5 best 5 worst

[captainscott]

A little twist on the grade curve who were the 5 best and 5 worst Devils this season use their ability as a curve and what is expectations of that player


5 best

1. Bernie's
2. Carter
3. Green
4. Loki
5. I don't even have another

5 worst

1 Volch
2 zajac
3 henrique
4 broduer
5 hedberg

Click to read more...

 

[Zubrus Coffee Maker]

i think Green deserves #1 bar none

 

[captainscott]

i think Green deserves #1 bar none

Wasn't putting them in order but yeah he was
Good

 

[Bleedred]

Brodeur worse than Hedberg? WHAT? Yeah I think I'll go take a walk or something.

 

[Status Quo*]

Best:
Greene
Bernier
Lokti
Carter
Kovy

Worst:
Clarkson ( after first 10 games)
Harrold
Volch
Poni

 

[AfroThunder396]

The Good:

Greene
Loktionov
Larsson
Bernier
Elias


The Bad:

Henrique
Zajac
Salvador
Ponikarovsky
Tallinder


The Ugly:

Volchenkov
Clarkson
Hedberg
Harrold
Being 13-4-4 with a full lineup.

 

[Bleedred]

Best

1. Greene
2. Loktionov
3. Bernier
4. Carter
5. Either Gio or Marty before he got injured.

Worst

1. Volchenkov and not just cause I'm bitter and pissed about today either.
2. Clarkson after the first 12 games.
3. Ponikarovsky
4. Zajac
5. Elias when Kovalchuk got injured probably. Or for the whole year I'd say Harrold though even he only played half the games.

If Moose got more than 1.83 goals of support per game while Marty was out then maybe him.

 

[Devilsfan92]

I'll do three.

Best; Greene, Bernier & Loki
Worst; Volchenkov, Zajac & Hedberg were all on another level of bad

 

[bmqdevils]

Best in no order:
Bernier
Loktionov
Carter
Zubrus
Greene
Worst:
Zajac
Clarkson
Hedberg
ZIDLICKY.
Salvador
Tallinder
Henrique
Everybody at times

 

[captainscott]

Brodeur worse than Hedberg? WHAT? Yeah I think I'll go take a walk or something.

wasnt in order and also graded on what that player's expectations are ie: you expect more from kovy than gionta...

broduer is an hof goalie he had a bad year... but i wasnt putting them in order

 

[hlaverty06]

The Good:

1Greene
2.Loktionov
3.Larsson
4.Carter
5.Gionta

HM: Bernier

The Bad

1.Volchenkov






2. Zajac
3. Clarkson
4. Salvador





5.Hedberg (he was put in a tough spot to be fair, since mad man Pete wouldn't give him a break)

 

[captainscott]

well the one consistant theme

bernier and carter had good seasons....swell



have fun with the off season fellas

 

[Volodya Krutov]

Best:
Greene
Loki
Bernier
Zubrus
Zids

Worst impact on the team
Zajac
Hedberg
Kovy
Volchenkov
Elias

 

[SKNJD9]

Best

Greene
Elias
Larsson ( had his bad moments but saw a lot of good from him )
Loktionov
Kovy

Bad

Volchenkov
Zajac
Salvador
Hedberg
Clarkson ( minus the first 12 games of the yr )

 

[MountainGoat]

Best in order:
1. Greene
2. Elias
3. Bernier/Carter/Gionta line
4. Loki
5. Clarkson, he's an elite 3rd liner forced into a top 6 role because we have no depth in the top 6 and yet he leads the team in goals.

Worst:
1. Volchenkov, too slow and is a liability, buy him out.
2. Zajac, probably the most disappointing player this season.
3. Moose, too many softies and couldn't make the big saves we needed from him and he cost us alot of games. I still can't hate the guy though, he's very likable lol.
4. Lou, our top 6 is the worst we've had in a long time.
5. Harrold

 

[Bleedred]

I actually thought Kovy had a very good season before he was injured. For what he was given to work with at least. There was one game he rang it off the pipe two different times on breakaways and he was hitting a lot of posts.

When you go from playing with Zach Parise to a new left winger every game especially a rookie grinder like Matteau, and other mis mashes it takes a hit. He also had a new center almost every game until Loktionov came along.

 

[JimEIV]

There were no positives to this season. None whatsoever. Being competent is not being good and not a single player on this team rose above competency.

 

[JimEIV]

I actually thought Kovy had a very good season before he was injured.

Yeah, we couldn't have lived without his 3 or 4 even strength goals is 34 games.

Very good season when S. Gionta outscores you even strength.

 

[CerebralGenesis]

mic dropped by Jim

top 3:

CBGB

bottom 3:

Lou
Volchenkov
Moose

 

[SteveCangialosi123]

Best
1A.Bernier 1B.Carter(this is pretty clear to me)
3.Greene
4.Gionta
5.Loktionov

Worst
1.Zajac- big time
2.Hedberg
3.Volchenlov
4.Clarkson
5.Salvador

 

[AfroThunder396]

Yeah, we couldn't have lived without his 3 or 4 even strength goals is 34 games.

Very good season when S. Gionta outscores you even strength.

Come on Jim, cherry picking stats with two qualifiers is beneath you.

His shorthanded production was an enormous part of our success early on and you know that.

 

[JimEIV]

I would give credit to Loktionov. Far exceeded any expectations I had. Under better circumstances it would have been a great story.

 

[Bleedred]

I would give credit to Loktionov. Far exceeded any expectations I had. Under better circumstances it would have been a great story.

Weren't quite a few of Loktionov's points scored by or assisted by Kovalchuk?

 

[JimEIV]

Come on Jim, cherry picking stats with two qualifiers is beneath you.

His shorthanded production was an enormous part of our success early on and you know that.

Are you serious? Cherry picking stats? The guy scored 4 even strength goals this season ...you can't spin that disgusting fact in any positive manner. He literally did nothing 5v5 all season.. Nothing. The guy is being paid 11 million real dollars a season now to score goals and he is something like 7th on the team in 5v5 goal scoring not factoring TOI. That is ridiculous no matter what positive you might be able to find. I'm sorry if you can look at Kovalchuk's production this season and in any way say it was adequate you're simply making excuses.

 

[JimEIV]

Weren't quite a few of Loktionov's points scored by or assisted by Kovalchuk?

Great.