One thing this AAV illustrates is defensemen are traditionally more cost effective to build around than flashy elite forwards.
Notwithstanding some of the silly contracts that have been handed out the past couple of off-seasons, you can draft a stable of 4 elite to dependable blueliners like a Nashville, and you have pretty compact strong core group that can be on the ice that can eat up 45 minutes of the game. Throw in a goalie and you're contending. Not my stylistic preference, but I definitely respect that way of building.
Nashville is known as a Dman factory but it’s been a little more spread out.
Weber and Suter came after the 2004 lockout, Hamhuis as well as kind of a forgotten man. I’m fairly certain they picked up Timmonen in the expansion draft.
They traded away Franson and Ellis, which is fine, Franson would not be able to play the game at 2022 speed and Ellis is one of the glassiest players ever.
Ekholm and Josi played their first games in 2011, since then all they’ve gotten are Jones and Girard, both traded, and I guess Fabbro but he’s not really anything special.
They always identify who to keep, and trade the rest for the offensive talent they’ve never drafted - they also traded Fiala for Granlund.
I think it’s easier to run a baseline competitive team with a good stable of D, but you aren’t winning anything without a good group up front.
The current Islanders remind me of the Preds 5-7 years ago; a very good top four D (Pulock, Pelech, Romanov and Dobson),
one elite forward and a bunch of okay guys and grinders - Martin and Clutterbuck, not one of them but both, for two years, four years to someone named Ross Johnston, significant term on Pageau and Cizikas.
I have no idea what Lou is doing, but I’m happy he isn’t doing it here.
I honestly don’t remember the last team a team had not just one but multiple stud D prospects come in and make a big splash - aside from the most recent winners who got lucky enough to get a once every ten year player and a very fortunately timed lottery pick.
Like McAvoy and Werenski before him, Dobson will be getting a significant bag, no way he says ‘I’ll take 7 because I don’t want Pulock and Pelech to get jealous.’
Maybe individually having one elite D is better than having one elite forward, but if you get multiples it’s better to have two high end forwards because you can spread them out a lot more.