WhatTheDuck
9 - 20 - 8
Yeah one of those should work, Freddie I guess would have to be returned healthy and willing to waive his NTC. For cap purposes he'd surely make more sense. Would be some neat irony if him and Gibby were traded for each other.
LeBrun: Carolina has talked to Anaheim about Gibson; "...the price is going to have to come down..."
- Thread starter Big Daddy Cane
- Start date
Yeah one of those should work, Freddie I guess would have to be returned healthy and willing to waive his NTC. For cap purposes he'd surely make more sense. Would be some neat irony if him and Gibby were traded for each other.
- Oct 10, 2007
- 26,448
- 14,291
They seem to building a promising young team. Sure, they suck now, but their younger players are surrounded by more experienced players which should help as they take over.
CrazyDuck4u
Registered User
- Oct 14, 2006
- 7,251
- 4,363
Lol you need to watch a ducks game. Our veterans are worse than our rookies
Boom Boom Apathy
I am the Professor. Deal with it!
- Sep 6, 2006
- 49,513
- 102,884
- Oct 10, 2007
- 26,448
- 14,291
We don't know the asking price.
I'm not saying they are great or good players, but you don't want to surround promising young players with AHL call-ups. It doesn't work well for development.
OilersFanatics505
Registered User
- Aug 11, 2008
- 5,542
- 5,283
Asking price had to be more than what was paid for than ‘wood or they would have taken the historically better goalie.
- Oct 10, 2007
- 26,448
- 14,291
OilersFanatics505
Registered User
- Aug 11, 2008
- 5,542
- 5,283
dirtydanglez
Registered User
- Oct 30, 2022
- 5,533
- 5,575
tarheelhockey
Offside Review Specialist
Serious question — how does Anaheim need Gibson? He turns 32 this summer, still has 3.5 years left at a sizable cap hit, hasn’t put up a strong season since before COVID. He can’t be part of the long term plans for the Ducks.
I understand and expect that Anaheim will want a meaningful future building block if they’re asked to pay salary on him going forward. But “we need this player” seems like a bit of a disingenuous stance, at least from the outside looking in.
MessierII
Registered User
- Aug 10, 2011
- 28,787
- 18,342
Or avoided the whole situation and traded him years ago when they were starting to rebuild and he was still pretty good.
We are but lets be fair. Anaheim has been a rebuilding team for several years now, I would rather hear hear from people who have watched him and not just looking at stats. I for one haven't really watched him so who knows. But based on stats you're right he would be a cap dump
Gibson is playing much better this year and his stats reflect that. He was unlucky last night with 2-3 goals coming off deflections from his own teammates.
- Oct 10, 2007
- 26,448
- 14,291
Reading that more charitably, the team trading for Gibson needs to give something Anaheim needs. What that is might be exactly be what you said. This depends on how much emphasis you put on "want him more" and ""Anaheim needs him." I didn't read that post as Anaheim really needs him.
TheFinalWord
Registered User
- Apr 25, 2005
- 2,249
- 882
There is never an issue finding a contract to take on to get to the cap floor. The cap floor is never an issue.
canuckslover10
Registered User
- Apr 10, 2014
- 2,064
- 1,870
32 Thoughts: Soft talks underway between NHL, NHLPA for next CBA
The NHL Board of Governors meetings have wrapped and teams were left with the impression that the ride to the next CBA will be smoother. Elliotte Friedman discusses that, a possible 84-game season and more tidbits from around the league.
Friedman also mentions Gibson, noting that the Canes may have been close up to multiple occasions in the past.
Just a little more smoke.
Emerald Duck
Registered User
The problem with these trade rumors is that no one knows what the Ducks are asking for, what the Canes or other teams are offering, and the details about Gibson's NTC. We don't know if Gibson has asked for a trade even as some hockey insiders insisted that Gibson had played his last game for Anaheim last year.
As pointed out many times, Gibson helps the Ducks with their cap floor and helps Dostal with his game load. We don't have to trade him. He is expensive as a backup or a 1B starter, but the situation is manageable for the Ducks. We don't have to move him for a cap dump backup and more late round picks when our organization is full of prospects. There is no information to suggest that Gibson is a locker room problem or a disrputive figure.
If we can accomondate Gibson and the move helps the Ducks then I'm sure management will pursue it, but just to move him to help solve another team's problem doesn't help us.
I don't see Carolina as a fit. Gibson seems too much like big game hunting, which the Canes usually avoid. Even Freddy seemed like too big of a name but he came in at a reasonable cap hit and didn't cost any assets. I think they browse the bargain bin and hope their guys figure it out by April.
The team I'm shocked isn't all over Gibson is Detroit. He fits in their age, and they should be desperate for a good goalie. Husso blows. Talbot is a backup that's spent the last 10 years somehow convincing teams he's a starter, and every year someone falls for it. Lyon is good for about 20 games a year until he's either hurt or his play falls off. They should make a trade like COL & SJ just did, where Husso plays the role of Georgiev
The team I'm shocked isn't all over Gibson is Detroit. He fits in their age, and they should be desperate for a good goalie. Husso blows. Talbot is a backup that's spent the last 10 years somehow convincing teams he's a starter, and every year someone falls for it. Lyon is good for about 20 games a year until he's either hurt or his play falls off. They should make a trade like COL & SJ just did, where Husso plays the role of Georgiev
Stephen
Moderator
- Feb 28, 2002
- 81,839
- 59,803
Feels like the time to get a haul on John Gibson may have passed. He's like an old eBay listing with a very high buy now price and just never going to move.
Ideally he would have been moved a few years ago, giving him a fresh start on a contender, allowing Anaheim to bring in more youth, tank a little harder... but Anaheim has drafted up a prospect pool, Gibson is into his 30s and it's like they passed the action by date.
Ideally he would have been moved a few years ago, giving him a fresh start on a contender, allowing Anaheim to bring in more youth, tank a little harder... but Anaheim has drafted up a prospect pool, Gibson is into his 30s and it's like they passed the action by date.
All of this is true...until a team with SC aspirations needs a goalie and decides that Gibson is the goalie they need. Then it breaks down. Will that ever happen? TBD.
