2018 Redraft 2024 Edition

[Brookbank]

This is the 2018 draft class in order of points. In what order should the top 5 be ?

 

[Frank Drebin]

Yeesh that is bad outside top 6

Hughes
Dahlin
Tkachuk
Bouchard
Dobson
Svech

?

 

[M2Beezy]

Quinn Hughes

 

[thrillhous]

Yeesh that is bad outside top 5

Hughes
Dahlin
Tkachuk
Bouchard
Dobson

?

… then Svech, then the ?

 

[Frank Drebin]

… then Svech, then the ?

Yeah forgot svech

 

[hotcabbagesoup]

Svech can be great sometimes but he's I think after Ovechkin punched him in the face, he's lost consistency.

Dahlin is an idiot so. Such low IQ.

Hughes
Tkachuk
Bouchard
Dobson
Svech
Dahlin
Farabee

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

Svech can be great sometimes but he's I think after Ovechkin punched him in the face, he's lost consistency.

Dahlin is an idiot so. Such low IQ.

Hughes
Tkachuk
Bouchard
Dobson
Svech
Dahlin
Farabee

Yeah no Dahlin is still 2nd and I say rhis as a Sens fan.

Hughes
Dahlin
Tkachuk
Bouchard/Dobson (Bouchard needs to have another 2024 playoff run in order for me to consider him clearly above Dobson)
Bouchard/Dobson
Svech
Miller
Farabee
Hayton
Durzi

 

[hotcabbagesoup]

Yeah no Dahlin is still 2nd and I say rhis as a Sens fan.

Hughes
Dahlin
Tkachuk
Bouchard/Dobson (Bouchard needs to have another 2024 playoff run in order for me to consider him clearly above Dobson)
Bouchard/Dobson
Svech
Miller
Farabee
Hayton
Durzi

Thanks for adding KAndre Miller to the list. Will get to see him play next SJ vs NYR. Miller was picked one spot after the Sharks pick, the enigmatic Ryan Merkley lol. I wanted Miller so bad that draft haha.

Merkley of course, is in the KHL.

 

[HockeyWooot]

Hughes
Tkachuk
Dahlin
Dobson
Bouchard
Svechnikov
Dostal

Miller
Farabee
Sharangovich
Marchenko
Fehervary
Kotkaniemi
Romanov
Samuelsson
Durzi

Hayton
McLeod
Kurashev
Ersson
Kesselring
Pospisil
McBain
Wahlstrom

Holmberg
Kupari
Bahl
Hofer
Dewar
Harris
Emberson
Dellandrea
Boqvist

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

Hughes
Tkachuk
Dahlin
Dobson
Bouchard
Svechnikov
Dostal

Miller
Farabee
Sharangovich
Marchenko
Fehervary
Kotkaniemi
Romanov
Samuelsson
Durzi

Hayton
McLeod
Kurashev
Ersson
Kesselring
Pospisil
McBain
Wahlstrom

Holmberg
Kupari
Bahl
Hofer
Dewar
Harris
Emberson
Dellandrea
Boqvist

A surprisingly good draft for the Oilers. One 1RHD in Bouchard. A strong 3C in McLeod and a promising 2nd pairing RHD in Kesselring.

 

[Coffee]

A surprisingly good draft for the Oilers. One 1RHD in Bouchard. A strong 3C in McLeod and a promising 2nd pairing RHD in Kesselring.

Great draft by the Oilers

 

[olli]

A surprisingly good draft for the Oilers. One 1RHD in Bouchard. A strong 3C in McLeod and a promising 2nd pairing RHD in Kesselring.

sure would be nice if the oilers could reverse that Bjugstad for Kesselring trade right about now

 

[CowbellConray]

Svech can be great sometimes but he's I think after Ovechkin punched him in the face, he's lost consistency.

Dahlin is an idiot so. Such low IQ.

Hughes
Tkachuk
Bouchard
Dobson
Svech
Dahlin
Farabee

Dahlin behind Bouchard is insane. I get it, Dahlin plays very tight to the line and will go over it, but he is a very clear #1D and has been for 3 years.

Hughes
Dahlin
Tkachuk
Dobson
Bouchard
Svech

 

[Brookbank]

Svech can be great sometimes but he's I think after Ovechkin punched him in the face, he's lost consistency.

Dahlin is an idiot so. Such low IQ.

Hughes
Tkachuk
Bouchard
Dobson
Svech
Dahlin
Farabee

I was waiting for someone to put Bouchard ahead of Dhalin. If anything, he's right there behind him, ready to pass him

 

[Bouboumaster]

Hughes, by far
Tkachuck
Dobson
Dahlin
Bouchard

 

[EdJovanovski]

1. Kravtsov
2. Hughes
3. Tkachuk
4. Dahlin
5. Svechnikov

 

[Raistlin]

1. Kravtsov
2. Hughes
3. Tkachuk
4. Dahlin
5. Svechnikov

was waiting for this guy to chime in.

Hughes - clear cut above
Tkachuk - too much of a unicorn to ignore
Dahlin - a 1D in most days with occasional brain cramps
Dobson - a 1D with a lower ceiling.
Bouchard - an elite PPQB