If Staal is moved there better be quite a bit coming back. That makes re-signing Stralman a necessity. If it returns a young-ish top-6 center or a bigger 3rd line C + 1st or something along those lines I would be okay with it.
I understand your point... we don't technically have a 2nd pairing D anywhere if we send Staal away.
I would trade Nash straight up for Spezza, but I don't know that Ottawa would do it. Buy out Richards. Re-sign everyone else unless their demands are unreasonable. If we think Staal isn't going to re-sign in 2015, trade him now.
Whatever you think of Spezza at this point in his career, he's an upgrade over Richards and won't be a cap problem down the road. Both he and MSL would have 1 year left on their contracts and we can mostly keep the team in tact for another run.
I would do Nash for Spezza, but I'm not sure the Sens or Nash approve that trade.. Then again, if we're serious about winning a cup, then this is the right move... we need center depth right now...
Personally, I think Eric Staal is a better option than Jason Spezza, but that's just my speculation
At the end of the day the only trade chip the Rangers really have right now is Staal.
Maybe they could dump Nash but that would be selling for pennies on the dollar and would not improve next year's team. Aka it's not happening. Limited picks to trade this year or next. Miller, Fast, Lindberg, Mac don't have a ton of value.
And the UFA market is slim pickings this year. It is going to be very difficult for this team to come to camp with a better roster than they have now. So many FAs, little space, poor UFA class, limited trade chips. I would a surprised if there was much turnover beyond Richards and some bargain hunting.
Nash will have value NEXT DEADLINE if he gets somewhat back to his regular game pre-concussion. That's probably Sather's best move at this point. Trading him before the start of this season is selling very, very low, and no GM will pay for that. He'll be more valuable next deadline when he's got 25 goals under his belt.
As for the UFA market, the only guy's I'd consider is Stastny (not really a fan of signing him anyway), Derek Roy, or Mikhail Grabovski, and even then those guys are #2 Centerman at most
If we're serious about a #1 Centermen, as well as another good playoff run (3rd round or better), our best trade chips are (in order of value):
Nash (only if traded around the 2015 Trade Deadline)
Staal (Traded before December)
Girardi (Traded at any time)
J. Moore (Traded at any time)
But trading even one of those away depends on who comes into camp and blows the Rangers brass away, who requests to be traded, and who becomes an option to be traded in... Regardless, Center Depth is a serious issue, and Miller is the most reachable option... If Nash goes, who takes his RW spot? I haven't seen any wonderful RW'ers on the UFA market..
As for Trading Staal, it's dependent on what was said here:
I'd consider dealing Staal if Stralman would re-up. He fits the system with his skating better currently.
It's either Stralman or Staal. Not both. Both are solid.... I like Stralman's ability to step up... I like Staal's ability to shut forwards down.... but if one absolutely has to go, Staal will not only net the bigger return, but also could free up more cap space right now, save us a huge contract going forward (Stralman should be around 4.2M, Staal could easily get 6M), all while allowing us to take a minimal hit on defense