Speculation: 2014 - 2015 New York Rangers :: Roster building / proposal thread Part II

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sign Kreider, sign Zucc. Stick them on a line and let them become super stars together
 
Listen, I think what it really boils down to, for JT, is if he takes control of his opportunity.

For him to be a successful player in this league, he needs to approach every thing he does in a different manner.

My friend is best friends with Kreider, she talked to JT two years ago. I'm pretty sure she used the words "really immature" to describe JT. He was 18 at the time, right about to turn 19.

He's only 21 years old, for some people it takes longer to learn how to be a good professional.

In any event, that needs to happen for him to be successful.

But why I wouldn't trade Miller for Eakin is because to me, one thing seems rather transparent. Miller has a higher offensive ceiling and I'm basing that on previous comparable statistics.

Anyone who's watched Miller at the pro level and, especially, in the AHL can see that this is spot on. It's been true since I first started watching him. He has a ton of talent and can easily become a two-way, physical, scoring center. But he needs to get his head out of his ass. His talent and his "swagger" has carried him for so long against inferior competition that he has learned some bad habits. It works as high as the AHL, but it is what has led to benchings and demotions in the NHL.

By no means do I want him to lose his offensive cockiness - honestly, I wish he could give a little to Kreider - but he has to temper it and learn to process the larger picture a little more. He doesn't make egregious Kristo-esque turnovers, but he gets himself caught and misses the right play because he's trying to make the aggressive one way, way too often. Just a little growing up and we've got ourselves a really good player. The only question is whether or not he'll ever will. For our sake, I hope so.
 
So why can Miller who hasn't proven he can be an effective 3C at the NHL have a better shot at being a top-6 center one day than Eakin?

I'm not discounting your logic. I'd just like more than what you've provided.

I've also watched Eakin quite a bit and came away a little more impressed.

Bottom 6 skillset doesn't mean bad.

I also usually come away impressed with Eakin, he has magnificent speed and hustle, a player anyone would love to have.

Because Miller has more potential, and Eakin's just not that talented in my opinion? I don't know what you want me to tell you. Miller's got a better frame that he can use more to his advantage, more high end talent in his shooting and passing than Eakin has, just a better overall offensive skillset.

And Miller didn't prove he can't do anything at the NHL level, to be honest.

I like what Tawnos said. This is the offseason for Miller. He's had two full years learning the pro game, he really took the step forward you want to see at the lower level, etc.
 
Anyone know if Brad Marchand has ever played center? His game seems suited for it, and I think he'd adjust to it quite nicely with the right linemates.

Boston needs to move a contract like his to alleviate some cap pressure. It's doubtful they'd want to deal him to us (at least we're not in the same division). Perhaps something like...

Brad Marchand for J.T. Miller, Jesper Fast, and Kevin Klein


Kreider Stepan St. Louis
Nash Brassard Zuccarello
Hagelin Marchand Stempniak
Glass Moore Lombardi/Lindberg

McDonagh Girardi
Staal Boyle
Moore McIlrath/Allen

Lundqvist
Talbot
 
Anyone know if Brad Marchand has ever played center? His game seems suited for it, and I think he'd adjust to it quite nicely with the right linemates.

Boston needs to move a contract like his to alleviate some cap pressure. It's doubtful they'd want to deal him to us (at least we're not in the same division). Perhaps something like...

Brad Marchand for J.T. Miller, Jesper Fast, and Kevin Klein


Kreider Stepan St. Louis
Nash Brassard Zuccarello
Hagelin Marchand Stempniak
Glass Moore Lombardi/Lindberg

McDonagh Girardi
Staal Boyle
Moore McIlrath/Allen

Lundqvist
Talbot

I like Brad Marchand a whole lot. That being said he's not a guy I give a good steady d-man + 2 young up and coming top 9 forwards for. Five years down the line and either Miller and/or Fast on their own might be equal or better than Marchand. I especially think that of Miller. The trade you're suggesting is really only likely to have an immediate benefit. Past another year or so I don't think it will be to our benefit any longer. Marchand is not an old guy but the Rangers need to hang on to some of their young guys at least until we see how we see the next wave of younger players turn out.
 
Anyone know if Brad Marchand has ever played center? His game seems suited for it, and I think he'd adjust to it quite nicely with the right linemates.

Boston needs to move a contract like his to alleviate some cap pressure. It's doubtful they'd want to deal him to us (at least we're not in the same division). Perhaps something like...

Brad Marchand for J.T. Miller, Jesper Fast, and Kevin Klein


Kreider Stepan St. Louis
Nash Brassard Zuccarello
Hagelin Marchand Stempniak
Glass Moore Lombardi/Lindberg

McDonagh Girardi
Staal Boyle
Moore McIlrath/Allen

Lundqvist
Talbot

so you'd offer a package like that for Marchand which is bad enough but to want to acquire him and switch him to a position you have no idea if he's ever played in his life is headscratching.
 
so you'd offer a package like that for Marchand which is bad enough but to want to acquire him and switch him to a position you have no idea if he's ever played in his life is headscratching.

Read the post.

I asked if anyone knows if he played center in juniors or anywhere during his career.

The rest of the post hinges on that possibility.
 
Anyone who's watched Miller at the pro level and, especially, in the AHL can see that this is spot on. It's been true since I first started watching him. He has a ton of talent and can easily become a two-way, physical, scoring center. But he needs to get his head out of his ass. His talent and his "swagger" has carried him for so long against inferior competition that he has learned some bad habits. It works as high as the AHL, but it is what has led to benchings and demotions in the NHL.

By no means do I want him to lose his offensive cockiness - honestly, I wish he could give a little to Kreider - but he has to temper it and learn to process the larger picture a little more. He doesn't make egregious Kristo-esque turnovers, but he gets himself caught and misses the right play because he's trying to make the aggressive one way, way too often. Just a little growing up and we've got ourselves a really good player. The only question is whether or not he'll ever will. For our sake, I hope so.

I'll tell you one thing. A lot of guys never learn how to be "good" professionals. Our locker room of successful and decorated vets provides him irreplaceable resources for him to develop into a better professional.

He needs to want it, but he'll have excellent help along the way. Great team mates that have experienced nearly everything on their way to being successful NHL'ers. Great coaching staff. It's certainly in JT's hands now.
 
Anyone know if Brad Marchand has ever played center? His game seems suited for it, and I think he'd adjust to it quite nicely with the right linemates.

Boston needs to move a contract like his to alleviate some cap pressure. It's doubtful they'd want to deal him to us (at least we're not in the same division). Perhaps something like...

Brad Marchand for J.T. Miller, Jesper Fast, and Kevin Klein


Kreider Stepan St. Louis
Nash Brassard Zuccarello
Hagelin Marchand Stempniak
Glass Moore Lombardi/Lindberg

McDonagh Girardi
Staal Boyle
Moore McIlrath/Allen

Lundqvist
Talbot

I like Marchand, but WOW that's a lot to give up for a small 2nd liner
 
Anyone know if Brad Marchand has ever played center? His game seems suited for it, and I think he'd adjust to it quite nicely with the right linemates.

Boston needs to move a contract like his to alleviate some cap pressure. It's doubtful they'd want to deal him to us (at least we're not in the same division). Perhaps something like...

Brad Marchand for J.T. Miller, Jesper Fast, and Kevin Klein


Kreider Stepan St. Louis
Nash Brassard Zuccarello
Hagelin Marchand Stempniak
Glass Moore Lombardi/Lindberg

McDonagh Girardi
Staal Boyle
Moore McIlrath/Allen

Lundqvist
Talbot

Boston has too many dmen already. Why would they want Klein?
 
Question:

When a team retains money, is that team retaining only cap space or cap space AND actual dollars?
 
We cannot afford to make 3 for 1 trades. Just plain stupidity.

Judging on how Sather usually operates, he will make a 3 for 1 trade... we will be recouping some assets in place of 1.

We traded assets for Nash, following big trade was Gaborik to CBJ.

We cash strapped the team with Drury, Gomez, and Redden. Following Sather move was to trade Gomez for 3 parts.

Looking at the guys who can provide this:

Staal, Nash, Girardi.

Eventually, Sather will make a 3 for 1 move, adding depth to the Rangers rather than trading it away for stardom. It's how he operates after strapping the team financially or depleting the farm.
 
Judging on how Sather usually operates, he will make a 3 for 1 trade... we will be recouping some assets in place of 1.

We traded assets for Nash, following big trade was Gaborik to CBJ.

We cash strapped the team with Drury, Gomez, and Redden. Following Sather move was to trade Gomez for 3 parts.

Looking at the guys who can provide this:

Staal, Nash, Girardi.

Eventually, Sather will make a 3 for 1 move, adding depth to the Rangers rather than trading it away for stardom. It's how he operates after strapping the team financially or depleting the farm.

trading 1 for 3 happens if the season is a disaster. Barring, that, don't expect it.
 
Miller isn't a finished product. Kreider isn't a finished product. The Rangers learned to live with Kreider's mistakes. They need to live with Miller's mistakes. The veteran players make mistakes and their ice time isn't reduced. He is a center. He is cheap. Even if he has a good year, he will still be cheap in his next contract without arbitration rights. Look at the Rangers up for contracts next July. Staal will be the best group 3 D on the market. St. Louis. Stepan and Hagelin are arbitration eligible. Hagelin will be one year away from group 3. cap is going up but how much? More TV money. 4 fewer outdoor games. Canadian dollar.
 
trading 1 for 3 happens if the season is a disaster. Barring, that, don't expect it.

Perhaps. I don't think Sather will let Staal walk away for nothing if contract negotiations stall.
 
Brad Richards was gifted offensive zone starts all year. Defensively he was lacking. He was a good PP player. I am confused as to why Miller has to be some defensive whiz.

Time to start developing some of these younger guys. Fast. Lindberg. Miller. Kristo. Decide who is in the plans of the team/organization and let them grow.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Ad