overpass
Registered User
- Jun 7, 2007
- 5,416
- 3,369
In 1958, Sport Magazine polled 70 sports writers and commentators from across the United States and Canada to choose an all-time, all-star NHL hockey team, providing a snapshot of the general opinion on the all-time greats.
I haven't seen the article itself that Sport published. It was in their March 1958 issue, with baseball pitcher Lew Burdette on the cover. If anyone has access to the issue, it would be interesting to get more details.
Here's a writeup (in French) on the team from Parlons Sports, Feb 8 1958
G: Bill Durnan
D: Eddie Shore
D: Doug Harvey
LW: Gordie Howe
C: Howie Morenz
RW: Maurice Richard
The article in Parlons Sports has a few notes about the approximate vote totals.
Maurice Richard received the most votes, "almost 25% more than any of his teammates on this all-time all-star team," and "came very close to being chosen unanimously."
Howie Morenz was "easily chosen at the centre position."
Gordie Howe was chosen over Ted Lindsay at LW, who "put up a fierce fight with his former teammate".
Eddie Shore "earned the most votes among the defense players".
Doug Harvey "had no difficulty earning a position on the blueline alongside Eddie Shore."
No mention was made of Durnan's vote totals or competition.
La Patrie, Feb 2, 1958, also references Sport's team.
Phil Seguin of La Patrie explains that two right wingers were chosen because voters were not required to specify the position of the wings. So maybe some just picked the two best wingers, and others preferred to pick a LW and an RW? I have a hard time believing Lindsay would be close behind Howe if position was really not a consideration.
La Patrie also lists other stars who received votes.
Wingers Ted Lindsay, Bill Cook, Harvey Jackson, Aurele Joliat,
Goalies Frank Brimsek, Terry Sawchuk, Chuck Gardiner, Turk Broda, Roy Worters, George Hainsworth
Defenders Ching Johnson, Red Kelly, King Clancy
Centres Milt Schmidt, Bill Cowley, Syl Apps, and Jean Beliveau
It looks like the voters didn't go back to pre-consolidation hockey, except for players like Morenz, Cook, and Clancy who still played most of their careers after 1926. No mention of Nighbor, Taylor, Lalonde, or Cleghorn. Seguin wrote that this team of stars "will probably not satisfy the veterans, but even those who claim the best hockey was played 40 years ago must admit that this club would be difficult to beat in any era of hockey."
I haven't seen the article itself that Sport published. It was in their March 1958 issue, with baseball pitcher Lew Burdette on the cover. If anyone has access to the issue, it would be interesting to get more details.
Here's a writeup (in French) on the team from Parlons Sports, Feb 8 1958
G: Bill Durnan
D: Eddie Shore
D: Doug Harvey
LW: Gordie Howe
C: Howie Morenz
RW: Maurice Richard
The article in Parlons Sports has a few notes about the approximate vote totals.
Maurice Richard received the most votes, "almost 25% more than any of his teammates on this all-time all-star team," and "came very close to being chosen unanimously."
Howie Morenz was "easily chosen at the centre position."
Gordie Howe was chosen over Ted Lindsay at LW, who "put up a fierce fight with his former teammate".
Eddie Shore "earned the most votes among the defense players".
Doug Harvey "had no difficulty earning a position on the blueline alongside Eddie Shore."
No mention was made of Durnan's vote totals or competition.
La Patrie, Feb 2, 1958, also references Sport's team.
Phil Seguin of La Patrie explains that two right wingers were chosen because voters were not required to specify the position of the wings. So maybe some just picked the two best wingers, and others preferred to pick a LW and an RW? I have a hard time believing Lindsay would be close behind Howe if position was really not a consideration.
La Patrie also lists other stars who received votes.
Wingers Ted Lindsay, Bill Cook, Harvey Jackson, Aurele Joliat,
Goalies Frank Brimsek, Terry Sawchuk, Chuck Gardiner, Turk Broda, Roy Worters, George Hainsworth
Defenders Ching Johnson, Red Kelly, King Clancy
Centres Milt Schmidt, Bill Cowley, Syl Apps, and Jean Beliveau
It looks like the voters didn't go back to pre-consolidation hockey, except for players like Morenz, Cook, and Clancy who still played most of their careers after 1926. No mention of Nighbor, Taylor, Lalonde, or Cleghorn. Seguin wrote that this team of stars "will probably not satisfy the veterans, but even those who claim the best hockey was played 40 years ago must admit that this club would be difficult to beat in any era of hockey."
Last edited: