ATD IX Rd 1: Kaner9 vs CHGoalie27

Which card do you prefer?

  • Kaner9

  • CHGoalie27


Results are only viewable after voting.

HandsomeHollywood

Brooke Shields ain't got nothin'
Mar 20, 2017
1,531
1,219
Kaner9:

HELL IN A CELL WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP MATCH CM Punk vs Rick Rude



Chris Jericho vs AJ Styles



TAG TEAM CHAMPIONSHIP MATCH Steiner Brothers vs Demolition vs Rock’n’Roll Express



Goldberg vs Ron Simmons



I QUIT MATCH Jay Lethal vs Kenta



Raven vs Shinsuke Nakamura vs Marty Scurll



Kota Ibushi vs Billy Kidman with Torrie Wilson


Hakushi vs Lord Tensai

-VS-

CHGoalie27:

Live at The Philadelphia Spectrum April 20
Host/Commentator Joey Styles, Ring Announcer Howard Finkel

- US vs Canada National Championship Title Unification: I Quit Match, Best of 3 Falls
1907 Frank Gotch vs 1939 Stu Hart

- Tables, Ladders, & Chairs For The Million Dollar Briefcase
2001 The Hardy Boyz vs 1998 Rob Van Dam & Sabu

- Last Man Standing for Rights to the Sheik Name
1965 The Sheik vs 1983 Iron Sheik

-AEW vs WWE War Games
Team WWE : 2022 Charlotte Flair, 2021 Bianca Belair, 2019 Shayna Baszler, and 2018 Ronda Rousey
Team AEW: 2021 Dr. Britt Baker D.M.D., 2022 Jamie Hayter, 2016 Rebel Tanea, and 2022 Jade Cargill

- 60 Minute Iron Man Match
1997 Eddie Guerrero vs 2017 Andrade Cien Almas

- Hell In A Cell
1997 Hayabusa vs 2019 Adam Cole

- Hardcore / No DIsqualifications
1997 Bam Bam Bigelow vs 2020 Drew McIntyre

- Parking Lot Preshow: Over The Top Battle Royale with Barbed Wire Ropes
1. 2022 @Natey The Good Boy Jack Russell
2. 1999 Nick Gage
3. 2001 Justice Pain
4. 1999 John Zandig
5. 1997 Balls Mahoney
6. 1995 Axl Rotten
7. 1995 Ian Rotten
8. 2000 Lobo
9. 2015 Matt Tremont
10. 1996 Super Leather
11. 1994 Tommy Dreamer
12. 1998 Mr. Gannosuke
13. 1992 Tarzan Goto
14. 2006 Mickey Knuckles
15. 1992 Shark Tsuchiya
16. 1992 Megumi Kudo
17. 1983 Dump Matsumoto
18. 1993 Akira Hakuto
19. 1995 W*ING Kanemura
20. 1996 The Great Sasuke
21. 1993 Mitsuhiro Matsunaga
22. 1993 Mr. Pogo
23. 2005 Jun Kasai
24. 2022 Shlak
25. 1985 The Missing Link
26. 1986 Carlos Colon
27. 1987 Sgt. Slaughter
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: Kaner9 and Natey

les Habs

Registered User
Sep 21, 2005
22,747
4,175
Wisconsin
@Kaner9 Some big matches at the top of your card. I just wish you would have fleshed them out a bit with some background. I think Punk vs Rude could have been a really interesting storyline. Still some interesting matchups throughout the card. You got my vote here.

@CHGoalie27 Some great matchups and I particularly like Eddie vs Andrade. I like that you added the version of the guys you chose. Oh, and women’s War Games was a nice touch.

Another really close one here.
 

CHGoalie27

Don't blame the goalie!
Oct 5, 2009
15,994
3,226
SoFLA
Here's the explanations:
Gotch vs Hart i wanted the legit all time masters of the holds to go at it. I was considering adding Hackenschmidt but I thought this was better considering how many people Stu taught. He vs the original GOAT of pro wrestling seemed like a great surprise that hasn't been done for some reason.

Sheik vs Iron Sheik is pretty self explanatory, the Sheik legit hated the Iranian Champion for taking on the gimmick Farhat had long built up.

RVD & Sabu vs The Hardyz in a TLC, to me, is the most exciting match in the whole draft. Nuff said lol

Adam Cole has proven himself to be a main eventer, capable of all things tough n acrobatic, Hayabusa seemed like the perfect match for him for a hell in a cell.

Andrade vs Eddie in their most exciting physical primes for an hours worth of supreme mexican style excellence.

Bam Bam vs McIntyre is one of the best one on one big men match ups where in ring and hardcore can show the powerful best of each other.

The girls war games match is pretty self explanatory, as is the ultra violent all star battle royale. Threw in Sarge, Link, & Colon for good measure lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kaner9

JackSlater

Registered User
Apr 27, 2010
19,259
14,586
Tight one for me, CHGoalie has a more creative card with more of an "all time" feel while Kaner9 has a better in-ring product. Guerrero vs Andrade is a standout for me on CHGoalie's card, while on Kaner9's card I would have liked some of the matchups, like CM Punk vs Rick Rude, fleshed out a little. went with CHGoalie here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CHGoalie27

BruinDust

Registered User
Aug 2, 2005
25,447
24,593
I went with CHGoalie here. I like how you included the "year" of the performer your portraying, helps visualize the card better. I actually thought about doing that with my card but with my format it wouldn't of had the same impact. Lots of unique and contrasting match-ups.

Kaner's main event with Rude doesn't turn my crank much. I like Rude overall but when comparing him to others there are just so many more performers who are more legitimate main eventers than Rick Rude. I can see Rude in the 2nd or 3rd biggest match on my card, but I wouldn't envision him in the main event. Jericho and Styles happened in real life recently (WM 32) so that's a knock for me there. Different had the match taken place many years ago and your trying to rekindle the feud.
 

Ad

Ad

Ad