Prospect Info: 2024 Ducks Prospect Rankings #6
- Thread starter MMC
- Start date
- Status
MMC
Global Moderator
First poll I'm really intrigued to see the results of. None of the first 5 were close but I expect this one to be
Going with Peterson.super quick, great hands and quick shot. Has a great defensive game too. He’s our Marner hopefully without the drama queen attached.
Clang was a close call. He’s my next.
Edit. Sorry meant Clara not Clang.
Clang was a close call. He’s my next.
Edit. Sorry meant Clara not Clang.
Last edited:
MMC
Global Moderator
Interested to hear what makes you remain so high on Clang? He's ok and I think he still has a shot to make it but just among Ducks goalie prospects I'd have Clara and Suchanek ahead of him.
Boo Boo
Registered User
- Jan 31, 2013
- 2,269
- 2,483
Is it too early for suchanek - he was pretty fantastic in the ahl this year and our goalie development system can be trusted to develop him to the nhl in my opinion
MMC
Global Moderator
TheGoodShepard1
Dongle Digits.
- Nov 26, 2017
- 10,291
- 14,975
I went with Dionicio, I think he has the most intriguing high-end skillset of all the players left. Bit bullish on him, but there’s potentially top-pairing upside if he can put it all together and improve the skating IMO
goonsaredumb
Registered User
- Sep 30, 2022
- 766
- 1,479
Could go one of multiple ways, mainly because there are different stages of development and the goalie position.
Pettersson has actual top 6 center upside
Colangelo is closest to NHL ready
Clara as the goalie of the future holds importance rivaling Gauthier and Sennecke
Suchanek is a wild card because of the size but his impact was undeniable
Sidorov is still a work in progress, but he could be a big time scorer
I went with Clara, as he has now shown nothing but great progress, quite similarly to Dostal before him.
Pettersson has actual top 6 center upside
Colangelo is closest to NHL ready
Clara as the goalie of the future holds importance rivaling Gauthier and Sennecke
Suchanek is a wild card because of the size but his impact was undeniable
Sidorov is still a work in progress, but he could be a big time scorer
I went with Clara, as he has now shown nothing but great progress, quite similarly to Dostal before him.
Colangelo for me. He stood out at the prospect scrimmage last year, and then had a strong NCAA season and a good limited showing in the AHL/NHL.
Think I'm going dionicio. Feel like he has the highest ceiling of the rest of our guys and is incredibly unique.
I feel like Colangelo can be a super effective role player in the top 6. While he may not get the most points, his value could be tremendous for us.
Arthuros
Registered Snoozer
I'm missing context on Clara because I tend not to put much stock in players until they're close to the NHL. I know he's been good, but I guess I don't have any idea if he's any better than Suchanek.
Colangelo gets my vote here.
Colangelo gets my vote here.
Pettersson for me. Top 6 upside hard to pass up. Clara is super close for me but goalies are so tough to rank. I get Colangelo but I think he upside of the other two is higher.
WhatTheDuck
9 - 20 - 8
Based on his raw potential (size/athleticism) and very impressive showing in a men's league at a young age, I have to go with Clara here. A strong showing in the SHL this year, will cement him as one of the game's elite goalie prospects, he's likely top 10 already.
MMC
Global Moderator
Suchanek is 2 years older and proven on NA ice but if you're the type who tends to vote on these polls based on ceilings with Clara's physical traits and the fact that he had a very impressive season in his own right leads me to believe his upside is higher
- Jul 25, 2012
- 41,675
- 37,973
You tryin to piss off montreal fans or something
Went with Clara.... think he has huge upside for us.
Dont mind Pettersson here... i just really dont know much about his game/upside.... wasnt a player that was on my radar at all this draft year. I did have Masse as a target with our potential oiler pick(prior to trading up)
Colangelo is who i figured would run away with it, kinda surprised he didnt.
A guy that really impresses me, maybe more so than any prospect we have right now is Sidorov... I keep thinking hes a long shot, but then i see him at the camp, or in game tapes and im like shit maybe we have something with him.
Last edited:
AngelDuck
Rak 'em up
- Jun 16, 2012
- 23,407
- 17,303
Going off the board with Terrance here. He’s been stuck on a horrible junior team his whole career and more than held his own. I see a breakout coming for him. Has the skill to play at the next level.
There’s a massive group of prospects here that are really close. I considered 6 different names before deciding
I think Colangelo is next for me
There’s a massive group of prospects here that are really close. I considered 6 different names before deciding
I think Colangelo is next for me
Dirk316
Registered User
- Jul 25, 2012
- 41,675
- 37,973
Dirk316
Registered User
I agree that he has a higher potential than people might appreciate. I don't think he has the highest, simply because I don't think he has the offense in him, but I do think he has a higher chance of playing a large future role than people might realize.
Separately, trying to guess anything with goaltenders is a fool's errand.
Smirnov2Chistov
EEK!
I hope (for their developments sake) Warren and Smith work out. Two big bodied defenseman that would really help this physically-deficient dcore
goonsaredumb
Registered User
- Sep 30, 2022
- 766
- 1,479
I just don't see a world where Warren is anything more than a bottom pairing guy and I think even that is a long shot.
Despite his physical gifts he couldn't even dominate the Q as an overager and even took a big step back production wise add on top of that how awful he looked at the WJC and his injuries and I just don't see what anyone else sees in him for his name to even be coming up this early.
Despite his physical gifts he couldn't even dominate the Q as an overager and even took a big step back production wise add on top of that how awful he looked at the WJC and his injuries and I just don't see what anyone else sees in him for his name to even be coming up this early.
- Status
