Prospect Info: 2024 HF Oilers Prospect Rankings #5

[The Nuge]

Jarventie edges out Wanner for #4.

Rank
#1. Matthew Savoie (TR)
#2. Beau Akey (2)
#3. Sam O'Reilly (ND)
#4. Roby Jarventie (TR)
#5.


( ) - Previous Year Ranking
UR - Unranked Previously
ND - Newly Drafted
TR - Acquired Via Trade
HM - Honourable Mention

Spoiler: “2023) Rankings”

No Poll Done / Lowetide top 20
#1. Xavier Bourgault (3)
#2. Beau Akey (ND)
#3. Raphael Lavoie (11)
#4. Olivier Rodrigue (HM)
#5. Max Wanner (HM)
#6. Matvey Petrov (5)
#7. Maxim Berezkin (19)
#8. Shane Lachance (ND)
#9. Nikita Yevseyev (ND)
#10. James Hamblin (16)
#11. Carter Savoie (7)
#12. Tyler Tullio (8)
#13. Matt Copponi (ND)
#14. Cam Dineen (UR)
#15. Jayden Grubbe (UR)
#16. Markus Niemelainen (10)
#17. Ben Gleason (UR)
#18. Noel Hoffenmeyer (UR)
#19. Phil Kemp (18)
#20. Luca Munzenberger (14)

Spoiler: “2022 Rankings”

#1. Dylan Holloway (#2)
#2. Philip Broberg (#3)
#3. Xavier Bourgault (#5)
#4. Stuart Skinner (#11)
#5. Matvey Petrov (#20)
#6. Reid Schaefer (new draftee)
#7. Carter Savoie (#10)
#8. Tyler Tullio (#12)
#9. Dmitri Samorukov (#4)
#10. Markus Niemelainen (unranked)
#11. Raphael Lavoie (#7)
#12. Vincent Desharnais (unranked)
#13. Michael Kesselring (#13)
#14. Luca Munzenberger (#19)
#15. Ryan Fanti (new signee)
#16. James Hamblin (unranked)
#17. Jake Chiasson (unranked)
#18. Philip Kemp (unranked)
#19. Maksim Berezkin (#17)
#20. Joel Maata (new draftee)

Honourable mentions
Maximus Wanner
Olivier Rodrigue
Noah Philp

Spoiler: “2021 Rankings”

Prospect Info: - HFOil's 2021 Final Top-20 Prospect Ranking

We're done! What are your overall thoughts on the Oilers prospect pool as it stands? Who is too high/low on this ranking? Who will surprise/disappoint this year and who are you most excited to watch? :edmonton HFOil's Top-20 Oilers Prospects Eligibility:

forums.hfboards.com

1. Evan Bouchard - RD (83.3%)
2. Dylan Holloway - C/LW (77.2%)
3. Philip Broberg - LD (74.8%)
4. Dmitri Samorukov - LD (53.7)
5. Xavier Bourgault - C/RW (50%)
6. Ryan McLeod - C (57.6%)
7. Raphael Lavoie - RW (66.7%)
8. Ilya Konovalov - G (50%)
9. Tyler Benson - LW (45.8%)
10. Carter Savoie - W (58.2%)
11. Stuart Skinner - G (64.6%)
12. Ty Tullio - RW (34.9%)
13. Michael Kesselring - RD (50%)
14. Cooper Marody - C (42.5%)
15. Olivier Rodrigue - G (26.0%)
16. Kirill Maksimov - W (35.9%)
17. Maxim Beryozkin - W (40.0%)
18. Filip Berglund - RD (30.0%)
19. Luca Munzenberger - LD (33.9%)
20. Matvei Petrov - LW (63.6%)

Spoiler: 2020 Rankings

Prospect Info: - HFOIL 2020 Prospect Rankings (Poll #20)

1. Philip Broberg
2. Evan Bouchard
3. Dylan Holloway
4. Dmitri Samorukov
5. Tyler Benson
6. Raphael Lavoie
7. Ryan McLeod
8. Ilya Konovalov
9. William Lagesson
10. Tyler Tullio
11. Filip Berglund
12. Carter Savoie
13. Olivier Rodrigue
14. Kirill Maksimov
15. Michael Kesselring
16. Cooper Marody
17. Philip Kemp
18. Stuart Skinner
19. Maxim Beryozkin
20. Aapeli Rasanen

Spoiler: 2019 Rankings

No Poll Done / Lowetide top 20

#1. Evan Bouchard
#2. Philip Broberg
#3. Ethan Bear
#4. Tyler Benson
#5. Raphael Lavoie
#6. Caleb Jones
#7. Kailer Yamamoto
#8. Dmitri Samorukov
#9. Ryan McLeod
#10. William Lagesson
#11. Cooper Marody
#12. Kirill Maksimov
#13. Ilya Konovalov
#14. Olivier Rodrigue
#15. Joakin Nygaard
#16. Joel Persson
#17. Filip Berglund
#18. Shane Starret
#19. Stuart Skinner
#20. Aapeli Rasanen

Spoiler: 2018 Rankings

Prospect Info: - HFOil Top 20 Oilers Prospects 2018 (Final Rankings)

1) Evan Bouchard
2) Kailer Yamamoto
3) Ethan Bear
4) Tyler Benson
5) Ryan McLeod
6) Kirill Maksimov
7) Caleb Jones
8) Stuart Skinner
9) Cooper Marody
10) Ostap Safin
11) William Lagesson
12) Filip Berglund
13) Dmitri Samorukov
14) Olivier Rodrigue
15) Joel Persson
16) Aapeli Rasanen
17) Philip Kemp
18) Cameron Hebig
19) Graham McPhee
20) Tyler Vesel

Spoiler: 2017 Rankings

Prospect Info: - HFOil Top 20 Oilers Prospects 2017 (FINAL RANKINGS)

1) Jesse Puljujarvi
2) Kailer Yamamoto
3) Caleb Jones
4) Ethan Bear
5) Tyler Benson
6) Laurent Brossoit
7) Ziyat Paigin
8) Jujhar Khaira
9) Dylan Wells
10) Joe Gambardella
11) Nick Ellis
12) Ryan Mantha
13) Dmitri Samorukov
14) Ostap Safin
15) Aapeli Rasanen
16) Kirill Maksimov
17) Filip Berglund
18) Stuart Skinner
19) Markus Niemelainen
20) John Marino

Click to read more...

 

[slim2001]

Polls are much appreciated

 

[joestevens29]

What kind names we going to have 20 this year?

 

[The Nuge]

What kind names we going to have 20 this year?

It's definitely looking a little thin. There aren't even any prospects taken in the first 4 rounds that aren't on the list. Our top 10 or so prospects are at least all guys who have a shot at the NHL still though

 

[TopShelfGloveSide]

Between Wanner and Berezkin

 

[5 Mins 4 Ftg]

Lavoie need to have a killer training camp.

 

[McDNicks17]

Going Vinni here.

Really exciting prospect. Great tools. Arguably the best goalie prospect in the draft.

 

[Behind Enemy Lines]

Top 5 and Tiers

1.Savioe - top line wing potential. Only blue chip in bad prospect system. Arrival this season or next.


2.O'Reilly - future hard ice 3C replacement. Big development year ahead with see if offensive potential manifests with junior team opportunity. Arrival three years..
3. Akey - prospective mid-size, puck mover 3 RD with some stretch upside to reach 2RD. Arrival window in three years.
4. Wanner - prospective hard ice goal suppression defender 3RD. Arrival window in two to three seasons.


5.Jarventie - second organization established AHL player with NHL games in. Recovery time on major injury with opportunity to complete for top 9 forward job in two seasons.
5.B Lavoie - big, productive mid-range shooter among the youngest of AHL top 10 goal scorers and at crossroads of NHL opportunity in Edmonton.

 

[Tobias Kahun]

Top 5 and Tiers

1.Savioe - top line wing potential. Only blue chip in bad prospect system. Arrival this season or next.


2.O'Reilly - future hard ice 3C replacement. Big development year ahead with see if offensive potential manifests with junior team opportunity. Arrival three years..
3. Akey - prospective mid-size, puck mover 3 RD with some stretch upside to reach 2RD. Arrival window in three years.
4. Wanner - prospective hard ice goal suppression defender 3RD. Arrival window in two to three seasons.


5.Jarventie - second organization established AHL player with NHL games in. Recovery time on major injury with opportunity to complete for top 9 forward job in two seasons.
5.B Lavoie - big, productive mid-range shooter among the youngest of AHL top 10 goal scorers and at crossroads of NHL opportunity in Edmonton.

Not a bad list, but I would drop Wanner to the 3rd tier. I think it depends on how Jarventie bounces back after knee surgery.

 

[Forgot About Drai]

I like the russian.

 

[Behind Enemy Lines]

Not a bad list, but I would drop Wanner to the 3rd tier. I think it depends on how Jarventie bounces back after knee surgery.

Yes, I can see that. Personally I think strong goal suppression defenders can be undervalued. Add a premium for right shot ones with size and in Wanner's case solid skating ability. His age 20 first pro season was impressive when compared to some of the organization's forwards who onboarded at easier positions. There's a strong growth potential base I'm looking forward to seeing in year two with more experience and maturity (mental and physically).

Jarventie everything likely hinges (no pun intended) on his knee. Point a game AHL production by age 21 used to be a solid measure for NHL future. Small sample as Jarventie was hurt last year. But a good base toolkit with projectable size, skill and offensive production potential. But for me right shot hard physical d who can skate is a tougher asset to find.