And that's exactly my point, I think the play out there has been mostly good. Most people who see him think it's been good. That's been the take internally. That's been the take by pundits and observers. That's been the feedback from eye tests and even underlying stats. It's been the feedback from other teams.
So the basic point is, while I agree with some of your observations, I don't know if I necessarily agree at the conclusion they arrive to.
Yes, he hasn't been perfect. He has things he needs to work on. But he certainly hasn't been bad. He hasn't looked over-matcjed. He's created chances out there and he's engaged. I notice him out there for positive reasons.
I don't think he's playing with 100 percent confidence, but I think that's typical of any teenager who is only 11 looks into his NHL competition. I mean we're barely past the month of what a rookie might see in the preseason --- especially if their team plays closer to 8 preseason games. So, yes, he's definitely still feeling his way around out there.
I don't see "extremely" tentative or "scared." I see a kid who is playing well, looks like he belongs, but is very much still learning.
Again, I would almost bet you a good money that if even half the opportunities he created are buried this weekend, probably 50 to 75 % of the more negative views don't exist. And that's without Lafreniere changing a darn thing.
Essentially, I don't feel like people are freaking out because of the on-ice performance. They're freaking out because they're staring at the box score and when there isn't a number next to Lafreniere's name they visit HockeyDB.com, ponder past high picks, and set themselves up for a panic attack that isn't fair to themselves or Lafreniere.