Proposal: [Bobby Margarita Special] “Trade is one for one: Jakob Chychrun for Mason McTavish”

[rt]

Wondering what the reaction would be if Jakob Chychrun went to Anaheim for Mason McTavish. One for one as McKenzie famously tweeted all those years ago when Taylor Hall was dealt for Adam Larsson.

Click to read more...

 

[The Mighty Duck Man]

If the Ducks won the draft lottery maybe they'd consider it but even then I doubt it, but that's just me.

 

[rt]

If the Ducks won the draft lottery maybe they'd consider it but even then I doubt it, but that's just me.

This is a deadline deal.

I’m imagining maybe Anaheim trades their 2nd to Minnesota for McBain afterward. McBain isn’t McTavish, but with McTavish gone, I could see Anaheim being tops on McBain’s list of destinations. Verbeek and Guerin have a trade relationship now.

Maybe Anaheim takes Gauthier or Kasper with their 1st, too.

 

[Eggtimer]

This is a deadline deal.

I’m imagining maybe Anaheim trades their 2nd to Minnesota for McBain afterward. McBain isn’t McTavish, but with McTavish gone, I could see Anaheim being tops on McBain’s list of destinations. Verbeek and Guerin have a trade relationship now.

Maybe Anaheim takes Gauthier or Kasper with their 1st, too.

Hands off , Gauthier is ours (Devils) unless Slavkovsky is somehow there when we pick.
Ducks can have Cutter instead .

 

[The Mighty Duck Man]

This is a deadline deal.

I’m imagining maybe Anaheim trades their 2nd to Minnesota for McBain afterward. McBain isn’t McTavish, but with McTavish gone, I could see Anaheim being tops on McBain’s list of destinations. Verbeek and Guerin have a trade relationship now.

Maybe Anaheim takes Gauthier or Kasper with their 1st, too.

Then especially no. There's a few ways they could mitigate the center loss but they're better off not doing that IMO. Only way they could consider parting with McTavish is if they had Shane Wright on the way, but that's just me.

 

[rt]

This is a deadline deal.

I’m imagining maybe Anaheim trades their 2nd to Minnesota for McBain afterward. McBain isn’t McTavish, but with McTavish gone, I could see Anaheim being tops on McBain’s list of destinations. Verbeek and Guerin have a trade relationship now.

Maybe Anaheim takes Gauthier or Kasper with their 1st, too.

Chychrun+Kessel (50%) + SJS 2nd to ANA for Comtois+McTavish

Then ANA moves their 2nd and Kessel with an additional 50% off to Minnesota for Jack McBain.

For the Ducks it works out to Comtois and McTavish for Chychrun and McBain.

 

[JoeSakic13]

It’ll only happen if Bobby gets to be the one to break it

 

[rt]

Hands off , Gauthier is ours (Devils) unless Slavkovsky is somehow there when we pick.
Ducks can have Cutter instead .

Arizona is going to draft Gauthier. He’s from Arizona, I’ve watched most of his games, and he’s my favorite player.

 

[MagicalRazor]

Ducks can't do that trade , You can never leave the Night's watch

 

[Gliff]

The Ducks can’t afford to trade to trade McTavish. He is the only potential top 6 center prospect so the only way he moves is for a young top 6 center.

 

[Big Daddy Cane]

If the pieces around the player aren't good enough to take advantage of the term that makes him so valuable, what's the point?

The Eichel conundrum 2.0.

 

[Mrfenn92]

Think the ducks say no

 

[SEALBound]

Chychrun+Kessel (50%) + SJS 2nd to ANA for Comtois+McTavish

Then ANA moves their 2nd and Kessel with an additional 50% off to Minnesota for Jack McBain.

For the Ducks it works out to Comtois and McTavish for Chychrun and McBain.

Not bad actually.

 

[Mickey Marner]

I wouldn't do it if i were Anaheim. I think McTavish is the real deal.

 

[Leonardo87]

Ducks are building enough assets in these recent trades to not have to go much into their own assets. Could see them maybe move maybe Zellweger in a package for Chychrun. McTavish has high end 2C potential and the Ducks need that depth down the middle for the future.

 

[Reddwit]

Easy pass if I’m Anaheim.

 

[Leafs87]

Anaheim just traded two great D men and signalled rebuild is their way forward. Highly doubt they make a move like this

 

[Super Hans]

The "Proposal" thread tag really needs to be a lot easier to tell apart from the verified sources tags, especially when a verified source is in the thread title.

 

[HoseEmDown]

Chychrun+Kessel (50%) + SJS 2nd to ANA for Comtois+McTavish

Then ANA moves their 2nd and Kessel with an additional 50% off to Minnesota for Jack McBain.

For the Ducks it works out to Comtois and McTavish for Chychrun and McBain.

Minnesota is asking a 2nd for McBain, so you're trading Kessel 50% retained for absolutely nothing?

 

[WingsMJN2965]

You can look at pretty much every Cup winner and they’ve got center depth.

Anaheim not letting go of Zegras or McTavish.

 

[Uncle]

No chance. Silly

 

[The Duck Knight]

You can look at pretty much every Cup winner and they’ve got center depth.

Anaheim not letting go of Zegras or McTavish.

Yeah add in Lundestrom though. If McTavish can become a high end 2C that's a fantastic 1-2-3 punch down the middle.

 

[Kaner9]

If mctavish somehow sees that title hes shook lmao.

 

[lwvs84]

You can look at pretty much every Cup winner and they’ve got center depth.

Anaheim not letting go of Zegras or McTavish.

Just to add to this, Ducks have traditionally done better at drafting and developing D than forward. None of the pipeline will likely be a good as Chychrun, but they have some solid guys in the system. Drysdale, Helleson, Thrun, Zellweger, LaCombe should all make some impact. Hopefully one breaks out and becomes a true difference maker.

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

Lhd we have a lot of… maybe not to the lvl of chychrun but we can’t move a potential top 6 center for him. I suppose if we knew the draft lottery results that might make it possible