AlternateSideParking
Registered User
- Dec 11, 2005
- 21,606
- 5,141
Yup cause who in their right mind would ever want someone who scores 15 more points a season and has a +/- rating of 36 points higher???!???!?
What if we went nuts for centers and traded Stepan + Girardi + Nash for Eric Staal + Jordan Staal and a +? The cap difference would be fairly close and it would give us size down the middle. I admit, it's extreme--and I love G--but this would give us a bit more size and some strength where we're lacking it. It does make our RW look rather weak, though. Calculated risk? We're bringing in 2 cup winners on 2 different teams.
It would give us a slot to go after a PMD of some sort. Girardi has been great, but I've also seen some dissent regarding his spot in the system.
Kreider - E. Staal - MSL
Hagelin - J. Staal - Miller/Fast
Pouliot - Brass - Zuccs
Boyle - Moore - Dorsett
McD - Stralman
Staal - Niskanen
Moore - Klein
Assuming a $69,000,000 cap, it'd be a tight fit, but we'd make it. Could even move Dorsett for some extra padding and put in a cheaper option in Carcillo or someone else.
According to puckdaddy, Ottawa will try to trade Spezza out of the Eastern Conference.
I like Eric Staal, but hes a notorious underachiever.
Id rather have Kesler than Staal.
Yup cause who in their right mind would ever want someone who scores 15 more points a season and has a +/- rating of 36 points higher???!???!?
Regardless of how they have played in the last month, Staal would be a greater loss than Stralman because Klein is in much better condition to take over a top 4 role than John Moore is.
I think we've shown mathematically that this team can keep everyone, including Stralman, if we just buy out Richards and replace him with Miller/Lindberg at center.
It isn't ideal, but I'd prefer that than blowing up the whole roster to try to get another pivot in.
Why not Klein-Stralman?
lol having a defenseman on his offside has become so taboo on here.
They're going to command similar salaries also, which would make it that much more of a nightmare.
If we sign Niskanen and let Stralsy or Staal walk, I will lose all faith in the management here.
I'd rather figure out who to pair with Stralman than just let Stralman go.
Niskanen had a pretty good year IMO, better than Staal. I don't see why making an upgrade on defense will make one lose faith in management.
You could put a golden retriever on the Pens PP and it'd put up points.
15 points more this season. Niskanen is 27 and has scored over 40 points exactly once in his career. Also, that production just happened to come when he was spoon-fed PP time with one of the most potent offenses in the NHL. If you want to risk > $5M per year for 6 or 7 years on this being a breakout season, that's your prerogative.
Gardiner already has two 30 point seasons under his belt before the age of 24. He's cost controlled. He also plays the left side, which makes him a more viable partner for Stralman.
Well it wouldn't be if the defense we had were capable of playing on their off side, but they haven't been. Only McD.