But do you think they'll actually go to games? I don't think there are dudes from Williamsburg or the new-Bushwick who are gonna go down to Atlantic Ave to see the ****ing Islanders after the first season.
I think it's cool because I think the Barclay's Center is really nice and I'll be able to go see Rangers-Isles for cheaper than at the Garden and save 20+ minutes on commute. But if KC or Seattle came calling, the smart move would be to give the franchise to them.
The arena will be filled. First, it's so easy to get to from Manhattan for those on their way to Long Island. Can easily get to Queens. Can get back to Staten Island. Can get there from Brooklyn. There's enough people in Brooklyn who enjoy sports, and enough families who want to get out, to make it worthwhile (and I don't think it's going to be a huge arena for hockey seating-wise). I'll definitely take my son to an obscure game just to see hockey at a reasonable cost and ten minutes from my house. Grab L&B and a Brooklyn Lager at the Arena and I'm set. I wouldn't call myself an Islanders fan, but think it would be enjoyable to see hockey in Brooklyn.
One made a case for the Nets' success in Brooklyn, and one can make a similar case, albeit watered down since hockey isn't basketball, for the Islanders. The Islanders are also a franchise name that carries value. Many casual fans know of what they did in the 80s. The closet fans will come out. Can't say it'll be a rabid crazy, well knowledgeable (about hockey) fan base, but they'll be sure to schedule plenty of Saturday matinee games with crappy teams to fill the arena against those tough teams...if the scheduling gods permit.