Prospect Info: 2024 Round 1, #10 Overall - LD Anton Silayev

[Nubmer6]

Devils Draft Anton Silayev 10th Overall - The Hockey Writers New Jersey Devils Latest News, Analysis & More

With the 10th pick of the 2024 NHL Entry Draft, the New Jersey Devils have selected Anton Silayev from Torpedo Nizhny Novgorod of the KHL.

thehockeywriters.com

Anton Silayev - 2024 NHL Draft Prospect Profile - The Hockey Writers NHL Entry Draft Latest News, Analysis & More

Anton Silayev is a massive defensive defenseman who had a very successful draft year in the KHL this season.

thehockeywriters.com

Meet Anton Silayev, the Devils' No. 10 pick in 2024 NHL Draft

Here is everything fans need to know about Anton Silayev, who recently went to the Devils with the No. 10 pick in the 2024 NHL Draft.

clutchpoints.com

Click to read more...

 

[CalamityX23]

Welcome to Jersey!

 

[evnted]

(shamelessly reposting this from the main thread lol)

i like this pick. not quite my best available, but i think a lot of silayev's offensive upside concerns and puck skill issues are less of a problem on a blue line that already has luke and nemo on it. we talk all the time about wanting to add true shutdown guys, well, here he is. his mobility at 6'7" is rare and he'll be hyper-coveted come playoff time

larionov has done a good job w him and artamonov in torpedo, and i expect that to continue. good team composition pairing even if i technically preferred a dickinson or buium pick more. my 9th ranked prospect

full report later

 

[Cheddabombs]

 

[Nubmer6]

(shamelessly reposting this from the main thread lol)

i like this pick. not quite my best available, but i think a lot of silayev's offensive upside concerns and puck skill issues are less of a problem on a blue line that already has luke and nemo on it. we talk all the time about wanting to add true shutdown guys, well, here he is. his mobility at 6'7" is rare and he'll be hyper-coveted come playoff time

larionov has done a good job w him and artamonov in torpedo, and i expect that to continue. good team composition pairing even if i technically preferred a dickinson or buium pick more. my 9th ranked prospect

full report later

I clamor for a shutdown guy, but at the same time I feel they're available in the 2nd and 3rd round.

 

[Emperoreddy]

Does read like he had a lot of development to still do, but has the tools.

 

[Darkauron]

Not a fan of pick and im usually very supportive. Much rather wanted Buium , Nygard or Dickinson.

 

[evnted]

I clamor for a shutdown guy, but at the same time I feel they're available in the 2nd and 3rd round.

thats completely fair, but not at his size and with his skating ability. those always go high because theyre so coveted. im honestly surprised he made it to 10 even if he wasnt the exact top of my board

given how the board shook out, LD was the correct route to take. i liked dickinson more, but hes not the slam dunk defensive projection silayev is. he also has some puck management issues just not to the same degree. i liked buium more too, but stylistically i was always skeptical he was a match for our blue line

we have luke, we have nemo. what we dont have, or didnt have until now, was a truly elite play stopper, which is what silayev is. this pick is a huge win for team composition

one note (and i dont wanna run too long its gonna take away from my bigger report lol) is he played a lot of RD this year as a left shot defender. that makes the passing game hard. he also almost assuredly struggled with fatigue by the end of the season. both of these factors quite likely have some influence on his issues, particularly down the stretch

 

[Triumph]

I clamor for a shutdown guy, but at the same time I feel they're available in the 2nd and 3rd round.

They certainly are, but you won't find anyone who's playing significant minutes in the KHL there. That's what sells me on the pick, players his age just don't play in that league.

 

[MasterofGrond]

I think he has the opportunity to be a really special defender.

Will he be? Who knows.

 

[Unknown Caller]

Fitz is currently obsessed with size, physicality, "violence" and being harder to play against. Obvious this was going to be Silayev or Dickinson even though Buium and probably Helenius were the best players on the board.

I don't think he's going to be Hedman. Could he be a modern day Chara? Possibly.

 

[Normal Devil]

Didn't see a mock draft with him any lower than #8 .. several had him at #3. Also rated at best athlete in the draft on The Athletic.

 

[britdevil]

 

[Bleedred]

So this pick is fine? I have no opinion yet. I know nothing about him.

 

[Alex NJD]

Honestly lukewarm on the pick. Felt the other two LHD have a much better chance to be in the lineup opening night 2025. But this is a guy we didn't even discuss because it seemed like no chance he was ever falling to us. If he hits his ceiling our d core will be INSANE.

Also my dad loves the pick. Polish immigrant who came over during the 80s always loves Russian players, doesn't have a team but if he did it'd be the Rags . Showed him a video and he's saying he was grown in a Russian lab

"Too fast for guy so big" - my dad

 

[evnted]

Fitz is currently obsessed with size, physicality, "violence" and being harder to play against. Obvious this was going to be Silayev or Dickinson even though Buium and probably Helenius were the best players on the board.

I don't think he's going to be Hedman. Could he be a modern day Chara? Possibly.

definitely not hedman, and its a disservice to the kid that the comp is even still floating around. but if things break right, something more in the chara mold could absolutely be in play. he has his issues, im not glossing over them because hes our pick, but youd be hard pressed to find a more dominant shutdown presence coming out of the draft than him

 

[Emperoreddy]

The insane size and the fact he is apparently a really good skater are big upsides.

And yeah the amount of KHL games he has at 17 years old is impressive.

 

[Triumph]

Also drafting for need gets a bad rap around here. You should not draft for need, but you should also not draft where you have a massive surplus already. The instant the Devils select Buium, it is a countdown to which of him or Casey is traded and when.

 

[Lou Bloom]

Absolutely love this pick, didn't even entertain the idea that he'd be available at 10th. He was easily the BPA for me at the pick and also was the best fit in this draft for what the Devils need more of (Big, Athletic, Defense minded players). Couldn't draw up a better fit to have long term next to Luke and Nemec.

 

[NJDevs26]

I don’t get why people hate this pick - so he’s gotta stay in Russia for two years, nobody we picked here was likely to play this or next year anyway.

 

[Satans Hockey]

I hope the guy I don't know eventually does well.

 

[Devils731]

Watching some of the video of Silayev and he is so comfortable skating for a guy his size.

You can see why some people would fall in love with a guy with his wingspan who can comfortable skate and pivot in all 4 directions. He may just swallow up other team’s offense.

 

[NJDevs26]

So this pick is fine? I have no opinion yet. I know nothing about him.

Sounds like there were a ton of d-men available and Fitz went for the guy with potential unicorn upside as opposed to safer, more offensive D.

 

[ZachaFlockaFlame]

Great pick, we legit have our top 4 of the future set in stone if Silayev is an NHLer.

Silyaev-Nemec
Luke-Anyone (lmao)

You could also put Silayev with Casey and it would probably work as well. This board can't complain how soft Siegs and pine for Bahl like it did and then hate this pick. He'll be an NHLer at the worst and his ceiling is tremendous as a shutdown D

 

[Hisch13r]

YESSSSSS I f***ing love this guy. Cannot believe he made it to 10. Even without the offense ever coming he should at least be a #3 elite shutdown D if not top pair caliber and if that offense ever comes…. Watch the f*** out

Great pick, we legit have our top 4 of the future set in stone if Silayev is an NHLer.

Silyaev-Nemec
Luke-Anyone (lmao)

You could also put Silayev with Casey and it would probably work as well. This board can't complain how soft Siegs and pin for Bahl like it did and then hate this pick. He'll be an NHLer at the worst and his ceiling is tremendous as a shutdown D

I doubt it happens but my hope was always D at 10 and Casey deal for McGroarty. I’d also still probably go Luke-Nemec. The shit they did together this year as 20 year olds was silly. They had like a 65% xG