oleksiak at even strength, and none of those pairings have been deployed like traditional bottom pairings.

You believe Chiarot is a much better player, but given age, contract status and current play, I'd take Soucy.

Bruins offer Forbort, Smith, DeBrusk and '22 #1
'23 #2.

How's them Appleton's...lol.

 

[ChazzMichaelMichaels]

Apples to Oranges.

Soucy is signed though next season and is 27 years old.

Chiarot is going to be 31 this season and is a pure rental.

Soucy is +7 on a bad Seattle team.

Chiarot is -20 on a bad Montreal team.

People push the narrative here that Soucy is a 6th defenseman, but that doesn't really tell the story.

Soucy has played mostly with Dunn, Giordano, and Oleksiak at even strength, and none of those pairings have been deployed like traditional bottom pairings.

You believe Chiarot is a much better player, but given age, contract status and current play, I'd take Soucy.

You're telling me you missed a clear chance at

"Appleton to Oranges"

In this thread?

 

[Irie]

You're telling me you missed a clear chance at

"Appleton to Oranges"

In this thread?

Oh, I originally typed Apple(tons) to Oranges, but I removed it before posting.

A few years ago I would have left it, but I no longer have faith in the ability of the new generation of posters to appreciate a good pun.

It is yet another sign our society is slipping into dark times....

 

[kihei]

For the many who want to ship Dermott to Seattle for whomever they want from the Kraken, ship him a little further west. To say, the middle of the Pacific Ocean (life raft available for future considerations).

 

[DudeWhereIsMakar]

I think Appleton would do well on a new team depending on where that is, but I think Seattle should be a lot wiser with him but the Jets would love to have him back.

Other than that, Soucy has shown to be solid with Seattle and they should hold onto him.

 

[kihei]

I think Appleton might thrive on a better team, but I hope that the Kraken keep Soucy long term. He is among a handful of players on the team who has steadily improved.