GDT: 2023 Upper Deck NHL Draft: 1st Round, June 28, 7 p.m. et | ESPN, SN, TVAS: Nashville, TN

Status
Not open for further replies.

A Loyal Demidog

Marc Bergevin's Bitch
Oct 20, 2016
9,783
11,979
Michkov has potential to be a franchise, even generational player.

Would you risk trading that for a much lesser player, a mid-late 1st round pick (likely bust or 4th liner) and a decent-ish player???

There’s a reason other fanbases asked for Slafkovsky/Suzuki+ for Montreal to go up just 1 spot when it’s a Big 5 prize. And we’re willing to trade down for magic beans? f*** off!
 

Kosseca

Registered User
Feb 23, 2020
1,366
1,216
We weren't talking "value", we were talking "BPA", you said trading down would be the best way to get BPA. Sure you could get "more value", or maybe more quantity, but you don't get a better BPA by trading down. Geez dude.
Ok, i'll bite... you need some explanation....

BPA is a subjective construct. You decide who is the BPA and this may be different then the one another has. So... if you think you can take that BPA at a lower rank.... you trade down and get additional assets in the process = value for pick.
 

Tabarouette

ben kin
Jan 28, 2013
15,260
5,285
mtl
Michkov has potential to be a franchise, even generational player.

Would you risk trading that for a much lesser player, a mid-late 1st round pick (likely bust or 4th liner) and a decent-ish player???

There’s a reason other fanbases asked for Slafkovsky/Suzuki+ for Montreal to go up just 1 spot when it’s a Big 5 prize. And we’re willing to trade down for magic beans? f*** off!

we're Habs-pilled bro, guys who can score aren't part of the habs CULTURE
 
  • Like
Reactions: Twisted Sinister

WeThreeKings

Demidov is a HAB
Sep 19, 2006
95,677
107,362
Halifax
I just don’t like when people bring up hf posters like they’ve earned their stars. @WeThreeKings talks a big game but has never backed it up. His opinion is just that of opinion. Why do we care about what he says above others? Or give credit?

What do I have to back up?

I have never said my opinion is more than an opinion and the reason why someone might give me more credit than another poster might be because I give my honest opinion and sometimes I've been right on things, I've also been really wrong on other things.. but in the end, I actually watch the prospects and I'm kind enough to share my list every year.

There's a core group of draft junkies on these boards who have been here a long time and we have fun discussing, debating and putting our lists against one another. We are just having fun, if anyone takes something I've said as my opinion as gospel and feels burned, that's on them.
 

Barriwhite

Don’t be shocked by the tone of my voice
Nov 8, 2005
1,972
367
Montreal
I'm a francophone...but can somebody explain Leroux post to me...I have no idea what he's saying? lol
I think he tried to say that he thinks Habs are trading down if Michkov is still there at 5 and Fantilli/Smith/Carlsson are gone. And it came out weird as hell.
 

junyab

Registered User
Jan 22, 2013
2,035
1,220
Ok, i'll bite... you need some explanation....

BPA is a subjective construct. You decide who is the BPA and this may be different then the one another has. So... if you think you can take that BPA at a lower rank.... you trade down and get additional assets in the process = value for pick.
No. Because we're talking about the BPA. It doesn't matter if that player is ranked 5th or 8th. If you think the 8th ranked player is the BPA available, you don't trade down and risk that player being selected 6th or 7th if you only want BPA. You only do this to add VALUE. Montreal would trade down to add value/assets, not to select the BPA.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad