So two of the questions I keep getting asked the most are:
1. How high is Lafreniere's potential?
2. How does he compare to past first overall picks, namely MacKinnon.
The answer to the first question is that I think you're looking at a player with legit franchise-level potential. He's that good.
The answer to the second question is little harder to pin point, but I think Lafreniere holds his own quite well at the same age.
MacKinnon is a natural comparison because they both came from Q, they both have physical/competitive side, and they have very good physical frames as well.
Frankly, having seen both players as teenagers, I honestly think Lafreniere is right where MacKinnon was at the roughly the same ages. Obviously it's impossible to say if Lafreniere will hit the levels that MacKinnon has, but it's not entirely out of the realm of possibility either. It's certainly not wish-casting.
Play wise, both guys dominated. That's a given.
But even if we just look at the numbers, and adjust for games played, the results at the same age are remarkably similar. Again, that's not the sole gauge for future success, but it is at least worth looking at.
I removed Lafreniere's draft season, because he was almost a year older than MacKinnon at that point in time. But if we line up Lafreniere's D-2 and D-1 seasons, he's only about 5 weeks younger than MacKinnon was. If we just do a simple adjustment for regular season and playoff games played, we get this result in a blind sampling of statistical results: