I really hope it's not the Devils. I do admit I could be over-reacting and upset over the recent news, but I think it would be a bad match up for Binghamton. Also, being a Rangers fan, it's possible my viewpoint is biased.
There arn't a lot of Devils fans in the area. Normally, this wouldn't be an issue in Binghamton (IE: Ottawa). The real problem is, Binghamton is hardcore Rangers and Sabres territory.
Obviously, the Rangers would be a huge success and is the ideal option. I'm not going to focus on that right now.
As a Rangers fan it would be very difficult for me to get behind a Devils affiliate, and root for them. The scarier part is a lot of my Ranger fan friends have said the same exact thing. If this is what happens, the best idea would be to give the team an original name and color scheme. If they did this, they would have a better chance of succeeding. However, Binghamton and New Jersey have a history of naming teams after the parent club. Add the history of how the Devils AHL club has been run, and I'm at a point where I'd rather make the 45 minute drive and watch the Jackals in Elmira.
Imho it would be similar to how the Utica Devils ended up. It's difficult for Upstate NY markets filled with Rangers fans to support a Devils affiliate.At the same time, I understand a smaller market like Binghamton doesn't have much choice. I never thought I'd say this, but I do wonder if it would be better to drop down to the ECHL for a bit while we wait for a better affiliate. I'm concerned if the Devils come in, and are not successful, it will lead to a reputation that we no longer support the AHL.
Of course, I could be wrong. However, being a long time resident, I just don't see how a Devils affiliate would be successful here. They've killed off many markets, and I don't want Bing to be next.