Makar. I think Hughes will struggle to adapt right away and end up with 45-55. Kakko won't have a great team around him and won't have a guy like Taylor Hall to feed to or Nico Hischier to take the tough minutes.
Makar will be on a playoff team playing top pair and number one PP minutes with MacKinnon, Rantanen and whoever else they sign this summer. He's had more time to grow as a player, and is just as dynamic. Give me Makar with roughly the same number of points as the other two from the back end.