GDT: 2018 WJC • Game 03 • Group A: CAN (4) - FIN (2) F

[The Macho King]

Defender is not allowed to play the puck with hand in the goalie zone.

You get penaltyshot if he does...

Read the rules...

Not allowed to close hand on the puck - at least in NHL. You can use it though.

 

[PG Canuck]

You are not allowed to throw the puck away with your hand, also it's not allowed to touch it on the paint.

Wrong sport.

 

[JFG]

I swear Europeans don't understand hockey. Especially so called fans.

Please don’t lump the rest of us together with the finns in this thread.

 

[jepjepjoo]

Puck was on edge and crossed the goal line...

 

[Patrik Barkov]

Rule 618 | Handling Puck with Hands

(a) Play shall be stopped and a last play face-off shall occur anytime a player (except the goalkeeper) closes his hand on the puck and does not immediately drop the puck to the ice.
A minor penalty for delay of game shall be assessed to any player, other than the goalkeeper, who picks the puck up from the ice with his hand(s) while play is in progress.
A penalty shot/optional minor penalty shall be awarded to the non-offending team anytime a defending player, other than the goalkeeper, picks the puck up off the ice with his hand or holds the puck while play is in progress and the puck is in the goal crease. If this infraction occurs while the goalkeeper has been removed from the ice and prevents and obvious and imminent goal, a goal shall be awarded to the non-offending team

What do you make of this? Guessing Fabbro didn't hold or pick up the up.

 

[Leafsdude7]

You are not allowed to throw the puck away with your hand, also it's not allowed to touch it on the paint.

[Citation Needed]

 

[Brun0]

the game is 3-3 currently

 

[QnebO]

No it didn't.

It did, there was frame by frame of it. The puck was rolling but that still counts. If puck is 100% over goal line its a goal but I guess the videoref thought its unclear enough so he can call it no goal. I mean its just under inch over the line but if you stop the pick it is

 

[DatDude44]

Katchouk will get player of the game but I think Thomas deserves it

Yep, and katchouk has been real good imo. But thomas's raw talent as well as sound defense has been on display....i think there are plenty of points to follow for him as the tourney goes on.

 

[Psych0dad]

The puck crossed the line on the first goal of the game. Go check the replay

Not while game was still going. Net dislodged automatically stops the game and you can't score after it's stopped. It doesn't go by when ref blows whistle. It goes by which happens first, puck fully over line or net dislodged. There was no question. Net was off, game was stopped. It couldn't be a goal according to rulebook.

 

[Arto Kilponen]

Defender is not allowed to play puck with hand in goalie zone.

You get penaltyshot if he does...

You sound sure. Can you quote the exact rule here?

 

[chauron]

Hey you fellow finns, let's stop whining and show some SISU instead. It's just two goals

Additionally a match like this should boost the teams' motivation to play better in the future

 

[New User Name]

If this game is any indication, the US will make mince meat of both these teams.

 

[Emerz]

Hey wtf are you allowed to do that? By hand

Yes,

You are not allowed to throw the puck away with your hand, also it's not allowed to touch it on the paint.

You're just wrong my friend, you can indeed, as long as you don't close your hand on the puck.

 

[QnebO]

Finnish fans: if you blame this game, no matter it’s outcome, on your goaltender, you’re out to lunch. He’s the only reason you aren’t down by four or five this period.

No its the posts

 

[BB88]

missed football hold there against Heiskanen.

 

[Gsus]

Pssst...the puck has to fully cross the line to be called a goal.

Also psstt.. You don't allow goals that go in when the goal posts are off and also a slight interference from the goal scorer.

 

[The Macho King]

Katchouk will get player of the game but I think Thomas deserves it

Just give it to that whole line.

 

[CantLoseWithMatthews]

Finnish fans: if you blame this game, no matter it’s outcome, on your goaltender, you’re out to lunch. He’s the only reason you aren’t down by four or five this period.

Don't worry, I'm pretty sure they're mainly blaming the refs

 

[kabidjan18]

No goal, I guess it is allowed to take the puck and throw it away if you feel like it?

The reason this never happens is because of practicality purposes. You could also try skating on one leg, you'd find very quickly that you'd get nowhere with it. If the situation arises you can use your hands, but you'd never do that normally because your reach with your arms is poor compared to with a stick. 99% of times you won't get near it.

 

[PG Canuck]

Soccer, lol.

Read the hockey rules.

Find them then and prove me wrong. I'll wait.

 

[JustaFinnishGuy]

Finnish fans: if you blame this game, no matter it’s outcome, on your goaltender, you’re out to lunch. He’s the only reason you aren’t down by four or five this period.

Moot point. He hasn't made a play by himself, he has stood in front by luck in some situations. If he truly was a reason we would be tied, we would be.
There's nothing positive to be said about the defense, but nobody is safe from criticism when nearly everyone on the ice has made glaring mistakes.

 

[turkulad]

Not really.

So both the first goal and that no goal are already canonized in the Canadian collective psyche as non-controversial, unwavering and solid as granite?

 

[y2kcanucks]

Not while game was still going. Net dislodged automatically stops the game and you can't score after it's stopped. It doesn't go by when ref blows whistle. It goes by which happens first, puck fully over line or net dislodged. There was no question. Net was off, game was stopped. It couldn't be a goal according to rulebook.

Net displacement does not automatically stop the game. Ref also did not blow the whistle.

 

[LOFIN]

The puck crossed the line. It was clear. What's being debated is whether the net was off and whether it should have been called a goal based on that.

Well, that's what I was arguing. The net was loose before the puck crossed the line.

But this is useless arguing, it's not like Finland is losing because of these calls. We have not been good enough. Bad calls happen, and we have to accept that.

 

[jj cale]

LOL, seriously?

Of course I am, you are well known for what you are around here fantomas.

Hence you are disregarded in these matters.

Sorry, but thats what you have justly earned.