Prospect Info: 2024 Memorial Cup (Saginaw Wins - Beck Named MVP)

[Tyson]

Glad Dickinson is getting some more recognition with this Mem Cup. Kid is legit and definitely would be a great pick at 5 for us if he ends up a Habs.

If the Habs drafted Dickinson I would be ok with it %.

 

[ChesterNimitz]

Glad Dickinson is getting some more recognition with this Mem Cup. Kid is legit and definitely would be a great pick at 5 for us if he ends up a Habs.

He’s a much superior prospect than Mailloux. No comparison.

 

[Tyson]

He’s a much superior prospect than Mailloux. No comparison.

If anyone would know it would be you sir.

 

[Team_Spirit]

No longer alone on the Dickinson train lfg

https://x.com/i/web/status/1794471082683961795

 

[ChesterNimitz]

If anyone would know it would be you sir.

My conclusion is, regrettable.

 

[Scintillating10]

Yeah, but we shouldn't draft him 'cause of Trudeau, Struble, Harris.......Geez, if anything...you draft Dickinson, and if Xhekaj and Hutson are untouchables......TRADE Guhle. And if he's that good, imagine the great player we will have in return for him.

So not only you keep the very same depth. But you could replace a Guhle by a better....Guhle. AND you acquire a top end forward.

But somehow, let's settle for Sennecke. 'Cause you know.....needs.....Just insane takes.

Note: I am NOT saying that Dickinson is a better Guhle. Not saying that Sennecke is a bust. My takes on those prospects are irrelevant. It's the THOUGHT PROCESS of DON'T GO LEFT D because of depth that it's insane to me.

What player you want for Guhle? Hard trade to make

 

[Habs]

He’s a much superior prospect than Mailloux. No comparison.

He's leaps and bounds better than The Bach too.

 

[ChesterNimitz]

He's leaps and bounds better than The Bach too.

I prefer Chopin myself.

 

[dcyhabs]

I would be fine with this. But I don't think it's what management will do.

It's harder to get top talent at any podition than it is to fill the wing position. Though the question remains what can you get for Guhle? Yes, I don't think it will be easy for Hughes to get another Dach at that price. That was a unique situation where Chicago were giving away their players to tank.

Keep playing Guhle on the right when you have to?

 

[BLONG7]

If anyone would know it would be you sir.

Agreed.............Cherster is like EF Hutton, we all need to listen when this man speaks.

 

[MarkovsKnee]

He’s a much superior prospect than Mailloux. No comparison.

I mean, yeah. Lol

There really isn't.

 

[MarkovsKnee]

What player you want for Guhle? Hard trade to make

I wouldn't. He's fine on RD. In fact, I like him there. It keeps him on his forehand. It's pretty normal for LD to also be able to play RD. He played it in Junior as well.

 

[Tyson]

I wouldn't. He's fine on RD. In fact, I like him there. It keeps him on his forehand. It's pretty normal for LD to also be able to play RD. He played it in Junior as well.

Many great LD had hall of fame careers playing RD, most notably of course was Bobby Orr. If you watch alot of old videos you will see Doug Harvey played there quite a bit.

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

I mean, yeah. Lol

There really isn't.

What makes Dickenson that much better? I don't see a great player there.

 

[MarkovsKnee]

What makes Dickenson that much better? I don't see a great player there.

Dude, he's way better defensively. He's outstanding with his stick, which is a necessity for defensive play. He reads plays better both defensively and offensively. He's a better playmaker and has better vision. He's also an overall a better skater.

The only thing I would give to Mailloux is his shot. His wrist shot is unbelievable, but he can't always get it through because he lacks deception.

 

[General Fanager]

Dude, he's way better defensively. He's outstanding with his stick, which is a necessity for defensive play. He reads plays better both defensively and offensively. He's a better playmaker and has better vision. He's also an overall a better skater.

The only thing I would give to Mailloux is his shot. His wrist shot is unbelievable, but he can't always get it through because he lacks deception.

is he a late riser? I haven't seen a mock that have him that high. Most have him going 9th or later.....

 

[MarkovsKnee]

is he a late riser? I haven't seen a mock that have him that high. Most have him going 9th or later.....

No, he started last summer in #2 position on a lot of lists, and was still #2 on mid-season lists. He's not a riser, at all. If anything he's fallen a bit to 6-10 position from 2-5.

 

[General Fanager]

No, he started last summer in #2 position on a lot of lists, and was still #2 on mid-season lists. He's not a riser, at all. If anything he's fallen a bit to 6-10 position from 2-5.

I see.

I am a big BPA guy but I get the gut feeling they are hard after a forward.....

 

[MarkovsKnee]

I see.

I am a big BPA guy but I get the gut feeling they are hard after a forward.....

They are. There are some quality forwards to pick at #5. We'll see how things play out.

 

[Habs]

I prefer Chopin myself.

You remind me of my infamous High School Headmaster, and it scares me.

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

Dude, he's way better defensively. He's outstanding with his stick, which is a necessity for defensive play. He reads plays better both defensively and offensively. He's a better playmaker and has better vision. He's also an overall a better skater.

The only thing I would give to Mailloux is his shot. His wrist shot is unbelievable, but he can't always get it through because he lacks deception.

Interesting. I think Dickinson should be a very good defenseman. i don't see a star though.

 

[Habs]

Interesting. I think Dickinson should be a very good defenseman. i don't see a star though.

Star Dmen are so hard to find, so rare. Good ones, sure.. but Makar level.. so rare. Do you consider Fox a star?

 

[MarkovsKnee]

Interesting. I think Dickinson should be a very good defenseman. i don't see a star though.

I guess it depends on how you feel about Dobson or Bouchard? He's better defensively and more physical than both. I think he has Dobson's offensive upside, for sure.

 

[Ajhccwrs]

Dickinson is a trap at 5. Hope we don't fall for it

 

[dinodebino]

Dickinson, if that valuable, will get picked before 5th.