All-Time, All-Province

[DisgruntledGoat*]

The team would fail due to being GM'd by MacTavish.

 

[Sprague Cleghorn]

The teams will only include players at their natural positions and the only eligibility rule for a province is that you have to be born there (not born AND raised).

Ontario

Bobby Hull - Wayne Gretzky - Bill Cook
Ted Lindsay - Howie Morenz - Charlie Conacher
Frank Mahovlich - Frank Nighbor - Brett Hull
Cy Denneny - Phil Esposito - Babe Dye

Bobby Orr - Red Kelly
Larry Robinson - Brad Park
King Clancy - Paul Coffey

Ken Dryden
Clint Benedict

Quebec

Dickie Moore - Mario Lemieux - Maurice Richard
Luc Robitaille - Jean Beliveau - Guy Lafleur
Michel Goulet - Henri Richard - Mike Bossy
Rick Martin - Marcel Dionne - Bernie Geoffrion

Doug Harvey - Raymond Bourque
Denis Potvin - Pierre Pilote
Me - Serge Savard

Patrick Roy
Jacques Plante

I had to do some digging on that 4th LW for Quebec, which gives Ontario the default win at LW.

 

[Brominator]

Ab McDonald Bobby Clarke Billy Mosienko
Patrick Sharp Jonathan Toews Theo Fleury*
Ted Irvine Butch Goring reggie Leach

Duncan Keith James Patrick
Tom Johnson Jack Stewart
Chris Leschyshyn Grant Ledyard

Terry Sawchuk
Eddie Belfour
Ron Hextall
Turk Broda
Bill Ranford

There's my Manitoba. *note that I'm claiming Russell Manitobas Theo Fleury, even though he was born in Sk.

Strong down the middle but weak on defence. Awesome goaltending which is how we'll steal this tournament

 

[Sprague Cleghorn]

Just for fun since I'm bored (same criteria as above): Battle of the Prairies

Alberta

Johnny Bucyk - Mark Messier - Jarome Iginla
Paul Thompson - Norm Ullman - Lanny McDonald
Herbie Lewis - Neil Colville - Trevor Linden
Ray Whitney - Garry Unger - Shane Doan

Scott Niedermayer - Bill Gadsby
Dion Phaneuf - Mike Green
Dave Babych - Jay Bouwmeester

Grant Fuhr
Mike Vernon

Manitoba

Patrick Sharp - Bobby Clarke - Andy Bathgate
Dennis Hextall - Frank Fredrickson - Bill Mosienko
Ab McDonald - Bernie Morris - Harry Oliver
Dustin Penner - Jonathan Toews - Reggie Leach

Ching Johnson - Black Jack Stewart
Duncan Keith - Ken Reardon
Tom Johnson - Art Coulter

Terry Sawchuk
Turk Broda

Saskatchewan

Doug Bentley - Bryan Trottier - Gordie Howe
Bert Olmstead - Max Bentley - Bryan Hextall
Brian Propp - Elmer Lach - Theo Fleury
Clark Gillies - Sid Abel - Lorne Carr

Fern Flaman - Eddie Shore
Brad McCrimmon - Ted Green
Ted Harris - Terry Harper

Glenn Hall
Johnny Bower

Offense: Saskatchewan
Defense: Manitoba
Goalie: Manitoba

 

[TonyTinglebone]

I Don't think New Brunswick can even ice a team.

Danny Grant - Greg Malone - Willie O'Ree
John LeBlanc - Bill Miller - Gerry Ouellette
Mike Eagles - Manny McIntyre -
Brad Malone - Zach Phillips -

Don Sweeney - Randy Jones

Jake Allen
Cédrick Desjardins

I find it odd that you know about players like Bill Miller and Manny McIntyre, but don't know enough NB players to fill out a team.

Danny Grant - Greg Malone - Gordie Drillon
Hilliard Graves - Sean Couturier - Buster Harvey
Scott Pellerin - Forbes Kennedy - Joe Lamb
Everett Sannipass - Mike Eagles - Yvon Vautour

Don Sweeney - George Allen
Luc Bourdon - Charlie Bourgeois
Randy Jones - John Stevens

Jake Allen
Rollie Melanson