Arvidsson or Toffoli?

[Bjornar Moxnes]

Both wingers signed for two more seasons on extremely similar cap hits. Who would you take on your team?

Click to read more...

 

[biturbo19]

I like Arvidsson better. I always found Toffoli completely invisible when not scoring. Arvidsson at least sometimes kinda does other things.

 

[banks]

Toffoli always seemed more like a stat compiler and passenger, to me. Where as Arvidsson can carry a line sometimes and dictates the play a bit more.

But it's close. Neither player is a hero or a heel.

 

[Luigi Lemieux]

I'll take Arvidsson for the playoffs

 

[Cianide]

Toffoli has more skill, but that's all that he has. He's about as one-dimensional as they come. Arvidsson can do pretty much everything. The skill's not really top level but you're not asking for that in Viktor.

 

[Haatley]

I'll take Arvidsson for the playoffs

Based on what exactly?

 

[biturbo19]

Toffoli has more skill, but that's all that he has. He's about as one-dimensional as they come. Arvidsson can do pretty much everything. The skill's not really top level but you're not asking for that in Viktor.

Toffoli honestly has to be up there with the most 1-dimensional, invisible sort of "20-30G scorers" i can remember. He almost always seems to emerge with his 25-30Gs, and i had no earthly idea he was out there the entire rest of the time. His ability to blend into the woodwork is truly remarkable.

Arvidsson definitely stands out a lot more. Far more active and engaged. And it's not like he's completely lacking skill, or the potential to also pot 20-30G in a given year.

 

[Took a pill in Sbisa]

Toffoli because I know I get 20 more regular season games out of him.

 

[Cianide]

Toffoli honestly has to be up there with the most 1-dimensional, invisible sort of "20-30G scorers" i can remember. He almost always seems to emerge with his 25-30Gs, and i had no earthly idea he was out there the entire rest of the time. His ability to blend into the woodwork is truly remarkable.

Arvidsson definitely stands out a lot more. Far more active and engaged. And it's not like he's completely lacking skill, or the potential to also pot 20-30G in a given year.

My point exactly.

 

[biturbo19]

My point exactly.

He's somehow not even like a Radim Vbrata. Who was also insanely 1-dimensional and didn't do a whole lot else on the way to his annual 20-30 goals. But at least he scored a lot of absolute snipes that were vaguely memorable. Toffoli...i'm not even sure he really has that.

 

[Luigi Lemieux]

Based on what exactly?

I think he's a better player. Would fit the pens nicely.