CabanaBoy5
Registered User
It’s something that’s difficult to quantify because the play might have been made without the shift. But you’re right, I do notice it more when the shift is beaten. It did work earlier in the game when Chapman caught that ball that carried him close to second base.The Jays have one of the best infield defences in baseball even with Bichette's inconsistency. What's likely happening is that you don't notice the 8/10 times the shift works to their advantage, but since you seemingly don't like shifts the 2/10 times it doesn't work stand out.
I just think it’s being overused right now because it’s the sexy analytic thing to do. Some guys are catching on and just putting bat to ball, especially with two strikes.